5 ms·
Slightly off-topic, but there is a curious situation in the UK where people doing one course at one university seem to have a disproportionate amount of power:
by arethuza 13y ago
Slightly off-topic, but there is a curious situation in the UK where people doing one course at one university seem to have a disproportionate amount of power:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-11136511 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-11136511
[NB I'm not implying that this is a bad, or indeed a good, thing - just I've started paying much more attention to university courses now that my son is in his mid teens!]
- thaumasiotes 13y agoSomehow, I can't be too surprised that the top-level politicians are disproportionately drawn from those who majored in politics at the country's best university. (Where are you from? To my (US English) ears, a "course" is a class, the kind of thing that might happen every mon/wed/fri in the afternoons, but the article you link is clearly talking about a "major" (as in "I majored in politics & economics"). They refer to it as a "degree", which is also, to me, completely normal use ("my degree was in politics & economics").)
- arethuza 13y agoWell, to this Scot "course" ~= "degree". We don't have (or at didn't used to have) any like majors and, thankfully, nothing like the GPA system either.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- thaumasiotes 13y agoI don't understand how you think that differs from the US system. As far as I can tell, you're using a different word for the exact same system, and telling me it's different because the name is different. I majored in math. The level of specificity above that (i.e. less specific) is that my university was UCSC. The level below would be a list of the actual classes I took. At a US university, you apply to a major (often they can reject you), and the major (usually) requires a set of courses, possibly among other requirements. Meet the requirements and you get a certificate saying "Bachelor of (Arts / Science / Music / whatever) in (history / math / computer and information science / amateur football / sociology / whatever)". That first parenthesized group is the name of the degree itself; the second group is your major. So continuing with the example of myself, my degree would say "Bachelor of Arts in Mathematics". There are complications. For example, you can get more than one major by fulfilling the requirements of both (I simplified above. This is what I did). You can get a "minor" by meeting a lesser list of requirements which is felt not to indicate that you're as "fully qualified" as someone who majored in that field. But overwhelmingly, as practiced, the system is: you apply to the major, they tell you what courses to take, and you take those courses. edit: For the sake of completeness, I should probably point out: in US usage, "major" unambiguously refers to your (undergraduate) field of study. "Degree" can be used to refer to the same math-chemistry-history-anthropology axis, but can also be used to refer to the prestige axis of bachelor's-master's-doctorate, which I referred to above as the "name of the degree itself".
- arethuza 13y agoThis article seems to give a view of the UK system from a US perspective (mostly English, the Scottish education system is different but closer to the English that the US, I suspect): http://www.education.com/reference/article/british-university-study-abroad-england/ http://www.education.com/reference/article/british-universit... Out of interest, when does the US school system have kids specializing in particular areas? In Scotland it's ~14 - which I think is a bit young...
- thaumasiotes 13y agoHeh. Depends on your school, but as a "standard" thing, in their third year of college, when they'd be about 20 years old. You can apply to a specialized school, and you can apply directly to particular majors at unspecialized schools, but the generic system is that you come in undeclared and declare a major by year 3. Specializing kids before college is hugely politically sensitive, probably off the table for a long time into the future. (thoughts from other Americans are welcome)
- NickPollard 13y agoIn the UK most universities don't really have the concept of 'major' and 'minor' - you simple have your degree, which might involve you doing other learning around the subject. In this context, 'degree' and 'course' are often used interchangeably. 'Degree Course' in UK English is perhaps equivalent to 'Degree Program' in US. To be perhaps more pedantic, your 'degree' might be the subject ('I have a Degree in Computer Science'), whereas your course would be the particular program ('I took the University of Bristol's Computer Science course'). In this instance, the commentor is referring to not just any PPE Degree qualification, but the PPE Course at Oxford.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoI find your comment somewhat confusing. As I read it, you say that your 'degree' is the subject (this is also true in the US; 'degree' can be used with exactly the same semantics as 'major') and the 'course' refers to the university you studied at. But the comment I replied to refers specifically to "one course at one university", which implies that those are separate dimensions of variation; the same course might exist at different universities. In US usage, that's not surprising; lots of colleges have e.g. a "remedial algebra" course. If 'course' refers to the subject, that's also not surprising; lots of colleges will let you earn a degree in math (though not, one hopes, if you had to take remedial algebra). But if a 'course' is defined by the university that houses it, it cannot possibly exist at more than one university. My main point is that it's not even mildly surprising that students from Oxford should be disproportionately present in the UK government or anywhere else of significance. I have a feeling that, as important as the effect of a PPE degree may be, the effect of an Oxford degree is much stronger. My minor point was that even after considering Oxford vs. no-name, it's not particularly surprising to see people with politics degrees going into politics.
- arethuza 13y agoI think it's part of the concern that our politicians (at least from the main 2 parties) are basically all the same but are only differentiated by the color of badges they wear. Historically we had a bit more diversity.