3 ms·
> just under 12% of the cost (6% of the sale price) went to the people who made the yarn, cut the cloth, and sewed it all together. And what about the people w
by pdonis 13y ago
> just under 12% of the cost (6% of the sale price) went to the people who made the yarn, cut the cloth, and sewed it all together.
And what about the people who took the completed T-shirts and moved them to where they were wanted? That somehow has no value? People who ordered the T-shirts didn't order T-shirts sitting piled up in a factory; they ordered them so they could wear them. That means making the product is only the first step: then you have to move the product to the end user (shipping and handling), but before you can do that you have to figure out where the end user is and make sure he has paid for the product (order fulfillment).
For those three activities (production, order fulfillment, and shipping/handling), I get, respectively, $2.00, $1.79, and $2.36 (note that I've included both stages of shipping in the shipping/handling cost)--i.e., all roughly equal. That seems fair to me. In fact, if we include "printing" in production (which seems reasonable--people ordered a T-shirt with a design printed on it, not a plain one), that cost goes up to $2.90, more than the total shipping/handling cost. (Note, btw, that graphic design was only $0.12 per shirt, basically negligible.)
The real message of the cost breakdown, to me, is how much overhead there is: $1.21 per shirt in Kickstarter fees, $1.04 per shirt in Amazon payment fees, $0.33 per shirt in tariff, and $2.67 per shirt in "jockey costs" (presumably meaning company overhead for Jockey itself). That adds up to $5.25 per shirt in overhead, or about 42% of the cost.
- mrow84 13y agoI didn't say that the other parts of the process had no value, I said that the relative return to people at the bottom of the labour chain is low. My claim is that they are getting paid proportionally less for the work that they do. I don't really see why it is contentious - poor people have less bargaining power, because they have less to bargain with (e.g. poorer health, less education, less to fall back on), so will come off worse in trades, including trades for their labour. It makes economic sense, but that doesn't make it good. Also note that overall efficiency can become irrelevant if the returns on efficiency gains are unequally distributed. Addressing those problems, which are structural not individual, will improve the lives of people who are under-compensated by the current system. Claiming those problems don't have any effect on outcomes requires explanation.
- pdonis 13y ago> the relative return to people at the bottom of the labour chain is low...they are getting paid proportionally less for the work that they do. If this is true, then based on the cost breakdown (which is all the evidence we have in this case), it's also true for the people who do order fulfillment and shipping/handling. Are all of those people also "at the bottom of the labour chain"? > poor people have less bargaining power, because they have less to bargain with (e.g. poorer health, less education, less to fall back on) It's true that poor people have worse health, education, etc., but that's not why they have less bargaining power. They have less bargaining power because they cannot perform higher-value work. Improving their health, education, etc. helps because it makes them capable of doing higher-value work, not because it magically increases the value of the same work they were doing before. A T-shirt doesn't become more valuable because the person making it is healthier or has a better education; but if better health and education enables the person to operate a T-shirt making machine that makes 10 shirts per hour, instead of making 1 shirt per hour by hand, then that person is doing higher-value work and should be paid accordingly (and will be, in a competitive free market). So if people want to have more bargaining power, they need to bring more value to the bargaining table. Helping people to do that is certainly worth doing. But it's no use pretending that just improving people's health, education, etc. is enough. It isn't.
- mrow84 13y agoI'm not suggesting that "just improving people's health, education, etc. is enough." I'm suggesting that people aren't being paid enough because, structurally, they are in a poor bargaining position, and thus can't command higher wages, and so have worse outcomes, which perpetuates their position (that being the structural part). Lots of things go into it, and looking at individuals doesn't really address the wider problem. The only reason that people accept the low wages is because they have nothing else, and once things improve enough to drive wages up the industries that rely on low-wage labour move on. Now, you can take that two ways, and I see both as true (whereas you might only see one). Firstly, the jobs have (eventually/sometimes) improved conditions, up to the point where people demand too much, and the manufacturers have to move on. Note that this wasn't a benevolent act on the part of the manufacturers - they came there because that was where they could get the best return on their investment. It isn't quick, and the manufacturers have absolutely no interest in making it quicker - uprooting an industry is expensive, so they are incentivised to stop people attaining economic independence. The other way to look at it is that the only reason that the manufacturer could extract such a low price is because the people they came to employ were in such a desperate position that they had no other choice. The only argument is that it is still fair, because it was a mutual agreement, a point which I addressed in another sub-thread: it is not fair, because it relies on coercion. We go around the world, coercing people into doing work for us for as little pay as we can get away with. I don't know if you listened to it, but the NPR t-shirt podcasts had some of this stuff in there - including a guy from the t-shirt industry saying precisely that they go to wherever the poverty is, because it's cheaper (which makes sense!) The typical refrain is that, as I already mentioned, it makes things better. Yes, sure, it sometimes does, only much slower than it could do. There are also a host of other positive and negative effects that aren't covered by these ridiculous generalisations I'm making, that can make things either much better, or much worse, for the people involved. My belief is that we should use our combined wealth to mitigate the risks of uncertain negative events, and that it doesn't cost very much to do so for people who are poor. edit: I've enjoyed the discussion btw! :)