3 ms·
> right now, we really don't have a surplus of labor. If we did, then the average standard of living would be really high That doesn't follow. It's quite possi
by jjoonathan 13y ago
> right now, we really don't have a surplus of labor. If we did, then the average standard of living would be really high
That doesn't follow. It's quite possible to simultaneously have
1. Capacity to produce plenty of available food, land, shelter, etc
2. Plenty of people willing to work for the food, land, and shelter
3. Lack of fed and sheltered people due to #2's labor having lower value than #1
There is no reason why the market determined value of labor (VOL) must exceed the market determined cost of living (COL). It happens. This is what people mean when they say that famine is a distribution problem, not a production problem. What they really mean is that it's an economic problem. Markets are entirely compatible with the notion of an underclass that cannot put food on the table, even amid abundance. Refer to the (e)book "Poverty and Famines" by Amartya Sen for examples and analysis. Exporting food while part of the populace starves isn't a stunt reserved for communist countries.
Thought experiment: there's a village with 100 peasants and surrounding land capable of producing 100 units of food if tended to by 75 laborers. The landowner hires 75 laborers, providing them each with 1 unit of food in return (supply of labor exceeds demand, so he has all the bargaining power). He sells the remaining 23 units at market in the neighboring town.
What do the 25 peasants that weren't needed do? Go to the neighboring town? What if nobody there is hiring either?
> That fact that we cannot provide a high enough average standard of living even when the incentive to work is very high, proves that drastically lowering the incentive to work would not provide a sufficient standard of living.
A high standard of living requires more than products of labor. Crucially, it requires control over resources. The market provides sufficient indirect control if VOL>COL. We can empirically and theoretically observe that that's not always the case.
- noonespecial 13y agoIt is also possible that your local regulatory climate makes producing at COL impossible for nearly everyone. If you aren't allowed to do something profitable until you've done a great deal of unprofitable compliance work, you can't produce and so don't. In practice this simplifies to "men with guns won't let you earn enough to live" and it can sneak up on a society.
- jjoonathan 13y agoErr, that's theoretically possible, but I don't think it's nearly as big of an issue. Can you point to an example? Because it seems that there are many more examples of "supply of labor exceeds demand, forcing 70% of the peasants to work for the minimum they can live on rather than the value of their labor, and forcing 30% of the peasants to live on nothing." Was your comment an underhanded jab at minimum wage? In that case I agree that MW is a poor solution, but I disagree that it's a net negative or responsible for the VOL/COL gap.