4 ms·
Right, because if the US attorney didn't threaten Swartz with felonies and 50 years in prison, then what would stop other people from downloading lots of academ
by javajosh 13y ago
Right, because if the US attorney didn't threaten Swartz with felonies and 50 years in prison, then what would stop other people from downloading lots of academic PDFs?
First, I agree with Swartz that data should have been public. It's ridiculous that it isn't - and policymakers (now) agree. And yes, that matters. Kind of like when Rosa Parks broke the law sitting in the front of a bus. Second, the harshness of the prosecution was totally out-of-proportion to the act, even if you totally buy that it was really wrong. This was a clear cut case of a mindless, inhuman US Attorney (Cameron Ortiz and her lackys, Scott Garland and Stephen Heymann) angling for a plea-bargain that involved prison time and a felony.
The system is like a machine that grinds people up, like with that Oak Ridge incident[1], and we can't let it continue like this. Our government, for better or worse, has life and death power over us, and I for one cannot abide a government whose agents show not the slightest decency or respect for the value of self-restraint. Self-restraint, not loyalty to each other or anything else, should be our guiding light for determining goodness in our representatives.
[1] http://www.wagingpeace.org/tag/peace-protesters/ http://www.wagingpeace.org/tag/peace-protesters/
- tptacek 13y agoThe policymakers agree that there shouldn't be pay-to-access journals?
- javajosh 13y agoNo, but thank you for an opportunity to light a straw-man argument on fire: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/01/newly-passed-appropriations-bill-makes-even-more-publicly-funded-research-available-online https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/01/newly-passed-appropria...
- tptacek 13y agoThen I'm not clear what you were referring to when you said that the "policymakers" agreed with Swartz. Can you clarify a bit? Which policymakers? About what, in particular?