23 ms·
Consumer Safety Notice for Nest Protect: Smoke and CO Alarm
- klinskyc 13y agoI'm really wondering what unique circumstances could cause this. Flapping your arms out of fear when you see a fire?
- dm2 13y agoProbably running/walking past the smoke alarm. There's a fine line between too sensitive and not sensitive enough. If I burn something while cooking I do NOT want the smoke detector to go off (it's loud), and the Wave feature takes 3 or 4 seconds before it registers. Plus there are a lot of configurations to account for. Some people put the units on the walls while others on the ceiling. The Nest has to guess how far away people are when the walk by and how far people will be when they wave. Putting them on the ceiling with 10+ foot ceilings verses putting one on the wall in a small hallway will require different sensitivities for the Wave feature. If you have multiple Nest Protects then they will all go off when one detects smoke or carbon monoxide, so the Wave bug won't matter too much.
- michaelt 13y agoAny by all accounts the sensors are ultrasound - cost effective, but not a famously high resolution sensing mechanism. [1] http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Nest+Protect+Teardown/20057#s55891 http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Nest+Protect+Teardown/20057#s...
- dm2 13y agoI think there are also a couple of other sensors which also help detect movement and waving. They call them "occupancy" and "activity" sensors. http://support.nest.com/article/Learn-more-about-the-Nest-Protect-sensors http://support.nest.com/article/Learn-more-about-the-Nest-Pr...
- dsl 13y agoThe movement of smoke can trigger motion sensors. I believe they tried to account for this by also using a heat sensor, but if the smoke from the fire was within the threshold for "body heat" it could falsely assume a person is waving at it.
- xwowsersx 13y agoKind of awesome that this will, at least temporarily, be addressed via a software update assuming that you're nest is connected to a nest account via wifi. Puts me at ease.
- ars 13y agoHow do you know it will be a software fix? (Other than just disabling the feature.) I would assume they would use a new sensor to do a more discriminating job of detecting the motion.
- dm2 13y agoI strongly doubt they will replace the sensors, maybe it's influence the hardware in a 2nd version but they have plenty of sensors in the current Nest protect. It's more of a matter of better measuring the room to allow the unit to guess when someone is walking by and when someone is standing in front of the unit and waving. The sensors are almost working perfectly. Because this device is relied upon to save peoples lives and there are also legal repercussions to allowing a known bug, they have to make sure that the waving and walking can be distinguished 100% of the time. Only in a very rare situation (like having the unit at shoulder level or in a hallways with a very low ceiling combined with multiple people running past it) would the unit malfunction.
- erichurkman 13y agoVery awesome and direct response by Nest. Kudos. Oftentimes, recalls or other safety notices do not adequately spell out specific issues, merely allude to a vague "safety issue." Transparency is good.
- dfc 13y ago> we observed a unique combination of circumstances that caused us to > question whether the Nest Wave could be unintentionally activated. You think that counts as "spelling out specific issues"? That is not very transparent to me. Compare Nest's "specifics" with cperciva's response to a security bug in tarsnap: http://www.daemonology.net/blog/2011-01-18-tarsnap-critical-security-bug.html http://www.daemonology.net/blog/2011-01-18-tarsnap-critical-...
- erichurkman 13y agoFair enough, but for a consumer product, it's specific at least from the recalls and safety warnings I've been exposed to as a consumer (car recalls, child safety products, food, etc).
- dfc 13y agoExcerpt from most recent smoke alarm recall from CPSC: > In cooperation with the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission > (CPSC), Universal Security Instruments Inc., of Owings Mills, Md., is > voluntarily recalling about 34,000 smoke alarms. The smoke alarms can > fail to alarm when smoke or fire is present. A capacitor in the alarm > can burn out, releasing smoke and melting the cover. > Universal has received three reports of alarms failing, releasing > smoke. There has been one report of minor smoke damage to the wall of a > mobile home. No injuries have been reported. > Consumers can identify the recalled models by removing the alarm cover > from its base and looking for the manufacture date code and model > number. The smoke alarms are made of white plastic and have the > manufacture date code and model number imprinted on the back of the > alarm. https://www.cpsc.gov/en/Recalls/2000/CPSC-Universal-Security-Instruments-Announce-Recall-of-Smoke-Alarms/ https://www.cpsc.gov/en/Recalls/2000/CPSC-Universal-Security...
- lovemenot 13y agoNot waving, but choking. Many comments seem to be cutting more slack to this announcement than perhaps they would for other companies' products. Nest says they discovered this for themselves, which indicates that there is some measurable effect and it came up on post-release testing, months after release. Even though some people had been discussing a potential for exactly this scenario when the product features were first announced. Given this not unexpected error condition, Nest really should have run those same tests before releasing a product whose sole function is safety.
- greatsuccess 13y agoI have said many times before having bought NEST thermos and returned them on multiple occasions, these products DO NOT WORK, and are in fact a scam. I feel sorry for anyone who was bilked out of 3X times what a functioning device costs, and instead bought anything NEST produces. NEST is experimenting on its customer base with prototypes that are so poorly made as to beg the question, why havent regulators already stepped in?
- paulbaumgart 13y agoThings that were once unknown unknowns are always easy to point out in hindsight...
- lovemenot 13y agoThat is true in general. But in this case, what new information arose in the intervening months? There were no reported cases. Presumably the only thing that changed was that Nest's QA team eventually got around to doing what they were likely too busy to do before release. So this appears to be a classic case of trade-off between safety and time to market. I don't presume to correctly judge what would be the right values to plug into that equation, but I think it is fair to raise the question.
- uptown 13y agoIt could also be that their international expansion imposes different requirements, or doing it all under the supervision of Google's attorneys influenced the change.
- psadauskas 13y agoNot directly related to this issue, but I'm skeptical about the Nest Protect in general. It includes a CO detector, but CO is a denser-than-air gas, so stays near the floor while the Protect is mounted on the ceiling to detect smoke. Also, most CO detectors need to be replaced every few years because it wears out. Does this mean you have to buy a new $300 Nest Protect every 5 years? I have a Nest Thermostat that I love, but the Nest Protect doesn't seem nearly as cool or useful...
- electic 13y agoThat is very true. I have one of those older CO detectors and the instructions say it should be about a half a foot from the floor. I have no idea why the Nest CO detector wants it mounted 10 feet from the floor. Seems useless.
- mindslight 13y agoI believe any combo smoke+CO detector gets a pass to be up high. And isn't CO roughly the same weight as air anyway? That being said, I wouldn't trust Nest for a safety device where the goal is to have a simple reliable device, which contradicts having a wifi-connected uC in control. I don't know that they have the most engineering-minded culture either, based on the horrid input lag of their thermostat.
- conitpicker 13y agocarbon monoxide is less dense than air - according to wikipedia, density at room temperature is 1.15 kg/m³ for CO vs 1.275 kg/m³ for dry air. The nest protect retails for US$129.00 and has a service lifetime of 7 years. I recently checked all the smoke detectors at my parents house and found that they were all well past their 10-year replace-by date. (I replaced them, but not with Nest smoke detectors).
- sliverstorm 13y agoFun little tangent; I don't know how old my smoke detectors are, but the one by my front door gets a little test every now and again. One of my neighbors burns a fireplace on cold days. Invisible (but smellable) quantities of wood smoke pool under the rafters of my porch; the next morning, when I leave through the door, the smoke alarm always chirps for a moment! It amazed me how sensitive it is, when I first figured out what was going on.
- koenigdavidmj 13y agoIt's only a convenience feature anyway, it seems. Wave seems like the type of feature that should probably have some audio/light indication that it was invoked, though. Between this and Google, though, remind me never to name a product or feature Wave.
- dsl 13y agoA convenience feature that could have killed you. I know some engineers who design life critical safety systems for a living, and they all said something like this was going to happen when this product first came out. The example one of them gave was it was like a AED that could also let you recharge your phone, a moderately worthless feature that could only ever cause the failure of critical components.
- sliverstorm 13y agoOr perhaps a car airbag that can be disabled by spoken word
- dhughes 13y agoIt does, the light ring changes to indicate you're seen by the Nest Protect and when you wave to silence a smoke alarm the Nest Protect says "Smoke alarm hushed." http://support.nest.com/article/What-is-Nest-Wave-and-how-does-it-work http://support.nest.com/article/What-is-Nest-Wave-and-how-do...
- mkesper 13y agoSo what? If you're asleep and wave at the disturbing noise in half-sleep, that voice won't wake you up. GAME OVER. NO LIVES LEFT.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rdl 13y agoThe feature I really want in a smoke alarm is a "snooze" button which I can pre-register. I don't have a good fume hood over my kitchen stove, and the smoke detector is essentially in the kitchen (it's an open kitchen/living room), and the smoke alarm is on the kitchen side of the living room). I want a way to easily hit a button prior to cooking and not have any smoke alarm (but maybe a CO alarm still) for the next 15-30 minutes. As long as I'm still in the kitchen cooking, I don't need the smoke alarm to tell me if there's a fire. On the other hand, it's also entirely likely someone could step out of the kitchen for a few minutes, kitchen could catch fire, and bad stuff would ensue if the alarm were disabled. One option might be a pre-alarm for 5-10 seconds, during which you can snooze it. Unfortunately, if anyone ever died in a fire where 5-10 seconds might have made a difference, massive liability would ensue. The right solution is to move somewhere with a proper high-flow external-venting hood, of course, and only heat/CO alarms in the kitchen area.
- existencebox 13y agoI thought about this for a bit. Best solution i came up with would involve sensing the room a person is in and deactivating it locally, but even then there's the "edge case" of a fire happening "behind your back" (e.g. in a closed stove) and you don't notice. Basically, even though the possibility of a fire going unnoticed will become increasingly small, the cost if it does happen is so high that IMHO it doesn't balance the amortized cost of having to deal with an annoying fire alarm. (unless that serves to "train" you to ignore/disable it... This may actually be an interesting behavioral question)
- dfc 13y agoWhen I first red the snooze idea I thought the UL guidelines would say that it is not kosher but from a quick scan it looks like a "presnooze" button might be acceptable. UL 217 Smoke Alarms: https://ia600608.us.archive.org/3/items/gov.law.ul.217.1993/ul.217.1993.pdf https://ia600608.us.archive.org/3/items/gov.law.ul.217.1993/... Carl Malamud is fighting the good fight. Without resource.org that doc would set you back $400-900. CAVEAT: That is the 1993 edition. It looks like there is a 2005 update.
- 13y ago
- ensignavenger 13y agoFunny, when I first read about the Nest Protect, my thought was that the Wave feature could be dangerous if it was unintentionally activated. I figured they would have really tested it to make sure that couldn't happen, but I still wasn't comfortable with the feature in general.
- FatalLogic 13y agoThe support page for the Nest Wave feature is interesting http://support.nest.com/article/What-is-Nest-Wave-and-how-does-it-work http://support.nest.com/article/What-is-Nest-Wave-and-how-do... >One of the most common things you see when a smoke alarm goes off is people waving their hands, towels or magazines to air out the room. With Nest Wave, that instinctive motion will actually silence the alarm. A person's natural response to the first sign of danger might silence the alarm, inadvertently, and lead them to believe that they are safe. That is troubling. However, they have thought about this problem: >Depending on the situation, you may need to wave more at Nest Protect in order to silence it: Non-emergency situations require less waving, such as cancelling a manual test or listening to a Nightly Promise message. For your safety, you’ll have to wave more at Nest Protect during a Heads-Up or an Emergency Alarm. This helps ensure that you are deliberately trying to silence an alert. Obviously, the liability load on this product is far more than most other gadgets. I guess that even though they anticipated this sort of issue, a paranoid level of caution is required from Nest (Makes me think of the attention that Tesla received over one or two battery fires, or that bitcoin receives over company failures. New products are held to much higher standards than 'traditional' products)
- userbinator 13y agoIt’s very important that you immediately connect your Nest Protect to your Nest Account so we can remotely disable Nest Wave. Does anyone else find that unsettlingly creepy? If they can disable some feature of their product remotely, presumably via firmware updates or a similar mechanism, isn't it not much of a stretch to assume they can disable the entire alarm remotely?
- IgorPartola 13y agoAnd then they can get your Android phone to overheat and start a fire! Or slow down your car remotely when the police are chasing you! Yup, that's the 21st century for you. Most of the cool things we have today are here thanks to being able to be controlled remotely over the Internet. I wouldn't be surprised if the next product Nest comes out with is a security system. ADT has had its run of shitty and insecure systems for too long. It is time for someone to create a better version where you can monitor everything remotely. This will have all the same ramifications: the manufacturer can lock you inside your own home.
- userbinator 13y agoThe fact that they can do it remotely is not as creepy as how they've worded it and seemingly provided no instruction on how you can do it yourself.
- blueskin_ 13y agoI'll use a security system controlled by google shortly after a pig flies in through my window.
- techwatching 13y agoGreat response from Nest. But honestly - their algorithmic "trust us, the device knows what its doing" approach has always made me uncomfortable. The thermostat for instance - I don't want my thermostat to learn my habits and predict what temperature I want, etc. I just want to tell it what temperature the house should be and when, and leave it the hell alone. Same thing with the smoke detector. False positive? Push the button. Its the rational ux given the criticality of failure modes involved.
- jsumrall 13y agoI was under the impression that the Nest did work the way you would like— you tell it a temperature and thats it. The only "learning" involved was noticing you were gone and letting the temperature change a bit more, and when you come home it goes back to what you set. (There's also some bit about reducing the temperature a bit during peak load). As with a smoke detector, I would never expect it to disable its smoke detecting function unless I pressed some button.
- mkesper 13y agoI'm searching for a combination of "totally normal" smoke detectors (for safety) and a possibility to trigger an additional remote alert on my mobile phone. Is there some arduino project for something like that?
- userbinator 13y agoPersonally, I wouldn't trust an Arduino for anything safety-critical...
- mkesper 13y agoDo you know of any better approaches?
- bananas 13y agoWhat a mess. My existing CO and smoke detectors don't need a patch. As per my comment yesterday on Nest's thermostat, this product doesn't need to exist. To have it proven as dangerous suggests that they have their priorities wrong here. I don't want poorly engineered toys keeping me safe. As for the press statement, it's wriggling nothing more. Their products remind me of Zorg's desk in the Fifth Element.
- blueskin_ 13y agoWhere's the consumer warning that their data is now accessible to google and the NSA?