5 ms·
God this is an insanely good idea. Not only do you solve a real pain point for startups (the whole 409a eval) but if they sign up and feed you monthly updates o
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
God this is an insanely good idea. Not only do you solve a real pain point for startups (the whole 409a eval) but if they sign up and feed you monthly updates on their financial position you could massively front run the market on what startups were going to pop and which were going to expire quietly. Google thinking about acquiring your startup? Lets have a look at the other six companies in your space for which is the right one to grab and for how much. Ka-CHING!
- frandroid 13y agoI'm pretty sure it would be illegal for 4aaS firms to use the data they get through this service to front run the market.
- confluence 13y ago> I'm pretty sure it would be illegal Doesn't mean they won't do it. I don't know why I'm being downvoted here. It's a statement of fact. You see the same thing happening with investment banks, with the buy side front running sell side clients across that oh so opaque Chinese wall every so often. This stuff happens. I'm not saying it will happen in this case, but it is a reasonable possibility.
- aeturnum 13y agoHow exactly world you pitch that in your business plan? Under the 'Illegal but potentially lucrative' category? :) Might add well throw in some drug running on the side as well.
- TeMPOraL 13y agoUnder the "every one of you knows what we're doing, we know that you really, realy need us, so let's not talk about this out loud, shall we?" category ;).
- gamblor956 13y agoWhat you have just described would most likely be considered insider trading.
- jamiequint 13y agoNo, that is wrong. The qualification for insider trading is that it be a public company. Private companies don't fall under insider trading laws and public companies don't do 409a's.
- 7Figures2Commas 13y agoActually, you're wrong. There are a variety of "insider trading" laws and some apply to private companies too.[1] [1] http://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=e24dc4ab-2a77-43d9-8a78-9ea46eca1aca http://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=e24dc4ab-2a77-...
- chrishynes 13y agoThat case refers to a company defrauding its own shareholders by withholding material information from them during a buyback. That's far different from what OP is suggesting -- a wink/nod to a third party indicating to buy or sell.
- gamblor956 13y agoNo, that's precisely what insider trading is--trading by any person based on inside information they have acquired through means covered by a fiduciary obligation (i.e. employment, service provider, etc.). A company can trade on inside information with its own shareholders, since the company is using information it has access to which its own shareholders may not.
- chrishynes 13y agoExactly. It's not "trading by any person". Insider trading is can only be done by someone with a fiduciary responsibility. If a non-involved person somehow acquires "inside" information (without getting it from one with a fiduciary responsibility) it's not insider trading even if the information is non-public.
- pendevere 13y agoHello -- founder of Preferred Return (the valuation firm behind this offer that is partnered with eShares) here. As appraisers we cannot own equity or any economic rights in the companies we value.
- danieltillett 13y agoI am sure this is correct, but you are certainly sitting on a data gold mine.
- throwaway344 13y agoThis is like saying someone who lots of insider information about a particular company is "sitting on a gold mine". Insider trading laws exist for a reason.
- danieltillett 13y agoI was trying to suggest that the data they are collecting is rather valuable. They don't have to exploit the data (I believe them when they say they won't), but if it were to "escape" then someone could certainly make use of it.
- TeMPOraL 13y agoThis, and because of this "goldmine" they will become a target for blackhats who will try to get their data. There are people who would pay in megadollars for that data (or even aggregate reports), so there's an incentive, and there's a market.
- danieltillett 13y agoExactly. I think that the possibility that highly valuable data might escape is not given enough consideration by both vendors and customers.
- ChuckMcM 13y ago
- matthewmcg 13y agoThe aggregate data would still be useful. It is very common for firms that provide services to lots of start ups to publish "state of the market" type reports.