4 ms·
However, drug companies spend more on advertising than research which should give you some ideas for savings. Right. Because all they have to do is offer the
by mhb 13y ago
However, drug companies spend more on advertising than research which should give you some ideas for savings.
Right. Because all they have to do is offer the drug in an app store and the world will beat a path to their door.
- mikeyouse 13y agoIt's medicine not some trivial app. If you have Hepatitis C, your doctor will prescribe you this drug. Allowing direct-to-consumer marketing corrupts patients and allowing drug companies to lavish doctors with food / drink / entertainment corrupts physicians. I grew up in a medical household, you wouldn't believe the shit these companies do to curry favor. Some of it has been limited but much of it still continues.
- rayiner 13y agoPeople argue against creating a profit motive by saying "it's medicine, not a trivial app," and then wonder why all the bright kids at Stanford go off to build trivial apps instead of curing diseases. There are lots of things that should be in the public sector, but "it's too important" is a bad criteria to use. Because then all the money will be in doing things that are unimportant.
- mikeyouse 13y agoPeople argue against creating a profit motive by saying "it's medicine, not a trivial app," What in the world does that have to do with advertising? There are literally two countries in the world that permit direct-to-consumer advertising. It is strictly and explicitly banned by the European Union. Somehow I don't think it's harmed the profit motive at Bayer, Roche (who were profitable enough to buy one of the most profitable US pharmaceutical companies), GSK, Novartis, Sanofi, etc. etc. The point isn't that drug companies shouldn't make money, they clearly should. At one point, 97% of the people on earth receiving treatment for AIDS were taking drugs developed by the Chief Scientist that also developed this Hepatitis breakthrough. He deserves to be a billionaire dozens of times over. The point is that it's disingenuous to try to justify the high costs to consumers by blaming R&D spending when the R&D budgets are smaller than their advertising budgets. Pharma advertising is indefensible in nearly all cases. We have actual scientific and cost data that shows, for instance, that before Lipitor was generic, Crestor was more effective at treating high LDLs for a lower cost.[2] No amount of Pfizer sponsorship will change this fact. Allowing them to blanket the air waves and bribe doctors to get Lipitor on the formulary instead of Crestor is an ethical failing we are all responsible for. If Pfizer wants to change people's minds about Lipitor, their advertising should take the form of a sponsored independent study that shows better outcomes for patients on Lipitor. Or they could compete on price. This is how a sensible pharma market would operate. [1] - http://europa.eu/legislation_summaries/other/l21143_en.htm http://europa.eu/legislation_summaries/other/l21143_en.htm [2] - http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18489494 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18489494
- FireBeyond 13y agoHere's a clue: There is only one country in the world where the advertising of prescription medicine to the layperson is allowed. Can you name it? For bonus points, can you name why?
- Houshalter 13y agoThough to defend advertisement a little, it does inform people that there is a treatment for their condition and to go to a doctor.
- FireBeyond 13y agoPerhaps. A more realistic view is that "if something is paining or inconveniencing you to the point of discomfort, then you should talk to your doctor". In amongst all the specific ads (which actually, to my mind, are not necessarily a bad thing - think of the 'is drug X not helping with your condition? Recent studies have shown that adding drug B to your existing regime may improve efficiency'), you get oh-so-generic ads. "Feeling 'low energy'? X may be able to help. Ask your doctor if X is right for you!" These days, you can largely assume that most conditions are manageable, if not treatable and that your quality of life should be the driver, not advertising incentivizing you to go to the doctor (and giving you a helpful laundry list of other symptoms that you may or may not have to "aid" the "diagnosis" most convenient to the manufacturer).
- Houshalter 13y agoIt's not that simple. People with allergies might not know that there is a better medication available. People with restless leg syndrome may just think it's some weird thing unique to them. Depression is a really big one to get people to go to a doctor for. Notice there aren't any commercials for stuff like antibiotics. People are already going to a doctor when they have an infection and other serious conditions. They advertise the stuff that needs advertisement. If it didn't work they wouldn't do it.
- Retric 13y ago