Neat idea but I think it could easily devolve into youtube grade flaming in the comments. Threading or (at the very least) engadget style comment grading, modi

Neat idea but I think it could easily devolve into youtube grade flaming in the comments. Threading or (at the very least) engadget style comment grading, modified so that the arguers can't vote each other down, would be top on my priority list. Some way to divide the argument by paragraphs and vote up and down each one might be nice, as well. IMO it's difficult to boil down any comment worth making into an integer, let alone a boolean, particularly if controversy is involved.