3 ms·
They started off reasonable. Ask ordinary people to assign probabilities to potential world events that can be verified. The next step is also reasonable. Wi
by logfromblammo 13y ago
They started off reasonable. Ask ordinary people to assign probabilities to potential world events that can be verified. The next step is also reasonable. With a large enough crowd, the estimation noise around the "true" probability will cancel out. That's how the crowd mean estimated the ox weight so closely.
But then they turned left onto stupid street. They took the people who, perhaps by chance alone, predicted results closest to the crowd mean, and put them on a "team". What the heck is the point of that? It just reduces the size of the crowd and shows a fundamental misunderstanding of statistics.
Past performance does not necessarily predict future results.
Start with 10000 coins, and flip them all. Keep the ones that land heads. Flip those, and keep the ones that land heads. Repeat until all coins land on tails, or one coin remains as the "champion of heads." What is the probability that when it is flipped again, it comes up heads? Still 50%. It isn't a supercoin. You just managed to select it from a giant group by making it the sole outlier from a series of independent trials.
Though you should probably check to make sure it actually has a tails side, just in case.
- nzp 13y ago> It just reduces the size of the crowd and shows a fundamental misunderstanding of statistics. Why do you assume that what's in the NPR article is all there is to it, that there's no info, technical or other, left out? Of course they thought of that, and checked. There's no regression to the mean, the elite group further improved, their estimates were 65 % better than the overall crowd.[0] [0] http://www.economist.com/news/21589145-how-sort-best-rest-whos-good-forecasts http://www.economist.com/news/21589145-how-sort-best-rest-wh...
- logfromblammo 13y agoThat article is much more informative. Kudos to you, nzp.
- nzp 13y agoHeh, actually, kudos to joshuahedlund[0], I found it in his comment. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7515263 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7515263