3 ms·
"If you’re out in the woods camping and need help, you could broadcast your needs in the hope someone picks it up." You could, but it's unlikely to do you any
by mikestew 13y ago
"If you’re out in the woods camping and need help, you could broadcast your needs in the hope someone picks it up."
You could, but it's unlikely to do you any good using a radio whose output is measured in milliwatts. Unless "out in the woods camping" means a KOA.
"Similarly, during a natural disaster, you could help locate loved ones and people in need, even with non-operational cellular towers."
Same deal: no, you probably won't. A cell phone is a radio, and it's a pretty crappy radio that relies very much on existing infrastructure. When that infrastructure goes down, the only people you'll be chatting with will be the ones you can physically see. Even the 5 watt handheld radio that I have (which requires a license to operate) may only be good for a few miles in rough terrain.
It would nice if the article stuck to what is feasible (the music festival example) and disposed with the hyperbole. Remote villages in Bumfukistan will not be getting internet access because of this.
- sliverstorm 13y agoA 5 watt handheld is only good for a few miles in normal terrain. I think mine caps around 4-5 miles around town (suburb with absolutely no buildings over 3 stories), although that's with a factory ducky antenna
- mikestew 13y agoHuh, I wasn't aware that there was anyone that didn't order a gain antenna at the same time they ordered the radio. :-) I regularly hit a repeater 12 miles away. A bit fuzzy, but it works. But I'm using a gain antenna that's a bit longer than stock, you know, for street cred (street cred being very important amongst ham radio operators). Hook it up to the mag mount antenna in the car, and it expands to 20 or 30 miles (dunno exactly, haven't hit the limit yet). In an attempt to keep this on the topic at hand, anecdotal evidence would suggest (and solid empirical evidence confirms) that the antenna is important as well as power output. Combine wimpy power output with an antenna that has to fit in a 4" phone, and without cell towers or WiFi APs you might as well just shout to the person you're trying to contact.
- sliverstorm 13y agoWhat can I say, I'm a ham with zero street cred. Well, that's not true. I just don't invest much in ham equipment; I devote my radio funds to my emergency services band equipment instead.
- cbhl 13y agoI'm not convinced the music festival example is feasible. While GSM's Slotted ALOHA protocol breaks down at "only" 36.8% load, I imagine that mesh networking at a music festival is about as productive as having a conversation with the person next to you at said festival (too much noise for the device to "hear itself think", let alone for the device owned by the adjacent person).