5 ms·
Germany bans managers from calling or emailing staff after work hours
- Argorak 13y agoMisleading title. The german labor ministry, not Germany as a whole, is doing that. Not even other ministries. They follow several major companies (VW was one of the first, AFAIK).
- phreeza 13y agoThe missing pronoun makes all the difference. Funny how it would have been completely clear had it been the ministry of defense.
- arrrg 13y agoAnd even in the companies far from everyone is covered by that policy. (It’s still a good policy.)
- jessriedel 13y agoSo the labor ministry (basically the department of labor for us Americans) is a part of the German government with the power to institute nationwide rules regulating labor, but in this case it's just the ministry that is applying a rule to itself? Is that right?
- Argorak 13y agoThis is really just internals for the ministry, in their role as an employer, yes.
- dang 13y agoThat kind of linkbait is such bullshit, and so annoying, that I'm not going to bother to correct the title. I'm going to bury this post. Thanks Agorak. HN users: When submitting a story, you're responsible for making sure that it isn't something like this. You've read the story, the rest of us haven't, and there's no way the moderators can read them all. Do your due diligence and help us all optimize HN for signal/noise.
- kale 13y agoI understand the reasoning behind it, but is the e-mail part necessary? I often e-mail people that I know are on vacation for things that aren't time sensitive, mainly to ensure that I don't forget to notify them of something. I would hope that they wouldn't check work e-mail, or at least ignore it. I'd never call them off-hours unless it was an emergency. E-mail is a type of communication where the receiver can be in control of receipt and response. Should a manager type up an e-mail (if it's after work hours), save it, then write a note (or schedule a delayed send) to send it in the morning? It seems cumbersome and seems like it wouldn't address the core problem, unlike telephone calls.
- Argorak 13y agoThe usual implementation is that the email is not relayed during the night. You can still send. The idea behind these rules is to make it crystal-clear that no one can expect you to be reachable outside of office, which became somewhat a problem in the last years.
- duaneb 13y agoI would hope—I dare not say imagine—that the law would simply not require any response (or even reading it) outside of work hours.
- javanix 13y agoIsn't "except in emergencies" just asking for a company to liberally define "emergency"?
- Argorak 13y agoMost larger companies have time tracking and pay extra hours in such cases. If that happens too often, controlling will definitely like to have a word with you. I worked for multiple larger corps as a freelancer and they are very strict about "8 hours per day". They did the math and know that if I work 10, they pay 2 hours for the same price, but at less efficiency.
- eric_the_read 13y agoFYI, idiomatic English would read, "They did the math," not "They made the math."
- Argorak 13y agoYep, it is way beyond idiomatic time in germany ;). Thanks for the correction, you are right ;).
- drcube 13y agoThere are plenty of jobs where you're technically always on call. Firefighters, paramedics, doctors, soldiers, etc. What stops employers from simply informing their employees that, from now on, they are all on call 24 hours a day?
- Argorak 13y agoBe aware that the employers themselves are making those rules. The idea actually comes from car manufacturers in Germany. Also, all the jobs you mentioned have contractual clauses regulating that, like payment for emergency work and payment for on-call duty.
- pjmlp 13y agoThis is why I enjoy doing IT and living in Germany. At my current employer, the typical US 50h+ weeks would be squashed by the works council.
- blisterpeanuts 13y agoWhat if your colleagues are in the U.S.? Do you just turn off the phone until 9am the next day? I'm on the east coast in the U.S. and I have colleagues in Britain, Germany, California, Colorado, and Minneapolis. If we stuck to strict working hours, we'd never be able to communicate in real time! The guys in Europe sometimes are helping us until 10pm or 11pm which is not a requirement but they're just dedicated and we really appreciate it. By the same token, I'll get on a call at 6am local time, which works for them. But maybe not everyone has to deal with all these time zones. We're a little crazy.
- pjmlp 13y ago> What if your colleagues are in the U.S.? Do you just turn off the phone until 9am the next day? Yes, and I do work a lot with Asia actually. On the projects that require me not to do it, we have special agreements in place, where people are also compensated for sacrificing their private life in name of the employers profits. > The guys in Europe sometimes are helping us until 10pm or 11pm which is not a requirement but they're just dedicated and we really appreciate it. By the same token, I'll get on a call at 6am local time, which works for them. Not all companies have works councils, which leads to the following situations: We have the guys fresh out of university feeling that they will improve their career by working like crazy. Only to discover a few years later that they get to be fired like everyone else on the company. There are lots of people working as freelancer and getting paid by the hour. Obviously they are their own boss and work as much as they feel like like it. Not all companies have a works council that actively cares about the fellow employees, in such cases many people don't report back to them unlawful situations due to fear of what their boss might do.
- oxryly1 13y agoShould delete this due to misleading title.
- balls187 13y agoCurious that the HN community thinks about this. Is this such a problem that the some Labor Ministry has to enforce a rule? Think of this in another context: would people be okay with Olympic Trainers being banned from asking their athletes to train after hours?
- 6d0debc071 13y ago> Is this such a problem that the some Labor Ministry has to enforce a rule? Dunno, don't have the data. Anecdotally: I get called after hours from time to time, but then again I get paid a lot in return. Calling me after work, whatever you want, costs several hundred pounds a go. My sister, who works a bunch of part time jobs in retail and other minimum wage things get called on after hours as well. And she doesn't get paid for it beyond not being fired. She'd never dare tell one of her managers not to call her after work, because if she loses one of her jobs she's going to have trouble paying her bills. In my case the conditions in my contract ensure that I only get called if it's important. That's my protection from being constantly exploited. But... my sister doesn't have that - and frankly has no hope of ever having it. Should it be legal to take that sort of advantage of someone in that weak a bargaining position? We have the concept of undue influence in contract law, and this strikes me as the same sort of thing. It's like when you have a contract between two companies, the companies are expected to be protected by having a contract that they both understand and have negotiated from positions of relative equality. Whereas, between companies and individuals, the individual is generally expected to be mostly protected by the allowances of consumer protection law. > would people be okay with Olympic Trainers being banned from asking their athletes to train after hours? Well, I would. If the athlete does it of their own free will, then that's fine. But if they're being coerced by a desire not to get fired... well, 'Fuck you, pay me.' springs to mind.
- balls187 13y ago> But if they're being coerced by a desire not to get fired... well, 'Fuck you, pay me.' springs to mind. Agreed. Exploiting = bad.
- rsync 13y agoI've never understood this aspect of European culture. What's a manager ? What are staff ? Presuming that the state has formalized definitions for these things, what is the purpose ? Why is it assumed that someone is, or has, an employer, and why would we pigeonhole people into extremely narrow (and increasingly irrelevant) social roles ?
- adamors 13y agoFirst, read the article and you'll see that the title is misleading. It concerns only the staff of the German labour ministry. Second, Germany =/= Europe.
- blisterpeanuts 13y ago"Self-exploitation." Isn't that newspeak for what we used to call hard work?