3 ms·
I think the article overplays asian stereotypes. I, personally think that I fall into almost none of them. I'm rarely subservient and am generally anti-author
by dnautics 13y ago
I think the article overplays asian stereotypes. I, personally think that I fall into almost none of them. I'm rarely subservient and am generally anti-authoritarian. I speak up at meetings. All the time. I even called out a fellow postdoc for using a line graph when he should have used a bar graph (In a moment of passion I called the incorrect usage f---ing retarded, which then got picked up by the 80 year old nobel laureate in the lab). My science isn't terrible - I improved an enzyme four fold, which is a feat only a handful of people in the world can claim. I even started my own nonprofit with a future view of securing science funding outside of the traditional (and increasingly scarce) funding streams. Yet, I still can't advance beyond the "bamboo ceiling" and failed to obtain a faculty position in academia.
When applying to colleges, I only got into one school (although I only applied to six) - despite having rather good scores, but also having directed a full-length theatre production, and being captain of a regionally victorious chess team (which, you would think, would imply leadership potential). I even placed in my category at the International Science Fair and failed to get a position at MIT.
There's racism against Asians, it's deep-seated, and it's not going away anytime soon for many many reasons.
- corin_ 13y agoWithout commenting specifically on the accuracy or lack thereof of Asian stereotypes (my assumption is that they're massively exaggerated, as a side note), the fact that you don't fit them doesn't really mean anything. It's an accurate stereotype of human beings that they have two legs, but there are still people who can tell their story of how this stereotype doesn't fit them.
- fatjokes 13y ago> I even called out a fellow postdoc for using a line graph when he should have used a bar graph (In a moment of passion I called the incorrect usage f---ing retarded... That's an overreaction for a small error, don't you think? Not to mention unconstructively critical and unnecessarily antagonistic. Definitely not something I'd want to see coming from faculty.
- dnautics 13y agoYour biases are showing. Said postdoc is a very good friend and the delivery was not confrontational although perhaps surprising to the senior scientists. Data presentation is not a small error. A line graph implies a quantitative relationship between the ordinates in the independent variable, which did not exist in this case. And antagonism is not bad in science. Its certainly better than fealty or consensus.