4 ms·
what I've been told is that everybody who discusses Genetics and IQ honestly are effectively Nazis and should be driven from public life. Who told you that? So
by tokenadult 17y ago
what I've been told is that everybody who discusses Genetics and IQ honestly are effectively Nazis and should be driven from public life.
Who told you that? Someone here on HN, or someone somewhere else?
Just yesterday, writing a review of a different book, I came upon this interesting quotation from Thomas Sowell:
"The taboo against discussing race and IQ has not left this an open question. On the contrary, it has had the perverse effect of freezing an existing majority of testing experts in favor of a belief that racial IQ differences are influenced by genetics. No belief can be refuted if it cannot be discussed."
Agreeing with Sowell on the endorsement of open inquiry, I would love to have people discuss carefully, thoughtfully, and without name-calling what they mean when they talk about genetic influences on human intelligence and all other influences on human intelligence. This is a much-researched issue, and I have taken care to meet some of the eminent researchers in person and to read the peer-reviewed journal articles and major monographs of many more researchers on the issue for more than a decade. Facts are established by careful observation and experimentation, and the implications of those facts are discovered by considering yet more facts.
- mynameishere 17y agoSowell is an extreme outlier. Anyway, the "nature vs. nurture" argument invariable avoids a simple fact: Nature has a one-time cost, nurture has an infinitely-ongoing cost. I mean: Even if the left is right about schools, institutions, teachers, practices, education, etc, etc, being able to equalize the differences between people, you are essentially dividing the population into two parts: 1. Those who naturally meet a standard, and 2. Those who require 500,000 dollars worth of state intervention to meet the same standard.
- tokenadult 17y ago1. Those who naturally meet a standard, and 2. Those who require 500,000 dollars worth of state intervention to meet the same standard. What is your proposal for determining which group a person belongs to, if we accept the existence of two such disparate groups? How would your proposal take into account such known facts (from psychometric psychology) as 1) error in estimation in IQ testing, 2) individual variability in IQ over the course of childhood, 3) the influence of personal drive and motivation (acknowledged by ALL psychologists) in the expression of IQ as academic achievement, 4) the known malleability of IQ under less expensive interventions in some experimental studies of individuals and across whole societies over recent generations?