4 ms·
One of the huge problems you have in this debate is the question of cause and effect. Does porn cause harm? That it does is indisputable. There are many case
by einhverfr 13y ago
One of the huge problems you have in this debate is the question of cause and effect.
Does porn cause harm? That it does is indisputable. There are many cases where men report decreased sexual performance as a result of watching too much porn (that is a harm particularly if it interferes with close intimate relationships). If nothing else, that is a harm. Does it cause harm on the balance? That, however, is unknowable.
But the harms which are readily documented don't match the harms which are posited. The harms which are posited are also readily observed but a causal connection is impossible to draw. Our culture has for the better part of a century (since probably the 1920's or at least 1930's) slowly been decoupling sexuality, marriage, and reproduction. Pornography may be seen as a consequence of that separation, but it certainly cannot be seen as the primary cause given the timing. Whether it furthers and further entrenches a pattern of hedonistic sex may indeed not matter -- it is only one small piece of a much larger cultural pattern.
So in the end, I don't know if it causes the harms portrayed. What is clear is that a failure to deal with the context rather than the technology is a much larger problem.
- GotAnyMegadeth 13y ago> Does porn cause harm? That it does is indisputable. Isn't the whole point of this thread, and the whole international debate, that it is disputable?
- aaronem 13y agoIt would appear so: > Does porn cause harm? That it does is indisputable. > So in the end, I don't know if it causes the harms portrayed. But, hey, what's a little internal inconsistency when you're urging everyone forward into the past?
- einhverfr 13y agoWhat's wrong with trying to preserve or even revive the social institutions of the past? I am of the opinion that as energy prices continue to rise, we are going to find that retirement with the kids comes back (this is already starting). If that become the norm, the implications for marriage and sexuality are quite significant. But the point of my downvoted post is that you can't take an element of culture and assume that it is responsible for other elements. These things form tangled webs, not linear chains of cause and effect.