4 ms·
Oddly, I'm not outraged by this. Countries spy on each other, including private organizations of other countries. And they do so in secret, and to whatever exte
by javajosh 13y ago
Oddly, I'm not outraged by this. Countries spy on each other, including private organizations of other countries. And they do so in secret, and to whatever extent they can get away with. We can argue all day long about whether it's the right thing to do, but the behavior has, at the very least, a long history behind it. It seems that the expected behavior is to just get angry and roll some heads when it's found out, and then get right back to it.
And yet, I'm outraged by the exact same NSA behavior when applied to the USA. What's the difference? The difference is that Germans don't vote in the USA, and therefore the NSA isn't protecting itself in the context of our country, but (presumably) protecting our country in the context of the world. There's a lack of incest, recursion, self-reenforcement...however you want to put it. Sure, the opportunity for abuse exists, but it's not a systemic risk, unlike the systemic risk caused by any intelligence agency doing blanket surveillance on it's own citizens.
- josephlord 13y agoThat it an acceptance of a world in constant information war without friends and allies. It implies a massive global expenditure on both attack and defence. Now some is definitely going to happen on critical issues but I would expect them to be at least embarrassed when caught to act as a deterrent prevent it being done too casually. I'm British and GCHQ have been eager partners with the NSA and equally invasive in the UK (although possibly without breaking rules because there largely aren't any).
- javajosh 13y agoI think we agree then: embarrassed, yes. But outraged, no. My point is that there is a qualitative difference between untargeted domestic mass surveillance and targeted foreign surveillance. The former is a known threat to democracy; the latter is distasteful and it would be better not to exist, but it's part of the international landscape since forever.
- josephlord 13y agoI believe outrage is appropriate and that the NSA and the USA should be pretty deeply embarassed (and GCHQ and the UK). Foreign surveillance can be a threat (blackmail) to foreign democracies. Breaking into computer systems is also criminal in most jurisdictions. A government caught committing crimes in another country without very good reason should expect severe diplomatic and even economic sanctions, involved staff and those giving the orders should expect arrest if they visit the country spied on (those computer hacking in EU could expect arrest anywhere in Europe under the European arrest warrant). I'm not sure it would be wise for NSA bosses to holiday in Europe (without the protection of diplomatic immunity).