6 ms·
I agree with the linked article. Games, or at the very least "good" games, with the Rift are DOA. The VR internet or metaverse or whatever is Carmack's idea as
by bane 13y ago
I agree with the linked article. Games, or at the very least "good" games, with the Rift are DOA. The VR internet or metaverse or whatever is Carmack's idea as far as the public communication has been.
The metaverse or matrix or net or whatever is cool and all, and I'm also of the age where that idea is firmly in my head as one of the better use-cases for this kind of tech. But there are a million other use-cases for it too. The messaging that's come out from both Facebook and the Oculus team is that the metaverse now is "the" use-case for the tech.
I actually can't stop thinking about the Kinect. People who've taken the time to reverse engineer drivers for it have come up with all kinds of interesting applications for it, but MS bought it up and for many years none of those applications could become mainstream because of Microsoft's exclusivity on the technology. Now with the XBone it's a glorified remote control and the technology is still locked up.
The facebook purchase isn't just about games dying, it's about everything but facebook's vision for the peripheral dying and the exploitive and privacy violating way that facebook uses user data.
Games are also a pioneering medium for technology (just like Porn). Technology has been pushed forward in no small part because of gaming requirements. Games are not just "a" use-case of the rift, they would have been the primary use case, with everything else falling in behind on to a long tail.
In other words, if the raison d'être for the Rift is dead (games), then pretty much all other visionary use-cases for it are dead too.
This was my chief takeaway from the article
Let's be honest here, VR is going to be used for cyber-sex at some point. Do you think it's okay for FB to have records of who you've virtually seen, how long you virtually performed coitus, what virtual positions you liked and so on and so forth? What about the unknown party that FB sells that information to? You think you can hide behind an avatar or on-line persona? Since when did Facebook let people use handles? [1]
Some hypothetical terms of service where this isn't allowed protects you? What stops FB from just changing the terms without your knowledge because your life isn't as easy to monetize as Facebook would like?
Carmack and Abrash want to make the Metaverse because it's a very old and very cool dream. Zuckerberg wants to make the Metaverse because of the tremendous money making opportunities it creates. Imagine an entire universe you control and can endless plumb for dollars.
1 - https://www.facebook.com/help/292517374180078 https://www.facebook.com/help/292517374180078
- hosh 13y ago@bane, that's quite the fear. Games are at its core, a subset of experiences. The vast majority of games also reflect the attitudes modern society has: competition instead of cooperation, a fixation on leveling up, an obsession with generating enough realism to impart PTSD, a whole host of dysfunctional dynamics. I say this as one who have enjoyed shooters and strategy games. It is only in indie games you might find something different, something beyond: the upcoming Spirit game, DepressionQuest, Wild Divine, etc. And look at the kind of nerdrage DepressionQuest generated when the creators tried to get it on Steam. I will tell you, all the games out there don't have anything on the kinds of lucid dreams I sometimes have, for both the clarity and vividness as well as the insights gained from having experienced them. The impetus to create a game comes from the a deep, likely unconscious desire, to create non-ordinary experiences, and they are still pale imitation of the real thing. I don't mind that. However, the form in which those experience typically manifests are ... let's see, "tremendous money making opportunities". But thank you for writing what you did. It gave me an insight into why gamers and game dev feel so much rage over this. This dynamic is not about FB or Oculus; it is not about privacy; it looks like it is really about power and control. Games -- or at least, the typical games we have -- create an non-ordinary experience in which the gamer feels more control or power, and this buyout looks like it hit a big nerve with that, like it is taking that away.
- bane 13y agoYou bring up excellent points. I hadn't really as much considered the vibrant indie scene. One of the things that I think people who are passionate about games understand is creating and sharing an experience, and there's a kind of generosity involved. Of course as a game maker you may want to get paid for your time, and maybe make a little profit, but people make games because they love it (the working conditions are generally pretty poor compared to other places they could be using their skillsets). There's recently been a kind of pervasive over-monetization of games that's been happening more and more. The kind of small-experience, indie games and the like really aren't much more different and complex than the freeare and shareware games of the past, but all these free-to-play (with large in-app purchases) or digital only monthly subscription games and similar really set the hairs on the back of my neck on edge. I think the idea of games-as-art wasn't really understood until recently, and now that it is, it's being forgotten as quickly as possible in the big development houses. At the very least there's a few decades of unspoiled retrogames, emulation and the indie scene to keep it alive. I was very excited about a renaissance of this games-as-art vibe with the rift, with some as-yet-unknown dev in their basement building some quirky world or experience to explore (maybe not even in immersive 3d!) but I guess I have to wait now. So I'd add it's about power in both directions. Power for the gamers, but power for the game makers to craft the world of their vision as well. It's all been taken away.