3 ms·
Since this is not some across the board sweepingly true generalization, I suspect there are a number of factors at play as to when this helps and when it hurts.
by Mz 13y ago
Since this is not some across the board sweepingly true generalization, I suspect there are a number of factors at play as to when this helps and when it hurts. Some possibilities as to when and why it might hurt:
1) Social pressure to fail. Let's say you announce your plans to lose weight -- to your best friend who is also overweight and who bonds with you over burgers and beer on a regular basis. Or to your thin sibling who likes being "the attractive, thin sibling." Or someone else who has some reason to want you to not succeed, whether to preserve the current relationship or to preserve the pecking order (oh, god, how I loathe pecking order). You have just opened the door to letting them subtly sabotage you.
2) You don't really, truly want a promotion/weight loss/whatever, you just want other people to think highly of you. Announcing it can achieve the social recognition piece of it (in the short term -- until people decide you are a loser and failure for not doing it). In a case like this, it may have nothing to do with undermining your own actual goals. The whole point may be to get others off your back because you don't really want to do those things but you want to be liked, esteemed, whatever.
3) Announcing a goal to potential competitors who, again, have reason to want to undermine you or best you. So announcing a goal to get promoted at work to coworkers who are potential competitors can also result in opening yourself to sabotage or notifying someone else they need to work harder than you to beat you to it. If you want to get promoted, tell friends and family and maybe your boss but don't tell "the competition." Same with business goals or other goals where your success depends in part on outdoing someone else and where stating your goals may provide valuable intelligence to the enemy.
4) Situations where it looks like some kind of bragging because you are announcing something that seems like a really huge goal. People may undermine you out of spite or jealousy or just because they think you are talking BS.
I find it helps to talk to people about my goals in situations where such discussions help me move forward -- help me problem solve in some way. I find that ANNOUNCING -- LOOK AT ME, LOOK AT ME -- doesn't help. I mostly don't look for "emotional support" for my goals. If you need "emotional support" for your goals, yes, just announcing it may get you the warm fuzzies you were looking for without doing anything further. I look for practical support, not a cheerleading squad. I think that's probably the difference.
- taigeair 13y agoYour explanation is better than the article for my understanding. Thanks.