4 ms·
FTFA: "The support of ratified standards (that Web developers) can use is something that we are extremely supportive of," said Amy Barzdukas, general manager fo
by jamesbritt 17y ago
FTFA: "The support of ratified standards (that Web developers) can use is something that we are extremely supportive of," said Amy Barzdukas, general manager for IE, in a July interview. "In some cases, it can be premature to start claiming support for standards that are not yet in fact standards."
This is important. For years noted Web designers have been touting "designing with Web standards", and for good reason. While there are many sweet things in HTML5, treating what's defined today as if it were some final spec risks creating, over time, a hodgepodge of not-quite HTML5 documents.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoThis is important, but not for the reasons you think. Refusing to support (or implement or discuss or contribute to) a standard up until after it has been ratified as a full standard is Microsoft's favourite new technique for derailing standards. On first glance it seems reasonable but imagine if everyone followed the same rule. There would be no standard for anyone to follow, or if people forged ahead and wrote the standard anyway it would have no real world implementation and as a result be entirely useless. If you think they do support web standards then note they use the exact same tactic with ODF. I trust no-one is stupid enough to think that Microsoft is in any way enthusiastic for that standard to get traction.
- extension 17y agoThere's a fine line between derailing and simply not helping. The process is going fine without them and they're only shooting themselves in the foot by not putting their two cents in.
- jamesbritt 17y ago"This is important, but not for the reasons you think." I was speaking to developers who want to treat HTML5 today as a proper standard, and push out Web sites with HTML5 features, while the spec is still under development. But I think the tactic there is that if enough sites are using a common set of non-standard features supported by FF, Opera, etc, but not IE.whatver, then users of IE.whatever will eventually push Microsoft to implement these features. I realize that part of getting a usable standard in place is to first put possible usable standards into action, but it's reasonable to wonder if every feature people decide to push for or to act on should or will make the final cut. I hardly expect Microsoft to act out of altruism, (nor do I expect that of Google), but I also don't assume every question raised by Microsoft is done for malicious reasons.
- enomar 17y agoIf the alternative is that the spec is developed in a vacuum and takes longer to finish, I'll deal with some imperfect documents. Those will happen anyway.