5 ms·
I'm sorry, I know the man is a celebrated inventor and all, but this is hogwash. He's talking about how making health care accessible to all will make it access
by potatolicious 17y ago
I'm sorry, I know the man is a celebrated inventor and all, but this is hogwash. He's talking about how making health care accessible to all will make it accessible to none - an interesting thesis, but ultimately one that has been soundly disproved by the success of public health systems in most of Europe and Canada.
He is partially right - the lack of extreme-expense health care drives out extreme high-end solutions such as the article's highlighted "Luke" arm, a prosthetic that is almost as good as the real thing.
But really, what do we want as a society? For a two-digit number of extremely wealthy people to have access to the world's best prosthetics, stuff that is in the realm of sci-fi? Or for everyone to have access to "good enough" prosthetic technology that advances more slowly?
"if talented people are given resources they're going to keep driving us to having better, simpler, cheaper solutions to problems"
Absolutely false, and proven by his own highest-profile project; the Segway hasn't gotten significantly cheaper or more accessible despite years of R&D, and is unlikely to become affordable anytime soon. This man's own business is a textbook case of the lie behind this claim. In order for solutions to get cheaper there must be market pressure to reduce cost: this is something that doesn't exist in America's current health care system.
Health care providers don't care about cost - it's passed along to insurance companies and consumers anyway. Insurance companies care about cost, but not really - it's easily passed to sponsoring employers or individual buyers anyway. Really, the only people that truly want cost reduced are the endpoint patients and their employers, who generally lack the clout and influence to push for real cost reductions. The entire system is broken. Costs have not lowered for health care, and will not lower, until the system is reorganized such that cost reduction becomes advantageous to all stakeholders.
He does make a cogent point in the end: more R&D will lead to better solutions and lower costs (given the right structure and incentives). But this argument is really independent of the affordability issue that plagues America today. Where I come from (Canada) we do a huge amount of pharmaceutical research (in fact, we invented the insulin injection) on government funds. I personally know very talented people working every day on cancer research.
Yet we can still afford to give everyone health care. Imagine that. A person can still get a major disease without going broke. Imagine that.
I really do think Dean Kamen is conflating two unrelated issues. The lack of R&D funding is an issue, but increasing R&D need not come from the pockets of consumers. Just look at the existing private system - a third of every health care dollar spent is just on administrative costs. Imagine if we took this money and threw it into R&D.
- lutorm 17y agoWell said. He makes an argument that people are trying to "instill fear in ordinary Americans" and seems to think the system is working perfectly, without giving those that have no access to health care today even a token sentence. The argument that those that can afford it should just continue spending loads of money on health care and eventually, through some unspecified process, this will make life better for all those who don't have access to health care at all sounds like a variant of "trickle-down" voodoo economics to me.
- blhack 17y agoWho in the United States doesn't have access to healthcare? Quite honestly, I don't see why this is such a massive issue with everyone right now... Medical innovation (in it's current state, meaning building things on a molecular level) is prohibitively expensive. Gone are the days when a guy in his basement can hack out (or stumble upon) some great new wonderdrug like penicillin. These things are not cheap to do... Also, how does the US Gov't plan on getting the cost of healthcare down? If there is some magic wand that they can wave and make everything cheaper, then why don't they do it? Why do they want control over this so badly?
- potatolicious 17y ago"Who in the United States doesn't have access to healthcare?" I took the liberty of looking up some numbers, because clearly you haven't. The answer to your question is over 46.6 million Americans(1) (you have 300 million total), the ones without health insurance. Add another 25 million Americans(2) who are underinsured and the number is scarier. Underinsured is defined as people who have insurance but end up spending >10% of their income on health care expenses. The same source (2) indicates that 42% of working adults (19 to 64 years-old) are uninsured or underinsured. So in short, who in the US doesn't have access to health care? Apparently 42% of them. "Quite honestly, I don't see why this is such a massive issue with everyone right now..." You don't see an issue with someone breaking a leg and going bankrupt because of it? You don't see an issue with a population going broke just to keep themselves hobbling along? Here's some more fun. 50% of bankruptcies in the US today are due to health care costs (5). In fact, 68% of those who declare bankruptcy due to unaffordable health care costs have health insurance (4). You don't see a problem here? "Medical innovation (in it's current state, meaning building things on a molecular level) is prohibitively expensive." Yet Europe and Canada (and other first-world nations with public health care) are doing fine at their own medical research. It's s till expensive, but it's being funded by the government, and the people still get great health care (some of it is better than the US...). Your thesis is one that is trotted out a lot by proponents of the private system, but it simply holds no water. We have many cases of massive medical R&D being done in countries where every single person receives free health care. "Also, how does the US Gov't plan on getting the cost of healthcare down?" Easy. By going public. You asked if there is a magic wand, and I'm here to tell you it doesn't get more magic-wand-y than this. Right now 25% of every health care dollar spent is going towards administrative expenses (2), compared to 1% to 5% for public health systems around the world (2). By cutting out the private insurance companies you instantly gain a 26-32% efficiency on your health care dollars. Imagine the number of people you can cover with that massive amount of money (some $400 billion per year as of 2003). (1) http://www.cbpp.org/cms/?fa=view&id=628 http://www.cbpp.org/cms/?fa=view&id=628 (2) http://health.usnews.com/articles/health/healthday/2008/06/10/25-million-americans-are-underinsured.html http://health.usnews.com/articles/health/healthday/2008/06/1... (3) http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/8800.php http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/8800.php (4) http://www.nchc.org/facts/cost.shtml http://www.nchc.org/facts/cost.shtml (5) http://www.pnhp.org/new_bankruptcy_study/Bankruptcy-2009.pdf http://www.pnhp.org/new_bankruptcy_study/Bankruptcy-2009.pdf