3 ms·
But does "opposing speech" have to include getting someone fired for something they did 6 years ago? Opposing speech in an open democratic society shouldn't hav
by stcredzero 13y ago
But does "opposing speech" have to include getting someone fired for something they did 6 years ago? Opposing speech in an open democratic society shouldn't have the effect of oppressing the speech of others -- even if such actions are technically legal. Otherwise, it becomes the "open democratic society for the people whose opinions I like."
Using one's right to free speech to oppose bigoted speech is not impeding anybody's rights.
This is technically true, but the way such an idea was applied in this case lacks something of the spirit of free speech in a truly tolerant and open society.
- ChrisGaudreau 13y agoWell, he didn't say he regrets his actions from 6 years ago. It's kind of like adultery. If I cheated on you 6 years ago but never apologized for it or expressed regret for it, should you feel comfortable with me today? What if I wasn't clear about whether I believe adultery is okay? What if I wasn't clear about whether I am still committing adultery? The beliefs he holds are still current, as far as anyone can tell. If they aren't, I'm sure he would have said so. This is technically true, but the way such an idea was applied in this case lacks something of the spirit of free speech in a truly tolerant and open society. Yeah, some gay rights activists were a bit over the top and maybe should try a bit harder to understand the other side. But it is an emotional issue. If I feel that somebody is trying to use the might of the government to take away my rights, it's going to be difficult to sympathize with and understand why they would do that.