4 ms·
The Oculus Buyout Rage Machine
- waterlesscloud 13y agoBlogspam, but... Wow, Derek Smart. There's a name I haven't heard in a while. And talk about knowing the rage machine... EDIT - nice long, recent piece on Derek Smart http://www.polygon.com/2012/11/14/3553620/the-redemption-of-derek-smart http://www.polygon.com/2012/11/14/3553620/the-redemption-of-...
- hga 13y agoMaybe. But as someone who knew essentially nothing about all this (RSI forced me to give up gaming in the mid-late '80s), the "blogspam" oriented me nicely, and the linked, "best of breed" essay is indeed truly good, well written and easily read and skimmed (I don't need exposition on Facebook's particular evils :-). And as someone who's VR interest can't be games it gives me something to look for in the future.
- LandoCalrissian 13y agoI was pretty surprised to see him too. Derek Smart's Desktop Commander! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIn1_9YvGds https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIn1_9YvGds
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- shiftpgdn 13y agohttp://www.somethingawful.com/news/derek-smart-not/ http://www.somethingawful.com/news/derek-smart-not/ Good times. It's funny he was even sued by Take 2 Interactive over how his horrible games damaged their IPO.
- marknutter 13y agoCould it be that VR has wider applications than just video games?
- sebnukem2 13y agoAdvertisement remains Real in Virtual Reality.
- WalterSear 13y agoNot yet. Not for a while.
- sebnukem2 13y agoI've seen similar outpouring of unconditional love for companies like Comcast, Bank of America, and Monsanto. I keep wondering why Facebook has so many users. It doesn't look good in the long term.
- chc 13y agoAll of those companies are massively successful. I'm not sure what you're trying to say here.
- doktrin 13y agoThe linked article was more important than the actual piece [1]. Although it was interesting, I still disagree with the final conclusion. FB taking over OVR doesn't mean they will "own" the entirety of whatever common VR-accessible space emerges. They're just another player in what will most likely be a hotly contested market. [1] http://assayviaessay.blogspot.com/2014/03/virtual-spaces-real-data.html http://assayviaessay.blogspot.com/2014/03/virtual-spaces-rea...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- hosh 13y agoI'm sorry a lot of game devs feel this way. As a gamer, I feel some sympathy for this. However, this is a case where the game devs are lacking in vision. (1) My very first impression of the news last week was: Wow, I did not know that Zuckerberg had the guts and vision. I did not respect Zuckerberg at all. After the news, I see it as not only a big move for Facebook, I also explicitly acknowledge Zuckerberg as a visionary. Where this can go will disrupt what we think of as social networking, and being able to throw away the work which you have a vested interest in in order to bring in something greater, that takes courage. (2) Discussing this with friends and then looking at what is emerging, it is pretty clear to me that this is not a vanity buy, and that the scope of Oculus has now been expanded to something much much greater than gaming. We're no longer talking about the next evolutionary stage of gaming; we're talking about the next fundamental shift in how the mainstream will interact on the internet. Gamers have this unconscious, perhaps implicit, understanding of what it means to interact with the virtual world; many folks in the mainstream do not. When this pans out in the mainstream (months? years?), it will create a shift in the psychology of individuals, something we have only seen discussed in sci-fi and cyberpunk stories. Or at least, that is the potential. Execution remains to be seen :-) (3) Game devs in general have great imagination. Like artists, filmmakers, game devs bring their vision out into the world for others to experience. They tend to have a better feel for the future, for what the world can be, than your average person. However, I find it ironic that the game devs are so fixated on Oculus Rift = Gaming Device, that this is one of the rare times game devs failed to see the greater vision. (4) Based on what Caramack, Palmer, and Abrash were talking about in the articles that have emerged ... until Zuckerberg showed up, they too also framed the Oculus tech as a gaming technology. That was what they sold it as in the Kickstarter, and many people were on board with it. So I understand how many gamers and game devs are up in arms about this. It's also kind of sad to me: these same folks who are so imaginative are failing to see the much grander vision.
- bane 13y agoI agree with the linked article. Games, or at the very least "good" games, with the Rift are DOA. The VR internet or metaverse or whatever is Carmack's idea as far as the public communication has been. The metaverse or matrix or net or whatever is cool and all, and I'm also of the age where that idea is firmly in my head as one of the better use-cases for this kind of tech. But there are a million other use-cases for it too. The messaging that's come out from both Facebook and the Oculus team is that the metaverse now is "the" use-case for the tech. I actually can't stop thinking about the Kinect. People who've taken the time to reverse engineer drivers for it have come up with all kinds of interesting applications for it, but MS bought it up and for many years none of those applications could become mainstream because of Microsoft's exclusivity on the technology. Now with the XBone it's a glorified remote control and the technology is still locked up. The facebook purchase isn't just about games dying, it's about everything but facebook's vision for the peripheral dying and the exploitive and privacy violating way that facebook uses user data. Games are also a pioneering medium for technology (just like Porn). Technology has been pushed forward in no small part because of gaming requirements. Games are not just "a" use-case of the rift, they would have been the primary use case, with everything else falling in behind on to a long tail. In other words, if the raison d'être for the Rift is dead (games), then pretty much all other visionary use-cases for it are dead too. This was my chief takeaway from the article Let's be honest here, VR is going to be used for cyber-sex at some point. Do you think it's okay for FB to have records of who you've virtually seen, how long you virtually performed coitus, what virtual positions you liked and so on and so forth? What about the unknown party that FB sells that information to? You think you can hide behind an avatar or on-line persona? Since when did Facebook let people use handles? [1] Some hypothetical terms of service where this isn't allowed protects you? What stops FB from just changing the terms without your knowledge because your life isn't as easy to monetize as Facebook would like? Carmack and Abrash want to make the Metaverse because it's a very old and very cool dream. Zuckerberg wants to make the Metaverse because of the tremendous money making opportunities it creates. Imagine an entire universe you control and can endless plumb for dollars. 1 - https://www.facebook.com/help/292517374180078 https://www.facebook.com/help/292517374180078
- hnnewguy 13y ago>“FB doesn’t make games and there’s not a single game related acquisition in the company’s history. More importantly, FB doesn’t acquire outside of a very specific set of focus supporting categories. They have zero professional experience with the market, and at best the kind of games FB hosts that other people make are pretty exploitive and dismal.” This whole paragraph can be dismissed by the optimists with the phrase: "...Until now". Why should the past be the same as the future?
- bane 13y agoThe past probably shouldn't be. After all Nintendo used to make playing cards. But the past does inform the future and provide it with likely vectors.
- higherpurpose 13y agoIf you don't want Facebookulus to "own VR" in the future, then it helps that not everyone likes Oculus anymore right now.
- comsat 13y agoHere's the scoop on Facebook's VR plan http://www.virtfriends.com/blog/2014/04/01/facebook-virtual-reality/ http://www.virtfriends.com/blog/2014/04/01/facebook-virtual-...
- malkia 13y agoLol Derek Smart... nothing more to be said....