3 ms·
This is one of the most uplifting and positive stories I've read via HN. Whilst I understand that's probably not the most common take-away, I read it as a stor
by nl 13y ago
This is one of the most uplifting and positive stories I've read via HN.
Whilst I understand that's probably not the most common take-away, I read it as a story of how software development is slowly changing to a field where sexism is no longer acceptable.
I think it is fantastic that the developers stood up to Matti, and refused to give him the story he was looking for.
People will continue to argue all they like over if software development is a meritocracy and/or if different genders have differing natural inclinations towards the field.
All I know is that on that day there were two female developers who had gained enough respect from their peers that no one would fall into the trap of "providing a story" for the show.
I think that does all the developers involved credit.
Edit: Adriel Wallick (one of the developers involved) has written a blog post about it. I thought this bit was great:
I will not put my face and my “stamp of approval” on something where this is even a question. No, we are not at an advantage because we have women on our team and no, we are not at a disadvantage because we have women on our team. We all have advantages and disadvantages because of our varying skills and strengths. Having the audacity to be a woman does not hinder nor help any of these things. Being a woman simply means that we are women.
http://msminotaur.com/blog/?p=187 http://msminotaur.com/blog/?p=187
- fleitz 13y agoYeah, it's strange that they had to be smiling while holding the product, but misogyny was a completely fine thing to pair the brand with. Is Mountain Dew not fairing well with the minsogynst demo?
- ginko 13y ago> http://msminotaur.com/blog/?p=187 http://msminotaur.com/blog/?p=187 Really interesting read, but now my eyes hurt.
- rubinelli 13y agoSame post, on the much more readable Gamasutra: http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/AdrielWallick/20140331/214258/Lets_talk_about_accountability.php http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/AdrielWallick/20140331/214258...
- mikeash 13y agoWhy don't you just copy/paste the text into a text editor of your choice and read it there?
- rwallace 13y ago'I think it is fantastic that the developers stood up to Matti, and refused to give him the story he was looking for.' I agree completely. Nobody should put up with that sort of bullshit, and I'm glad the developers didn't. However, a comment from the linked account: 'But the people responsible for hiring those who ultimately destroyed it – they all contributed to a toxic environment, and they should be held accountable for that.' I must disagree with this. There is no such thing as precognition. How someone comes across in an interview is a weak predictor of how he performs on the job. With the best will in the world, sometimes an employer will make a mistake and hire the wrong person. And this mistake is already punished by law and custom more harshly than it should be. The result is that employers are incentivized to err strongly on the side of caution, to never give a candidate the benefit of any doubt, no matter how ill-founded. And this hurts everyone. It hurts good people who can't get a job because there's no absolute proof they'd be good hires. It hurts good people being abused by sociopathic bosses because they're afraid they wouldn't be able to get another job if they were fired. It hurts good people being paid below their worth because wages are bid down by the desperate. One way or another, it hurts you, and it hurts people you care about. The blame for the fiasco needs to be placed where it belongs: on Matti, not on the people who hired him without perfect foreknowledge of his future actions.
- nl 13y agoThe blame for the fiasco needs to be placed where it belongs: on Matti, not on the people who hired him without perfect foreknowledge of his future actions. This is absolutely true, so far as blame goes. But the people who hired him were responsible for him. That's how business works: a business cannot just reject responsibility for the actions of people acting for them because they subsequently find out they did bad things. The business can (and should) try to correct those thing, but they are accountable for it. And this mistake is already punished by law and custom more harshly than it should be. The result is that employers are incentivized to err strongly on the side of caution, to never give a candidate the benefit of any doubt, no matter how ill-founded. And this hurts everyone. It hurts good people who can't get a job because there's no absolute proof they'd be good hires. It hurts good people being abused by sociopathic bosses because they're afraid they wouldn't be able to get another job if they were fired. It hurts good people being paid below their worth because wages are bid down by the desperate. One way or another, it hurts you, and it hurts people you care about. I disagree with this. Yes, employers should be able to take risks on people, but at the same time a business can bring powerful resources to bear on something, and in the wrong hands those resources can be dangerous. A business absolutely should consider this when they hire, and should be held accountable if they make a mistake in hiring.