3 ms·
Finding isolated in-group proponents of beliefs typically despised by that group is never hard (in fact, I'd argue that such proponents occur regularly but with
by jonahx 13y ago
Finding isolated in-group proponents of beliefs typically despised by that group is never hard (in fact, I'd argue that such proponents occur regularly but with low probability), so I don't find this argument compelling.
Also, the fact remains that the argument imo, no matter who is making it, is an exercise in word play and sophistry.
- AndrewBissell 13y agoObviously you're free to disagree with arguments like Rauch's, but calling his writing "word play and sophistry" just shows that you haven't actually examined it.
- jonahx 13y agoYou said he "makes almost exactly this argument," referring to the one in my OP -- so my comments were in reference to that argument and not his work.