4 ms·
One possibility is that Dropbox deduplicate files (they almost certainly do), and somebody else had a public copy of the same file, and that was given a DMCA ta
by jstanley 13y ago
One possibility is that Dropbox deduplicate files (they almost certainly do), and somebody else had a public copy of the same file, and that was given a DMCA takedown, which now also applies to his copy since it's the same file even though it's private.
- bashcoder 13y agoI should hope it doesn't work that way, because under section 117 of the Copyright Act I'm allowed to keep an archival copy. [0] [0] http://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-digital.html http://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/faq-digital.html
- vpeters25 13y agoThere is nothing in dropbox's message suggesting he cannot upload or access archival copies. It says they got a dmca notice so they disabled sharing on some of them. This is either a bug on dropbox where the message shows to anyone having some flagged file(s), or he was sharing copyrighted content and conveniently emptied the folder before taking the screen capture to paint dropbox in a worse light.
- cordite 13y agoDidn't stop youtube from preventing me from downloading a video I uploaded where the video content was entirely my own.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoDropbox definitely deduplicates. There used to be a cladstine app out there called "Dropship" or "Airship"; it would extract the hash of a file from your local Dropbox SQLite database; you would provide that to someone else, which the app would then insert into their database. Dropbox would immediately start syncing the file. Dropbox asked the author to take down the app, and now Dropbox does additional consistency checks to prevent this use case. EDIT: Dropship: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dropship_(software) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dropship_(software)
- holyjaw 13y agoI don't understand the point of Drophsip; why not just share the file with the person and let them sync it the normal way?
- nitrogen 13y agoThe point AIUI (I'm not a Dropbox user) was to make Dropbox think you have a copy of the file already just by having its hash, allowing widespread sharing of the hash without implicating a specific origin by a direct sharing link. The files would sync into your private folder, avoiding DMCA takedowns (before they fixed it). I read about it on HN, so a search of HN's archives might give you more information or correct anything I got wrong.