4 ms·
This isn't that.
by davidgerard 13y ago
This isn't that.
- vacri 13y agoI think it is just that. I live in Melbourne myself, and while I'm not involved in the gay scene, I'm also not that far removed from it. What you've got here is a bland statement saying "we're boycotting this product" without actually stating any changes made. Does the council even use Mozilla's stuff? If they do, what changes are they making? How effective have previous campaigns of theirs been? (Like I say, I'm admittedly not involved in the scene, but I haven't actually heard the name of the aids council for literally years). How much political reach do they have to make people actually change the web browser they're using? Few people use thunderbird or firefox OS or Mozilla's other subsidiary products. And what is the basis of their claim? A single sizeable donation from six years ago. What more recent evidence do we have that he's still acting this way? People can and do change over the course of years. This announcement is merely jumping on a political bandwagon, and the suggested boycott has no teeth in it. It's a robotic response, and smacks of the usual way these things are written: responding to the hot gossip with no further investigation. Fine, boycott away if they want to, I'm just saying that press releases like this - giving little insight, having no real teeth, no course of action, and which can be written in 10 minutes - don't require much to trigger them. It doesn't even mention that Mozilla's primary product is Firefox and you can start off by using something else!
- wpietri 13y agoRegarding the "what has he done lately" question, he basically dodged the question in 2012: https://brendaneich.com/2012/04/community-and-diversity/ https://brendaneich.com/2012/04/community-and-diversity/ As far as I've seen, he's said nothing else on this topic. This could lead any Mozilla employee to wonder: does he still believe gay people don't deserve the same civil rights straight people get?
- bzbarsky 13y agoYou mean any Mozilla employee who's never actually talked to Brendan, right? The people who have interacted with him have this to say: https://twitter.com/Jason_Duell/status/449276922359320576 https://twitter.com/Jason_Duell/status/449276922359320576 http://subfictional.com/2014/03/24/on-brendan-eich-as-ceo-of-mozilla/ http://subfictional.com/2014/03/24/on-brendan-eich-as-ceo-of... (And I saw a few more along those lines on twitter, but trying to search twitter on this topic right now is a bit difficult.) Oddly enough, the only Mozilla employees I've seen calling for Brendan to step down are employees of the Foundation, not of the Corporation, and as far as I can tell don't deal with him on a regular basis, if at all.
- wpietri 13y agoI think that with 600+ employees, there are going to be an awful lot of employees who are not going to be comfortable saying, "Hey, boss's boss's boss's boss: why did you put your money down with the anti-gay bigots?" And I don't know about you, but if I were a) afraid to ask, or b) didn't get a satisfactory answer, I wouldn't be posting about it on Twitter. Because of that great-great-grandboss thing. I have no idea what's going on in Eich's head, but I am saying that people working for him could be reasonably concerned.
- bzbarsky 13y agoTrue, but my point is that the people who have actually been working for him for many years now have no negative experiences along these lines to report that I've seen. And that if you're worried about how he'll treat people working for him, the best thing to do is to ask the people who have been working for him. It's not like he's a new hire into the organization or something; there are lots of people around who have been interacting with him for a long time. I agree that if you had no other source of information than the existence of the donation, that would certainly raise the chances of there being problems in other aspects of interacting with the man, of course. That's obvious. I'm just saying that if there are non-proxy sources of information available, it's better to use those than to use proxy sources that rely on good but imperfect correlations. (The correlation in this case being "someone who strongly supported Proposition 8 is also a problem to work with if you're gay". Reasonably good correlation, I expect, but not perfect.)
- wpietri 13y agoI agree that we've so far had no negative reports. But a) there's a strong disincentive to report, b) subtle discrimination is hard to pin down, and c) that he has helped to strip gay people of their civil rights is enough to cause fear, and fear is all it takes to create problematic working conditions.
- bzbarsky 13y agoThere's a difference between "no negative reports" and "people actively reporting positive experiences".