6 ms·
Intellectual property is an Americanism that metastasized. It's a global idea not because of it's own merits, but because it was propelled by American treaties
by Zigurd 13y ago
Intellectual property is an Americanism that metastasized. It's a global idea not because of it's own merits, but because it was propelled by American treaties and diplomacy during an era when America was dominant.
One irony in that is the fact that the Framers were skeptical of intellectual property. In fact, they didn't call it intellectual property. Even less did they call it "intellectual property rights." It was a temporarily granted monopoly. It was not considered to be a right.
How is that? All your actual rights are assumed to exist. The Bill of Rights explicitly says it isn't the List of Rights. That's because your rights predate any laws and constitutions. You simply have them, and governments are more or less just in observing that you have rights and in not trampling them.
This is key to making the US constitution future-proof. It carves out a set of legitimate powers. It doesn't enumerate your rights: to travel by car or jet-pack, or space-warp, to use unbreakable codes, to marry the person you love, etc.
Patents and copyright monopolies, on the other hand, are explicitly granted, and, unlike your rights, they expire. The congress could at a whim change patent and copyright terms to a week, a day, a nanosecond, and there would be no constitutional case against that law. Because these grants of monopoly are NOT rights.
- m1sta_ 13y agoThe United States did not invent the idea of intellectual property.
- Zigurd 13y ago"Intellectual property" is a neologism. It isn't property at all. It isn't a right. And what does "intellectual" mean in this context? That phrase was not in use in jurisdictions from which the Framers got the idea to allow patent and copyright monopolies.
- m1sta_ 13y agoCan you see an argument for how both physical property rights and intellectual property rights are both government granted rights?
- Zigurd 13y agoNo. At least that's not how rights were seen by the authors of the US constitution.
- Retric 13y agoNo. There government mandated monopolies just like your local electric company. At it's core IP is a set of short term privileges gained in exchange for making your ideas public. Most obviously you don't gain IP for ideas that stay in your head. Medieval guilds are in many ways the precursor to IP except the ability to manufacture something was what's being protected not the knowledge of how to manufacture it. The interesting part of this is that privilege could easily be revoked. However, this promoted a lot of secrecy and good ideas where often lost, so patents protect only those shared secrets.
- harshreality 13y agoYes, but... there's a difference in what happens when you try to do away with them. Society without physical property rights requires everyone to abide by fair evaluation of what they need and what others need; otherwise, anti-communal individuals take things in order to enrich themselves. The people they take from are either non-violent and end up not being able to feed or clothe themselves—limited only by the conscience of the person taking unfairly—or else there's extra-legal armed conflict. Even if everyone agrees to the principle of equitable sharing, a communal ideal, there are still mismatches in different people's evaluation functions of need and ability. I think the drug market can be viewed as a microcosm of that. There are no state-enforced property rights in drugs, at least none that anyone outside the drug trade takes seriously. It doesn't turn out very well for anyone involved in the market. Even those who get rich from it are at greatly increased risk of turning up dead. Abolishing IP would affect income streams, but so does outsourcing, automation , and change in particular job markets or industries... the onward march of progress. I don't see that as a reason why it shouldn't be done.
- SeanLuke 13y ago> Intellectual property is an Americanism that metastasized. Patents were invented in Venice and Copyrights in England before the Colonies even existed. Trademarks date from the 13th century. > One irony in that is the fact that the Framers were skeptical of intellectual property. In fact, they didn't call it intellectual property. One should hope so, given that the term was invented in Europe the 19th century, and was (and still is largely) a European concept. > How is that? All your actual rights are assumed to exist. These aren't inalienable rights in the sense you're using (and abusing). They're rights in the sense of "copyRIGHT". It's an old alternative use of the term.
- 001sky 13y agoPatents and trademarks are not "intellectual property". They are temporary monopoly privledges. Before the americans came along, these ideas were blatant and well understood. Somewhere around the time of thr french revolution, rewarding special interests with monopoly privledges became scary, because it seemed an awful lot like the fake rights given to the aristocracy. So the monopolists and the special interest lobby re-packaged the same crap in the lingo of the french revolution and the enlightenment. The "enlightened" marketing PR spin for government granted monopoly became "rights" as a result. The "intellectual" was adopted under the umpbrella of meritocracy and rule by the learned (ie, as opposed to "birth" rights). Every time someone repeats this phrase its just old-skool marketing and brainwashing at work.
- rayiner 13y agoI hate to break it to you, but all property is a government granted monopoly. This place I call "my yard" isn't "mine" in any real sense. I didn't make it. It has existed long before I was born and will exist long after I'm gone. I can't defend it, I don't have any guns or ammo. But I have exclusive use of it ("a monopoly") because the government granted it to me.
- burntsushi 13y agoIt is worth drawing a distinction between that which requires a coercive third party like government to enforce (e.g., intellectual property) and that which does not require such a thing (defending property). The distinction is a direct consequence of the fact that intellectual property isn't actually property. (Because it is not scarce.)
- rayiner 13y agoIts silly to call it American on the copyright side, most of the increases in term lengths have come from Europe. Indeed, while its viewed as a temporary monopoly in the US, in Europe it's based on the idea of moral rights of the author.
- ddebernardy 13y ago> during an era when America was dominant Was? Maybe I'm living in some kind of alternate reality... Mind expanding on which country or group thereof comes even close to having the same levels of economic activity, military might and diplomatic influence as the US?
- precisioncoder 13y agoThe EU and China are the other big players right now. Both approach America in both economic, military and diplomatic influence.
- loup-vaillant 13y agoThe EU is fragmented right now. We still don't have a unified European government (state are still somewhat sovereign). We still don't have a unified international representation. And we still don't have a unified army.
- ddebernardy 13y agoEU? Economic, yes: it's indeed as large (in fact, larger) than the US. Military, not really: US outspends all of its close allies combined. Diplomatic: they're so fragmented they can't get anything done. China? Economic, hardly: it's getting there, but it's entirely dependent on the US consuming its output. Military: they're outgunned 6:1 by the US alone in terms of spending. Diplomatic: not the slightest bit, except on its immediate neighbors (and in Africa, to an extent, if you count showering local strong men with cash as influence).