6 ms·
Its a promising result, but a lot of mice experiments don't have the same effects on people. It would be ironic if this technique failed on humans subjected to
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
Its a promising result, but a lot of mice experiments don't have the same effects on people. It would be ironic if this technique failed on humans subjected to a lot of exposure to botox :-) The fear is that suddenly not only would the rich get richer, but they would never die. That leads to some fairly depressing scenarios.
- JabavuAdams 13y agoStep 1. Get rich. Same as it ever was.
- ashray 13y agoThe rich would not get richer. They would stay alive and stick around until they got poorer and eventually died.
- tormeh 13y agoThat's not how capitalism works. Your earning potential increases with your capital, eventually making talent and effort negligible factors.
- WalterBright 13y agoThe first generation makes the fortune, the second generation spends it, the third starts over.
- Lockyy 13y agoWhat happens if that second generation never replaces the first?
- eli_gottlieb 13y ago"A witty saying proves nothing."
- stcredzero 13y agoIn Larry Niven's Known Space books, some of the rich stuck around so long that they became hyper bored and so decided to become super criminals. He has one such minor character who is a woman over two centuries old, with all of the experience and knowledge that entails, with the body of an 18 year old.
- X4 13y agoAsked a buddy who ain't that smart on what he would do, if he could live 300 years. He said: "I'd rob a bank, big time." I asked why he would do that and he said that he could give the money to a trustee and sit his time and become rich afterwards. So your story sounds legit to me. And I just asked for 300 years. Living 16.000 years like in the movie: "The man from Earth", was way out of his graspable zone. And he started arguing about god would kill you and so on...
- alanfalcon 13y agoWhen you rob a bank and get caught, they don't let you keep the money.
- stcredzero 13y agoTell your buddy to take a decade out of his life and become a NASCAR driver. Then take another decade to become a top-flight Bluegrass banjo player. I think those trump whatever life experience he'd get from robbing a bank.
- anentropic 13y agoaren't they already basically super criminals?
- mavdi 13y agoYou really haven't understood how this works
- argumentum 13y agoI'm pretty sure if possible, serious anti-aging technogy will drop in price due to incredible market demand. It's highly unlikely the compound relies on resources that are extremely rare. Even if that were the case, someone would quickly find a way to replicate the procedure without the rare resources. Likely the things in the way would be governments and corporations trying to profit through IP. In that case, black market tech would be developed and you could likely go to an unregulated / 3rd world country to get the procedure done.
- rz2k 13y agoJust to be clear, increasing demand implies shifting the demand curve rightward, and increases the price. The dynamics of economies of scale that we are familiar with are related to chance that suppliers can lower their marginal costs if demand also justifies a fixed cost in suitable technology. And furthermore, if there is a big enough market and enough suppliers, the market price will approach the marginal cost of production. Imagine someone wants you to make a spoon that they'll buy from you. It takes you an hour to whittle one out of a piece of wood, and you charge $100. Then they want ten more using the exact same method you used on the first one. Ten hours whittling sounds like even more of a hardship than an hour, so you charge even more per spoon. A thousands spoons painstakingly whittled? Nope. Now imagine on the other hand, they want you to make them a plastic spoon. Making one plastic spoon is going to be a lot more difficult than whittling one wooden spoon. And yet, if they want enough of them, and you can use any technology, your costs might start to approach $0.01 per spoon. Anyway, since we think of anything that's to become a viable business in terms of how it can scale, it's easy to reverse the outcomes of changes in supply or demand in the base case where no technology or methods are changing.
- argumentum 13y agoI didn't say mere "increased" demand, I said "incredible" demand. I meant to imply that economies of scale would develop, as I imagine most will pay everything they have for the ability to live forever. (At least I would, as long as I was purely rational. I can imagine getting bored of life in 500 years or so, but I doubt it).
- buyx 13y agoThe political consequences will be interesting. One of the consolations if living under a tyrant is that they will, eventually die. I wonder if having Robert Mugabe around for another 40 years would excite Zimbabweans. The flip-side is that citizens could get more politically active if they couldn't rely on death to prevent gerontocracies.
- orangecat 13y agoNorth Korea's tyrants eventually die, but that doesn't help as long as they have equally tyrannical descendants ready to take over.
- krrrh 13y agoAnother interesting flipside might be that people become less willing to participate in a revolution for the sake of improving a few decades of their own lives and the lives of future generations when the risk of dying in a revolution means potentially giving up hundreds of years of one's own useful living.
- frade33 13y ago> but they would never die Challenge Accepted. God. /s On a serious note, this could be charming, but still, most people die, not because they were too old., in fact a very few people hit their biological age limit which i guess is 100 ~ 130. They are still many challenges such as diseases, road accidents which are the No. 1 cause for death.
- jseliger 13y agoIn 2005 Charles C. Mann wrote "The Coming Death Shortage" (http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2005/05/the-coming-death-shortage/304105/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2005/05/the-comi...), which attempts to imagine what a world with drastically lengthened lifespans might look like.
- nnq 13y agoDon't bother with those immortality consequences scenarios until you see a real general working treatment for cancer (something way more than "it cures 80% of the cancers in 80% of the cases"). If you live long enough, you will get cancer - basic molecular biology and probability and thermodynamics will take care of this. Also, the side effects of most regenerative treatments are increases in the risk of cancer. Also, don't bother with "the super-rich becoming super-genetically-enhanced" scenarios - all known genetic therapy technologies have as side effects increasing the risk of cancer. Basically, cancer is the mythical dragon guarding the tree of eternal-life and super-gene-therapy, so while it's still alive, being super rich and having access to all regenerative medicine and anti-aging therapies will make a difference, but not such a big one, so don't worry :) (And yeah, finding a "general" solution to the cancer problem is truly hard, maybe even impossible for the absolutely general case - ie, you'll still have rare forms of cancer that don't respond to any know therapies, and as you live longer and longer the probability of bumping into one such form will approach certainty. And getting a better and better treatment for each type of cancer doesn't seem to go much faster until we get a specific set of breakthroughs in nanotechnology that could be applied to this specific problem.)
- wozer 13y ago> If you live long enough, you will get cancer Is this true, though? The really old rarely die from cancer, it seems. http://z3.invisionfree.com/The_110_Club/index.php?showtopic=8049 http://z3.invisionfree.com/The_110_Club/index.php?showtopic=...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jpollock 13y agoThey don't die _from_ cancer, but they tend to _have_ cancer when they die. Tumours in old people grow slowly.
- asveikau 13y ago> Tumours in old people grow slowly. Anyone else read this and fantasize about the world's most ironic cancer treatment? If we could somehow speed up the aging process... (No I'm not serious...)
- straws 13y agoWe'll have effectively created a new breed of super-mice though.