10 ms·
Supreme Court Strikes Down Aggregate Limits on Federal Campaign Contributions
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- lordCarbonFiber 13y agoI wonder though, now that the process to buy candidates is a bit more direct (no need to funnel your money into a super PAC and then have that money weaseled to fuel campaign machinery) could in these coming elections we see the first crowdfunded candidate? I'm envisioning a system by which a representative could sell direct democracy back to the voters. They fund his campaign and (assuming he wins) in return are able to vote (online and in a manner actually convenient to them as opposed to the terrible system the US uses now) on all his actions on the Hill. IANAL, but, the thought seems interesting.
- cobrausn 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_action_committee#Super_PACs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_action_committee#Supe... Practically speaking, as long as some needed transparency is in place, is there much of a real difference to how things are currently run? Also, the rash of 5-4 decisions in the supreme court lately bothers me. Was there ever a time where the supreme court was this polarized?
- giarc 13y agoI think as the NYT article states, it will likely funnel some money away from the super-PACs. This just brings the donor and the candidate closer together. People like Sheldon Adelson will still continue to contribute huge sums of money to candidates, he'll just be able to do it directly now.
- twoodfin 13y agoAlso, the rash of 5-4 decisions in the supreme court lately bothers me. Was there ever a time where the supreme court was this polarized? I don't think it's particularly polarized. If Antonin Scalia is your benchmark for a "polarizing" figure, the # of 5-4 cases where he was in the majority appear to have been trending downward: http://scdb.wustl.edu/analysisOverview.php?sid=1301-TICTAC-7244 http://scdb.wustl.edu/analysisOverview.php?sid=1301-TICTAC-7...
- frankchn 13y agoWe hear about the 5-4 decisions because they are often the most controversial ones and ones that the media will report on. Based on last year's statistics (http://scotusblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/agreement_OT12.pdf http://scotusblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/agreement_O...), even between the two Justices who disagree with each other the most (Ginsburg and Alito), they agree on the same judgment in 58% of cases.
- cwal37 13y agoIt really just means an individual can donate to a lot more individual campaigns now, as the aggregate limit has been struck down. I doubt this will increase any transparency, as current rules are barely enforced to begin with, and the real money is coming from PACs. I threw this together a couple years ago to demonstrate how a foreign company, if they wished, could donate funds which in the eyes of the law would be "untraceable" (even if it really is obvious). http://i.imgur.com/Hjp1b.gif http://i.imgur.com/Hjp1b.gif It also just shows how quickly money gets "disguised". I should have put something in there about limits, but I forgot at the time.
- smackfu 13y ago>Also, the rash of 5-4 decisions in the supreme court lately bothers me. I believe this is actually the first 5-4 decision in the current term, which has been going since October: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_term_opinions_of_the_Supreme_Court_of_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_term_opinions_of_the_Supre... There have been a lot of 9-0 decisions, and several 6-3.
- cobrausn 13y agoGood to hear. I must have imprinted that opinion from some scaremongering headlines earlier. Doing a search for 'Supreme Court 5 4' or similar yields a lot of spin.
- mason240 13y agoI'm guessing that 5-4 decisions tend to be more polarizing to the public as well, generating more news, while 9-0 decisions The more controversial tend to be more mundane, generating little attention.
- smackfu 13y agoAnd a lot of Supreme Court decisions don't even make the news, because they are deciding small bits of law that don't affect many people. Like the other case decided today was about whether an airline could terminate someone's membership in a frequent flyer program. The law was unclear, so the SCOTUS ruled on it, but it's not something that means anything to most people.
- briandh 13y agoThe percentage of 5-4 decisions being handed down is practically meaningless without relating it to how controversial or "hard" the questions being decided are. That of course, is fundamentally hard to quantify, although you may make some headway by dividing up decisions based on whether there were circuit splits, how (in)consistent the decisions of lower courts that evaluated the case were, the splits for the lower courts, etc. Moreover, cases often address multiple questions and a 5-4 decision can be handed down even when many or most of the questions answered were subject unanimous or nearly unanimous agreement. By the same token, a unanimous or near-unanimous decision could have been reached in spite of radically diverging rationales from the various justices.
- Shivetya 13y agoGreat news. The headline is misleading. Congress again was trying to play games with who could donate to who/what and when they could and so and so on. They were not interested in a level playing field, they were again protecting their interest. Restricting how money is spent in political races only protects incumbents and their party. It in no way protects the right of the people to vote for whom they want. The costs involved in modern campaigns can be insurmountable with the restrictions placed on donations and expenditures. The costs have exceed inflation, the limits have not. Never ever support such restrictions just because you don't like the message or messenger because you are merely handing someone the means to do the same to you.
- ewillbefull 13y agoCitizens United and other campaign "finance" rulings are poorly understood by the public still today. Most Americans probably still believe Citizens United had anything to do with contribution limits, or stating "money is speech", or that corporations are people. A cursory read of the wikipedia article would clear this up, but the media narrative surrounding these rulings will dominate for some time.
- ctdonath 13y agoThe ruling ends with When word concerning the plot of the movie Mr. Smith Goes to Washington reached the circles of Government, some officials sought, by persuasion, to discourage its distribution. ... Under Austin [(the basis for the campaign finance restriction discussed)], though, officials could havedone more than discourage its distribution — they could have banned the film. After all, it, like [the movie] _Hillary_, was speech funded by a corporation that was critical of Members of Congress. Mr. Smith Goes to Washington may befiction and caricature; but fiction and caricature can be a powerful force. Modern day movies, television comedies, or skits on Youtube.com might portray public officials or public policies in unflattering ways. Yet if a covered transmission during the blackout period creates the background for candidate endorsement or opposition, a felony occurs solely because a corporation, other than an exempt media corporation, has made the “purchase, payment, distribution, loan, advance, deposit, or gift of money or anything of value” in order to engage in political speech. ... Speech would be suppressed in the realm where its necessity is most evident: in the public dialogue preceding a real election. Governments are often hostile to speech, but under our law and our tradition it seems stranger than fiction for our Government to make this political speech a crime. Yet this is the statute’s purpose and design. Some members of the public might consider _Hillary_ to be insightful and instructive; some might find it to beneither high art nor a fair discussion on how to set the Nation’s course; still others simply might suspend judgment on these points but decide to think more about issues and candidates. Those choices and assessments, however, are not for the Government to make. “The First Amend-ment underwrites the freedom to experiment and to create in the realm of thought and speech. Citizens must be free to use new forms, and new forums, for the expression ofideas. The civic discourse belongs to the people, and the Government may not prescribe the means used to conduct it.”
- ctdonath 13y agoA win for freedom of speech, and of the press. Running a press costs money, as does speaking to more than a few people; if a group of people with common interests choose to fund & pool their money to promote a message, they have the right to do so. Ruling here: http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/09pdf/08-205.pdf http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/09pdf/08-205.pdf Crux of argument: First Amendment protections do not depend on the speaker’s “financial ability to engage in public discussion.” ... Distinguishing wealthy individuals from corporations based on the latter’s special advantages of, e.g., limited liability, does not suffice to allow laws prohibiting speech. It is irrelevant for First Amendment purposes that corporate funds may “have little or no correlation to the public’s support for the corporation’s political ideas.” Austin, supra, at 660. All speakers, including individuals and the media, use money amassed from the economic marketplace to fund their speech, and the First Amendment protects the resulting speech. That and related points go on in detail for 57 pages.
- protomyth 13y ago"A win for freedom of speech, and of the press." I'll agree on the speech part since it allows for groupings and patrons of movements to be more effective, but I think the press just lost some of its influence. Given the partisanship in the press, this isn't such a bad thing. They've been pushing their influence for years and can basically spend unlimited money on politics so its fine for "non-press" to be given the same ability.
- MisterBastahrd 13y agoFreedom of speech? It essentially turns individual voters without deep pockets into the citizen equivalents of flyover states. All the Supreme Court did was eliminate any pretense that the US isn't quickly turning into an oligarchy.
- ctdonath 13y agoIf individual voters are contributing nothing to the speech/press promoting the candidate/cause of their choice, they have nothing to complain about. Just because some don't exercise their rights doesn't mean they can suppress the rights of those who do.
- fourply 13y agoAs a law-talking-guy, I can say: this is really, really bad. It's really unusual to see such a split (4-1-4) in such an important decision, and it's tough to say for sure what the law actually is now. One thing that's clear: this doesn't bode well for American democracy UNLESS the legislature takes the clear signal the Court appears to be trying to send and crafts new law to fix the problems this decision creates.
- ctdonath 13y agoThe signal the Court appears to be trying to send is "Congress shall make no law ... abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press". It's not a new message, and not new that Congress is inclined to abridge it.
- iandanforth 13y agoMoney is not speech.
- twoodfin 13y agoNo, but many useful, protected forms of speech and the press require money. Congress couldn't constitutionally shut down the New York Times by making it illegal for them to purchase ink.
- ctdonath 13y agoSpeaking to more than a few people requires money.
- jmj42 13y agoYou have a right to speech. You DO NOT have a right to be heard.
- smsm42 13y agoSo is it OK for Congress to ban New York Times from distributing their paper? After all, they still can speak as much as they want, and if you want to listen to them you can come to their office or to their homes and listen, and nobody has right to be heard beyond that?
- jjoonathan 13y agoCampaigns cost money. Politicians get the lion's share of that money from people expecting an ROI. Our political system literally has a mandatory bribe quota. > but in the case of company X the lobbying ROI is a net positive for everyone, so the system can't be all bad Please list the top 10 donors (heck, I'll be generous: any 10 consecutive donors) to any seat-holding political party of your choice, along with your opinion of whether or not the policy they're after is net-beneficial to society (+), zero sum (0), or a net loss to society (-). Alternatively, pick the +/0/- labels according to your unapologetic self-interest, since it's reasonable to vote on that basis rather than trying to work out the whole "net benefit to society" thing. Let's focus on what lobbying IS instead of hoping (for example) that google will displace comcast from the gravy train.
- izendejas 13y agoAnyone that wants to hack this system of corruption, should join Lawrence Lessig (Aaron Swartz)'s cause: http://www.nhrebellion.org/ http://www.nhrebellion.org/
- snake_plissken 13y agoThis ongoing conflation of free speech and political participation via campaign contributions has got to end. All of these restrictions were put into place after Watergate for a reason; campaign contributions are a corrupting influence in politics.
- ctdonath 13y agoFrom the ruling's summary: the Government’s other arguments [reason] that corporate political speechcan be banned to prevent corruption or its appearance. The Buckley Court found this rationale “sufficiently important” to allow contribution limits but refused to extend that reasoning to expenditure limits, and the Court does not do so here. While a single Bellotti footnote purported to leave the question open, this Court now concludes that independent expenditures, including those made by corporations, do not give rise to corruption or the appearance of corruption. That speakers may have influence over or access to elected officials does not mean that those officials are corrupt. Later the Court elaborates on the reasoning behind this; I suggest you read it.
- snake_plissken 13y agoI have read it and I do not agree with the court. This is a cherry picked example so I will try to get some more later: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Vesco#Nixon_scandal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Vesco#Nixon_scandal
- crazy1van 13y ago> This ongoing conflation of free speech and political participation via campaign contributions has got to end. Should people be limited by how much time they can donate to volunteering for a candidate? How about how many words they can write in favor of a candidate? Why should someone who doesn't have the time to do those things but does have the time to write a check be prohibited from participating in the campaign process?
- buerkle 13y agoHowever, unlike money, time is limited. No one person can contribute more than 24 hours in a single day.
- 001sky 13y agoPlease amend the headline# to the actual one: Supreme Court Strikes Down Aggregate Limits on Federal Campaign Contributions So, at the end of the day individuals can spread their influence "a mile wide and an inch deep". But this does not imply that such individuals can spend in both unlimited depth and breadth. The primary limits (<$3K/per) remain inplace. And the article also notes that this does not impact groups. Wednesday’s decision concerned only contributions from individuals. Federal law continues to ban contributions by corporations and unions. Whether this is a good idea or not is debatable. But the editorialized headline doesn't help communicate the actual news. ____________ # HN submitted> "Supreme Court Strikes Down Limits on Federal Campaign Contributions"
- uptown 13y agoThe headline I originally submitted was the headline used by the NY Times at the time the story was published. I've updated the submission to match the change made by the NY Times per your suggestion.
- allochthon 13y agoThis is another blow against what remains of a sane US political dialog. The door has been further opened to the cheapening of American political discourse by monied interests, who are able to overwhelm the public with their carefully shaped messaging and attack ads. The current US Supreme Court is doing quite a lot to move the US to a "one-dollar-one-vote" business model.
- notdonspaulding 13y ago> The current US Supreme Court is doing quite a lot to move the US to a "one-dollar-one-vote" business model. Can you name one federal government body in the US that takes its job more seriously, or understands its limits and bounds more thoroughly, than the SCOTUS? Go ahead and try to find one. The SCOTUS is not perfect, it's made mistakes in the past, but please understand that you have a nation of people looking to them to make reasonable applications of law in extremely intricate situations. Read the SCOTUS transcripts sometime of a polarizing issue and pay particular attention to the questions that the justices who oppose your own viewpoint will raise. They're deliberate, and precise, and unyielding to sensationalism. I think you'll be surprised to find much less judicial agenda than you seem to think SCOTUS is guilty of.
- denzil_correa 13y agoI understand there's a 2600US$ cap on "each gift to a political candidate" and today's ruling doesn't affect this cap. I presume a donor could still give make a very high donation in multiples of 2600US$. Am I right?
- hga 13y agoNo, the caps on contributions to each "point source", you might call it, e.g. each candidate, remain the same. What was overturned was overall spending limits, that you could only donate a total of X dollars per election or whatever.
- denzil_correa 13y agoNPR is reporting otherwise > Overby says that even with the individual candidate limit still in place, the ruling "[makes] it possible for a donor to give a party leader a check for more than $1 million, with the money getting parceled out in $2,600 amounts to the candidates." http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2014/04/02/298326893/supreme-court-strikes-down-overall-limits-on-political-contributions http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2014/04/02/298326893/sup... I'm confused!
- hga 13y agoSo am I (well, not that much, that NPR would make a mistake biased towards their bias, or outright lie, would be nothing new). That's another "point source", of course, but per this (now slightly out of date) chart from the FEC: http://www.fec.gov/pages/brochures/contriblimits.shtml http://www.fec.gov/pages/brochures/contriblimits.shtml there would seem to be a limit to how much you could send to a "party leader". Maybe it would have to be washed though 200 (!) "political committees" to allow for 1M in 5K max chunks ... which would seem to be a bit obvious. Although that would be a loophole the Congress could close up, assuming it exists. E.g. a limit to the total to a "party leader" or PACs he controls would fly with 8 of the Supremes.
- ChrisGaudreau 13y agoI must say I was quite worried when I woke up and saw the headlines. They originally made it seem as though the Court struck down all contribution limits, even to individual candidates. Was relieved to learn that wasn't the case. I wonder if we're headed down that road, though.