4 ms·
I don't know what's the X11 protocol, but to think a protocol can be "ASIC resistant" looks naive Scrypt has a bigger memory footprint, but ASICs can work with
by raverbashing 13y ago
I don't know what's the X11 protocol, but to think a protocol can be "ASIC resistant" looks naive
Scrypt has a bigger memory footprint, but ASICs can work with more memory, no problem
Not to mention decreasing mineability may end up isolating their fork (causing their value to go down)
- thirsteh 13y agoThe point of scrypt isn't really to be "ASIC-resistant", but to make it much more expensive to build ASICs to efficiently reverse its outputs.
- raverbashing 13y agoI haven't heard any explanation why this would be so Ok, this explains a little bit about X11 http://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/21bely/have_you_already_heard_of_x11_hashing_algorithm/ http://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/21bely/have_... But whatever a GPU can do, a properly designed ASIC can do as well It seems they're counting on implementation time for new ASICs for this algorithm.
- thirsteh 13y agoIndeed. They seem to be switching out and tunable unpredictable memory access (i.e. have to spend a lot of money building an ASIC with a lot of die area -- see the scrypt paper to understand why: https://www.tarsnap.com/scrypt/scrypt.pdf https://www.tarsnap.com/scrypt/scrypt.pdf) for a faster but more "obfuscated" construction. The circuit needed to implement this will be more complex, but it will be much cheaper to mass-produce. In short, this is what happens when people who know nothing about cryptography try to sell their unexamined constructions.
- smtddr 13y ago>>I don't know what's the X11 protocol, but to think a protocol can be "ASIC resistant" looks naive. Maybe you shouldn't claim something to be naive when you don't know anything about it?
- raverbashing 13y agoDo you know what an ASIC is? Please tell me what computation can be done in a GPU that can't be done in a specifically designed ASIC.
- smtddr 13y agoNote the poster said "ASIC resistant" not "ASIC proof". Kind of like a pub/priv key is not uncrackable - just that the resources required to crack it are excessive enough that almost nobody can attempt it and get meaningful results. Maybe x11 requires something that would make ASICs very expensive to produce or maybe some kind of legal loophole where shipping ASICs, rather than GPUs, implementing the algo is a legal problem in target countries. I'm not saying I support the poster; frankly I'm just ignoring it until it comes from someone with authority. At the same time, I'm not writing this person off as naive until it is shown why x11-ASICs would be just as legal, simple & cost-effective as any other cryptocoin ASICs out there. I also realize that one could look at this from the other side and leave the burden of proof on the poster. He/She needs to show why an x11-asic would be hard to produce because of cost and/or legality. So... I'm neutral, but with a -0.01 since this doesn't look to be anyone of significant importance in LTC community.
- tromp 13y ago| ASICs can work with more memory, no problem Up to a point. When you need more memory than fits on a single chip, you have to incur off-chip delays in accessing memory. Basically your ASIC is now just an application specific manycore CPU that needs to interface to commodity DRAM. At which point it may not have much advantage over commodity CPUs...