3 ms·
Making stupid statements and performing harmful actions are vastly different things. Focusing on the former: making stupid statements does have consequences: Ot
by absherwin 13y ago
Making stupid statements and performing harmful actions are vastly different things. Focusing on the former: making stupid statements does have consequences: Others may question the judgement of the person making the statements. For whatever reason, Eich's views haven't raised those questions in those closest to him, perhaps, because they aren't discussed.
If someone stated that men and women have different numbers of teeth, why not encourage an experiment? It's not an absurd statement unless you've gathered evidence or trust the evidence you've read elsewhere.
The challenge in this case is that morality can't be determined objectively without reference to some other framework, which itself is likely subjective. So it doesn't tell us whether Eich can reason or incorporate evidence. He likely formulates his view from a different set of assumptions.
- MichaelGG 13y agoBy itself it doesn't tell us if Eich can reason. It certainly provides a very strong hint, though.