3 ms·
> Why should we not divert some of our growth into growing our leisure time, rather than growing our physical wealth? Because not everyone was created equal. S
by tomp 13y ago
> Why should we not divert some of our growth into growing our leisure time, rather than growing our physical wealth?
Because not everyone was created equal. Some professions are completely worthless (e.g. ad creators) and add nothing net to the society. Others, e.g. doctors, are so valuable, and so few people can do them, that they simply can't afford to work less (educating more doctors so that they can work fewer hours is not an answer - I'm not a doctor, but I imagine it takes a relatively fixed amount of hours of training to actually "become a doctor" (after finishing your education), so if doctors worked less, they would be worse doctors). The social contract then dictates that everyone must work, since doctors have to work.
Solution: automate medicine, energy, food.
- Ygg2 13y agoWe're on a road to that. I've read about robot surgeons. Very few mistakes, perfectly clean. Problem is what do we do with spare doctors? Research?
- epaladin 13y agoRight now surgery robots like the Da Vinci aren't automated. They have to be controlled by someone at the moment.
- maxerickson 13y agoThe number of teaching spots for doctors is not necessarily well exposed to the market (various regulations). It's unlikely that all the interested and capable people are able to become doctors. It's also possible to imagine a social contract that gives working people more, I'm not sure we have to stick with the one you see.
- beat 13y agoAs Bob Black pointed out in The Abolition of Work, if a job is worth doing, someone would do it, whether or not they got paid to do it. Charlie Stross made that point in his essay - he'd continue to be a writer even if he didn't need to write for a living. The same is true of doctors. And farmers. And firemen.
- tomp 13y agoThere's quite a bit of a difference between being a writer, and being a surgeon/emergency doctor/fireman. Writer's don't work 12 hour shifts, don't do physically hard work, and aren't killed by their jobs.
- ctdonath 13y agoI contend a core persistent failing of FOSS is proof that premise is not true. There is somewhere around 5% of any project which must be done, but which nobody wants to do because it's hard/dirty work which produces little (but not zero or negative) benefit, is not interesting, few if any will appreciate (or even notice) it, but without which there will be a persistent stumbling block. Sure, writers & doctors & farmers & firemen might do their stereotypical work for free because that's just what they do. But what about street cleaners & trash haulers? janitors for public housing? high-risk divers for floating oil rigs? Are you going to regularly clean, for free, elevators that low-end public-housing occupants piss in daily? pick up trash on the street, dumped there faster than you can clean up by bored teens who know they'll never have to do anything because their GBI cards will always get them food & pay the rent, and who are amused by your frustration at their persistent destructiveness?
- ZeroGravitas 13y agoStrangely I was just discussing this in another thread, but there's a shortage of doctors because the doctors have a union that ensures that is the case, as that is a benefit to their members. Any attempt to relieve this pressure, such as allowing qualified nurses to undertake more work, is strongly resisted by the doctors themselves. And they will fight automation too, for the very same reasons, and with many of the same soundbites.