5 ms·

" the shields prevented any damage that could cause a fire or penetrate the existing quarter inch of ballistic grade aluminum armor plate that already protects

" the shields prevented any damage that could cause a fire or penetrate the existing quarter inch of ballistic grade aluminum armor plate that already protects the battery pack" Ballistic grade aluminum armor plate... If there is one thing Tesla does well it is publicity. I know there are high strength steels but it seems like they want something that is strong and light. If it sounds like something impenetrable to the average customer that's even better for Tesla.

squigs25 13y ago
exactly my point - this is purely a marketing stunt.
- johnward 13y ago
  Well the chances of actually penetrating the aluminum shell of the battery pack seem pretty low anyway. They are just answering the media shit storm they get for any little problem with an equally over kill replacement that will lead to media shit storm.
  - sp332 13y ago
    There's no such thing as bad press. As long as Tesla has people looking at them they're going to use the opportunity to push their product.
sailfast 13y ago
Just for giggles, could it be that adding a heavier material such as steel would have a more significant impact on range due to the additional weight? Part of the upgrade pitch is that users only see a 1% decrease in range. With steel, perhaps you see a 3-5% decrease, and range has been the key argument for Tesla against other competitors.
- DEinspanjer 13y ago
  0.1% decrease. Believe it or not, I know several owners who would not be satisfied with even a 1% decrease, especially if it is adding a safety feature that most of them feel is so unlikely to happen, they would have preferred never to have temporarily disabled the low height mode.
dingaling 13y ago
> Ballistic grade aluminum armor plate... That's from the same marketing phrase-book as 'aircraft-grade aluminium'. Lightweight armour ( e.g. personal protection ) uses ceramic plates. Heavy armour ( e.g. tanks ) still uses steel alloys with composite and plastic layers. There were a few AFVs with aluminium armour, such as the M113 and Sheridan, but ballistic protection was restricted to small-arms and light shrapnel. A Sheridan could be ripped apart by a 12.7mm DhSK.
- wooster 13y ago
  A quick Google search indicates that it's used commonly in armored cars and military vehicles. eg: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/products/product.asp?prod_id=4307 http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/products/product.asp?prod_id=...

squigs25 13y ago

exactly my point - this is purely a marketing stunt.

johnward 13y ago
Well the chances of actually penetrating the aluminum shell of the battery pack seem pretty low anyway. They are just answering the media shit storm they get for any little problem with an equally over kill replacement that will lead to media shit storm.
- sp332 13y ago
  There's no such thing as bad press. As long as Tesla has people looking at them they're going to use the opportunity to push their product.

sailfast 13y ago

Just for giggles, could it be that adding a heavier material such as steel would have a more significant impact on range due to the additional weight? Part of the upgrade pitch is that users only see a 1% decrease in range. With steel, perhaps you see a 3-5% decrease, and range has been the key argument for Tesla against other competitors.

DEinspanjer 13y ago
0.1% decrease. Believe it or not, I know several owners who would not be satisfied with even a 1% decrease, especially if it is adding a safety feature that most of them feel is so unlikely to happen, they would have preferred never to have temporarily disabled the low height mode.

dingaling 13y ago

> Ballistic grade aluminum armor plate... That's from the same marketing phrase-book as 'aircraft-grade aluminium'. Lightweight armour ( e.g. personal protection ) uses ceramic plates. Heavy armour ( e.g. tanks ) still uses steel alloys with composite and plastic layers. There were a few AFVs with aluminium armour, such as the M113 and Sheridan, but ballistic protection was restricted to small-arms and light shrapnel. A Sheridan could be ripped apart by a 12.7mm DhSK.

wooster 13y ago
A quick Google search indicates that it's used commonly in armored cars and military vehicles. eg: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/products/product.asp?prod_id=4307 http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/products/product.asp?prod_id=...