13 ms·
Does Porn Hurt Children?
- einhverfr 13y agoOne of the huge problems you have in this debate is the question of cause and effect. Does porn cause harm? That it does is indisputable. There are many cases where men report decreased sexual performance as a result of watching too much porn (that is a harm particularly if it interferes with close intimate relationships). If nothing else, that is a harm. Does it cause harm on the balance? That, however, is unknowable. But the harms which are readily documented don't match the harms which are posited. The harms which are posited are also readily observed but a causal connection is impossible to draw. Our culture has for the better part of a century (since probably the 1920's or at least 1930's) slowly been decoupling sexuality, marriage, and reproduction. Pornography may be seen as a consequence of that separation, but it certainly cannot be seen as the primary cause given the timing. Whether it furthers and further entrenches a pattern of hedonistic sex may indeed not matter -- it is only one small piece of a much larger cultural pattern. So in the end, I don't know if it causes the harms portrayed. What is clear is that a failure to deal with the context rather than the technology is a much larger problem.
- GotAnyMegadeth 13y ago> Does porn cause harm? That it does is indisputable. Isn't the whole point of this thread, and the whole international debate, that it is disputable?
- aaronem 13y agoIt would appear so: > Does porn cause harm? That it does is indisputable. > So in the end, I don't know if it causes the harms portrayed. But, hey, what's a little internal inconsistency when you're urging everyone forward into the past?
- einhverfr 13y agoWhat's wrong with trying to preserve or even revive the social institutions of the past? I am of the opinion that as energy prices continue to rise, we are going to find that retirement with the kids comes back (this is already starting). If that become the norm, the implications for marriage and sexuality are quite significant. But the point of my downvoted post is that you can't take an element of culture and assume that it is responsible for other elements. These things form tangled webs, not linear chains of cause and effect.
- adnam 13y ago"It turns out that the research suggesting that teenagers and pornography are a hazardous mix is far from definitive." [Devil's advocate] If you had children, would you need peer-reviewed literature to inform your decision to allow them access to pornhub? And similarly, if you were a politician elected by people with children?
- baddox 13y agoI would certainly want peer-reviewed literature to make either decision. Granted, that's not always available, so sometimes you have to make default decisions without good evidence.
- aaronem 13y agoImagine your surprise when it turns out not to be up to you! That sounds flippant, perhaps, but behold: I knew lots of kids growing up whose (usually extreme Southern Baptist) parents tried to prevent them getting hold of porn, but I didn't know even a single one whose parents succeeded at so doing; those who couldn't get it themselves, and who didn't have friends willing to share, at the very least had acquaintances willing to be paid or otherwise persuaded to serve as brokers. This held true even during the year I spent in a Mississippi reform school which operated as an arm of a Roman Catholic monastery, and where getting caught with such outrageous contraband bought you a half-dozen wallops on the bare ass with a razor strap from a monk who was serious about it, the sort of thing that'd leave you sitting lightly for the better part of a week. I'm not sure whether anyone actually believed this had any dissuasive effect on the older students' desire to possess pornography, but anyone who did so believe was destined to be disappointed; indeed, the only effect such punishments had was as a strong incentive to develop the skills of misdirection, concealment, and lying with a straight face. (Me, I'm a cynic, and I half suspect that that was the whole point. If so, whoever designed the curriculum deserves some sort of award for unparalleled effectiveness in pedagogy.) The point is, even in an environment which was by design totally inimical to it, everyone who wanted it had as much porn as he could keep hidden. (Which, in a couple of memorable cases, was a three-ring binder full.) In a more permissive environment, where hiding one's stash was a simple matter of keeping it out of sight -- rather than, say, getting hold of a contraband razor blade and waiting until after lights-out to carefully slit a mattress seam where it didn't show -- the question didn't even arise, even for those of us not so fortunate as to have what was then the rare prize of unmonitored access to the Internet. Now? You'd have to not only homeschool your kids, but keep them locked up in the basement all the rest of the time, and even then I wouldn't lay odds against their finding some way to get hold of porn -- after all, in extremis, all it really takes is a hormonally overheated imagination and a pencil, and the pencil is optional.
- aaronem 13y agoOnly if it falls on them. Stack your DVDs and magazines carefully, folks. More substantively: When divided into "pro-impact" and "no-impact" groups for the "improvised debate" mentioned in the article, the former camp is described as having essentially parroted all the various arguments their elders make for pornography being bad for teenagers, while the latter camp had no such arguments for the position they were assigned to defend. Segal is (somewhat) careful to avoid explicitly drawing any inferences from that, but the obvious implication is that the "pro-impact" camp is correct ("Given that pornography is emotionally charged, it would be shocking if it had no impact.") Leaving aside the question of what a small cohort of randomly selected 16-to-18-year-olds, an age not generally noted for its keen introspective abilities, can be expected to know about much of anything, I'd be curious to find out whether the cohort which produced this result had had anything like equal exposure to both sides of the debate, or whether instead the "pro-impact" kids drubbed the "no-impact" ones because only the former had been fed lines beforehand.
- thaumasiotes 13y ago> "Given that pornography is emotionally charged, it would be shocking if it had no impact." I realize you're not making that argument yourself, but it strikes me as exceptionally weak. The "obvious" response is that it's been extremely difficult to document any experiences as having measurable impacts on children (starvation is a big exception, but hopefully it's not too difficult to see what might make that different...). So the baseline expectation should be a fairly strong confidence that no matter what it is that you're showing children, the effect is likely too small to measure.
- iSnow 13y ago>Leaving aside the question of what a small cohort of randomly selected 16-to-18-year-olds This stood out for me as a very weak part of the article. Cite studies and meta-studies that substantiate some relatively minor impact of porn on personal development and then turn around, toss the scientific way of thinking and take some random sample of teenagers in a non-controlled environment as the ultimate measurement.
- cstross 13y agoMinor nit wrt. the first paragraph: the UK's mandatory "family-friendly filters" only apply to consumer internet accounts. It's possible to get a BT Infinity business account without any company letterhead or ID -- it just costs a bit more (and a provides a better quality of service, with no net nanny in the way because your IT department is supposed to do that for you). And there are ISPs (Andrews and Arnold -- http://www.aa.net.uk/ http://www.aa.net.uk/ -- spring to mind) whose approach to government-mandated family-friendly filtering is robust and principled: http://www.aa.net.uk/kb-broadband-realinternet.html http://www.aa.net.uk/kb-broadband-realinternet.html (I'll probably be moving there when my BT contract is up). (Also, Tunnelbear is my friend.) However: regardless of whether porn harms children (disclosure: everything I've read, from the Meese Commission report onwards, says that it doesn't), the problem with the net.nanny filters is that they're indiscriminate and over-block important material that is not the ostensible target of the block. Want to find out about breast cancer? Good luck with that -- breasts are of course only ever of interest in an erotic context. Teenagers wanting to explore non-mainstream aspects of their sexuality are SOL; LGBT content is commonly blocked. And so on. This shouldn't be a problem for sensible parents -- who will opt out, and discuss the issues face-to-face with their kids -- but is storing up lots of trouble down the line. Not to mention providing a temptation for politicians who might want to follow that nice Mr Erdogan's example and censor viewpoints hostile to them. And meanwhile, Page Three of the Sun remains on display in every newsagent and supermarket in the UK.
- DanBC 13y agoI agree that internet filtering is a broken idea. But there are people who think that porn does change behaviour. They might. Have a point - hairlessness seems to have come from porn. While it's weird that breasts are displayed in a national newspaper (not because they're breasts, but because that paper is so judgemental about s lot of things. See also Daily Mail "all grown up" while shreKing about paedophiles) unclothed breats are not the "problem" that filters should be addressing. 1) it easy to find extreme, graphic, porn for free. 2) some parents find it difficult to filter that porn. 3) we don't want health or sexuality etc information to be filtered. These are hard problems to solve and it is immensely frustrating that Government ignores all the expert advice they get about the difficulties. I tend to welcome a "can do" attitude ("you're Google! You can do this!") it should be realistic. I have a child and I honestly have no idea how I am going to talk to them about porn.
- morgante 13y agoCiting Betteridge's law of headlines, I'm going to say no. Scientists are having a hard time proving that porn even has an impact, let alone that the impact is negative. What are they even looking for? That children will somehow start practicing BDSM after stumbling on porn? That their "precious minds" are tainted by the Real World?
- XorNot 13y agoI know you don't mean it, but the air of judgement in the way you've used BDSM there, shouldn't be. People who do practice BDSM are not somehow damaged, and would be the first to state that the "dominant" person is in fact not in that relationship.
- robobro 13y agoIt's probably rhetorical.
- aaronem 13y agoOh, I don't know; looking back on my time in the scene, I don't think it unreasonable to say that most of the people I knew who practiced BDSM -- myself included -- were in some way "damaged", if that's the word you want to use. Of course such is not by any means required, but in at least some cohorts there's a strong correlation.
- rmc 13y agoWhat's wrong with BDSM? You say it like "practicing BDSM" is a bad thing.
- leaveyou 13y agobecause BDSM hurts ? (I really don't know, I only guess that's why the OP used BDSM as an example)
- zxcdw 13y agoBut is that a bad thing if it is something one enjoys? I find it saddening that people should be ashamed of their fetishes and whatnot, like it's a taboo. Why couldn't we just express our sexuality openly and the way we want to without social stigma surrounding it? If there's something I think which needs disruption in our Western societies, it is human sexuality. What's holding us back and with what arguments?
- d0ugie 13y agoPerhaps the instinct of adults to shield children from the likes of pornography, and even the Catcher in the Rye itself, is akin to Holden Caulfield's desire the children from becoming "phonies" like the adults who had been exposed to whatever in life he saw as the catalyst of said phoniness. Only now after so many years from having read the Cliffs Notes do I realize that Holden was "catching" the children from the Rye that was pornography - more specifically to what J. D. Salinger had in mind, bittorrent clients and Kazaa. :)
- leaveyou 13y agomy suspicion is that governments don't really care that much about teenagers (maybe a little about children, but parents still care more). porn is just an addictive product like alcohol and tobacco and governments want to tax it (more), and they can't if it's so plentiful and easily accessible on the internet. maybe these are just first small steps towards restricting supply and imposing taxes.
- robobro 13y agoAddiction to alcohol leads to cancers and withdrawals can lead to death. Psychologically, addiction can make folks violent or take unnecessary risks. Cigarettes cause cancers not only in you but in those around you. They smell to high hell too. Porn is not physically addictive and is not physically harmful. It's just as addictive as video games, television, or any other form of entertainment. If your argument against it's that it can help form unnecessary habits, we may as well ban free speech so that we can block all forms of entertainment that offend you.
- meric 13y ago"Porn is not physically addictive." Oh but it can be addictive. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pornography_addiction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pornography_addiction
- aaronem 13y agoAnything that provokes a dopamine dump can be addictive. What's your point?
- throw-away4 13y agoSo in short, anything can be addictive.
- meric 13y agoIt's disingenuous to suggest it's "not physically addictive", it makes it sound like there's no danger of addiction, yet there is actually a significant portion of the population who when consuming porn regularly do get addicted, just like cigarettes.
- throw-away4 13y agoPersonally I started watchin porn on the internet at age of 7 and more actively at age of 10. I have not noticed any sign of it negatively affecting me. E: “If we start teaching kids about equality and respect when they are 5 or 6 years old --" And what does this BS SJW propaganda have to do with porn? It's just a way for people to get off.
- agumonkey 13y agoHow is your social life ? I'd be worried for people who only see sexual relationships, and somehow all relationships through cheaply crafted pornography.
- throw-away4 13y agoMy social life is just like I'd want it to be. I got few close friends that I can trust and that's all I asked for. If someone only sees sexual relationships it's probably not caused by pornography at young age but some other mental problems. You mustn't mix up porn and relationships because frankly they don't have anything to do with eachother.
- vertex-four 13y agoAnd how do we give kids the mental tools to understand the difference between porn and real relationships/sex, and at roughly what stage of development? That's what I want to see research on, personally. Blocking porn isn't going to help; learning how to teach kids to successfully maintain a concrete barrier between porn and the real world is.
- throw-away4 13y agoThey don't need any more mental capacity to diviate porn from real life than what they need with regular cartoons or other children's shows.
- aaronem 13y agoEvery kid (ideally) learns the difference between "real" and "not real", and, more subtly, the difference between "valid example" and "don't trust this, it lies" (e.g., most television, which is exaggerated for effect). I've seen plenty of assertions that porn is a special case for which the general lesson doesn't suffice, but never yet run across a supporting argument which didn't reduce to "well, because genitals are involved." Which, I mean, I understand why that would seem to an ape like a sensible thing to say, if an ape could talk, which we can. But I'm curious to know whether anyone has a genuinely novel argument to make in defense of the proposition.
- return0 13y agoHow can there ever be evidence for physical (psychophysical) harm to children who watch adults have sex? We 're like the only species who copulate in private, so it seems hugely presumptuous to argue that it is harmful. I think the greater harm is done by the continuous brainwashing with messaging that suggests that sex is the ultimate reward and is somehow connected to your value as a person, and is a thing you can trade.
- mariuolo 13y agoI read once that it's very difficult to assess any harm due to the near impossibility of creating control groups (that is, people who have never been exposed to porn).