3 ms·
Please. Tell us what you really feel. Stop holding back so much. :) I know it's fun to lob rhetorical hand grenades around. The nice thing about the US is that
by DanielBMarkham 19y ago
Please. Tell us what you really feel. Stop holding back so much. :)
I know it's fun to lob rhetorical hand grenades around. The nice thing about the US is that we have a system where failure is accepted. If you don't like the policies or leaders, there will always be someone along later that's more to your liking. We've done all kinds of screwed up stuff -- and all kinds of good stuff. I think it's absolutely important to point out where we're wrong, but a little perspective can be useful too.
In my perfect world there would be a lot less government involvement in all of our lives. We would be armed and take care of things like terrorism ourselves right when it happened, instead of farming the responsibility for our security out to big government. But both the left and the right want to take away all of our freedoms and do all the worrying and thinking for us. So that means we turn what should be personal things like health care, personal security, property ownership, and privacy into a huge multi-generational political argument without resolution. And then people complain that the government gets it wrong! I think people are all too happy to take away somebody else's freedom for their pet cause. It's just when somebody else does it to them that they squeal the most. That's why I can only answer what freedoms I am personally willing to trade in the war on terror. I can't and won't make those decisions for other people.
I can make one observation, though. As democracies are attacked by terrorism they have a tendency to get more and more restrictive. I would expect the US to follow that pattern -- it has in the past. The thing I am watching is whether those restrictions are temporary or permanent.
I don't countenance too much the argument that politicians use fear to keep the war on terror machine humming along. To me that sounds a lot more paranoid than just simply acknowledging that there are people right now who are actively plotting to kill lots of Americans. It's nothing to go beserko about, just something to consider when you make decisions to vote for representatives. If attacks continue over the next few decades, voters will punish politicians who downplay the threat of terrorism. That's just political reality.
- pg 19y agoThe nice thing about the US is that we have a system where failure is accepted. If you don't like the policies or leaders, there will always be someone along later that's more to your liking. I wish. Some of the top layer changes in elections, but it seems like the bad guys in the government have very long careers, alternating between government appointments and jobs in companies closely tied to the government. Cheney is a famous example, but there are thousands more like him. The culture in this world seems to be quite different from that of startup hubs. These people are suits squared. They fail a lot, but not because they try wildly imaginative things. They fail because succeeding (as we'd measure it) is not their goal; power is.
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoI don't know, Paul. I just am not the person to sit around wringing my hands over how bad the political system is -- and I'm a political junkie :) I've consulted with large government agencies and I've seen the alliances that form between various players, congress, and various agencies. My opinion is that any cohesive group of people with a lot of time on their hands is going to try to take political power from other people. The caricature people use is Cheney and the military, but it happens all over the place. I remember back in the 80s environmental groups would go around to state legislatures, getting them to write very complex laws. Then they would hit all of the local governments, offering to consult with them so they would be in compliance with the laws they helped write! So the big old wheel just keeps turning around and around. I will agree that the structure of the system is broken. Complex systems have a tendency to spin out of control. But in general the whole thing kind of hangs together anyway. We're not out in the streets with M-16s shooting at each other. Instead we can sit in our cushy chairs enjoying all of the benefits of freedom while we craft pithy arguments to toss at one another. I remember when the economy was in the toilet during the late 70s. Carter used to get on TV and say not only did the country suck, it was pretty much all our fault. Here's hoping that form of leadership doesn't return.
- aswanson 19y agoI'd take Carter over the current leadership of this country any day of the week.
- corentin 19y ago> Please. Tell us what you really feel. That's what I just did! I could have sugar coated my words into a more politically correct form so that they don't look like the typical reddit comment, but what's the point? That's precisely what I think. And I'm pointing out mere facts, not speculating about some crazy conspiracy theory. But I found your comment very interesting, nonetheless. It shows a profound cultural difference between you and us (europeans) (again, I'm not implying that one is better than the other; just pointing out facts). You trust your fellow citizens to "wake-up" when enough is enough ("[...] whether those restrictions are temporary or permanent.", "[...] voters will punish politicians who downplay the threat of terrorism.") Most european countries woke up too late at some point of their history; that's why we tend to be more worried about the whole situation (and not because we're anti-american).
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoHeck I wouldn't want any PC nonsense. All I ask is that you consider that there are probably good reasons things are the way they are. Smart people are on both sides of these issues, and people who generalize usually do so just to have a political fight to score votes, not to try to understand. I have yet to get into an honest political discussion where at the end of the day both sides were actually pretty close. The problem is that the media wants to present everything as a fight, so people spend a lot of time sort of repeating lists of slogans back and forth. To me, that sounded like what you were doing. As the national elections get closer, I imagine people are going to get more and more emotional. I like to compare our nation as one big dysfunctional family where the welfare check only comes once every four years.
- corentin 19y ago> All I ask is that you consider that there are probably good reasons things are the way they are. Should I call you Pangloss ? :) (kidding aside, I agree with you on the rest)