3 ms·
we like our signal to noise ratio to be as high as possible around here That may be true for select individuals, but I'll posit that it's no longer broadly tru
by mindcrime 13y ago
we like our signal to noise ratio to be as high as possible around here
That may be true for select individuals, but I'll posit that it's no longer broadly true for the majority of the people on this site who vote.
Going by my own comments (since those are the only ones I can see the score counts for), and comments which are obviously mass-downvoted (grayed out), I see cases all the time where "serious" posts - which are well researched, features citations, links, and serious discussion - languish. Meanwhile, the occasional angry rant directed at a popular "bogeyman" (like the NSA) gets massive upvotes.
Honestly, I feel like most of the talk about "signal to noise" ratio here is just a meme itself at this point. Sure, the gratuitously silly stuff gets downvoted to oblivion,
- mst 13y agoLooking at your comments, you seem to prefer a more direct and assertive style of debate than is normal on here. So do I, but I've chosen to adjust because I've found that a harsh tone signals aggression to people here where in other contexts it instead signals passion for the idea. Or: I propose the hypothessis that your calibration for how other people are perceiving things is incorrect, and that if you adjust that, then while there's still a lower percentage for whom it's true than there used to be, on average people still value signal more than you do.
- mst 13y agoGah. "still value signal more than you think they do". Sorry.