3 ms·
This seems like self-serving drivel. Engineers are not Gods and non-engineers are not single-digit-IQ morons. The tasks set is of course impossible by definit
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
This seems like self-serving drivel. Engineers are not Gods and non-engineers are not single-digit-IQ morons.
The tasks set is of course impossible by definition - which is not the case in the real world where most projects are doomed by human factors, lack of trust and will rarely if ever be rescued by one guy standing up and saying "No you are all wrong now listen to me and I will tell you why this cannot happen".
Humans work emotionally and love stories - if we want to succeed and still fulfill out inner Maker then instead of No you can't do it, please try "Instead of red lines why don't we sell pencils to enable our customers to draw their own lines. What's the best ad campaign we can imagine for a pencil case aimed at the blue collar market?"
Everyone else is not an idiot, is probably the best and most useful thing to take away from this.
- skybrian 13y agoNearly all stories are deliberately unrealistic in some way. I believe the point is not to make non-engineers look like idiots but to get across to a non-technical audience why this sort of meeting is frustrating.
- smileysteve 13y agoWhile a little of this clip suggest idiocy - The per... per... dick... dick... This video is actually more about the human factors in communication. The "you do know what translucent means" is an example of speech that is VERY absolute and inflammatory. The sales and PM are very agreeable to the client and distrusting of the engineer - very often putting the burden of his "being the expert" against him in the conversation.
- hrabago 13y agoThe reason this illustration works is because it uses concepts that everybody understands and can relate to. If a sketch showed end users asking for features that are simply not logical, but because of reasons that end users can't really understand, then only engineers can understand them, defeating the usefulness of the video in illustrating the frustration that an expert can experience. TL;DR: It's just a metaphor.