5 ms·
Just the CEO? Who else shall we burn at the stake? Mary, the office manager, goes to church every Sunday. How did she vote? John over in mobile dev is a devout
by mikestew 13y ago
Just the CEO? Who else shall we burn at the stake? Mary, the office manager, goes to church every Sunday. How did she vote? John over in mobile dev is a devout Muslim, I'll bet he doesn't take kindly to such things as gay marriage. Time to start scanning through those campaign contribution records for Prop 8 and seeing if a JOIN on the employee database gives us any results.
I've always held to the idea that my job is to make my manager look good. I don't know that mouthing off on twitter such that Ars Technica picks it up is fitting to that philosophy.
- Mikeb85 13y agoThank you for posting this. It's insane that there's this witch-hunt over someone's personal views, and the fact that this outlandish behaviour is actually supported and applauded by people. If anything this just gives more credence to the 'gay agenda' conspiracies that up until fairly recently no one took seriously...
- m0a0t0 13y agoBecause equal marriage is really, really important. When gay people are not accepted in society opposing something that would improve that greatly is a bad thing to do
- Mikeb85 13y agoWhy? Marriage has always been about community and religion, in many countries people never bother registering it with the government. In some countries like Canada, common-law partners get the same benefits as married partners. Personally, I'd be all for doing away with the entire government institution of marriage, and simply have 'civil unions' for all, with each community and religion being able to decide for themselves what 'marriage' means.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Marriage has always been about community and religion, in many countries people never bother registering it with the government. At least in Europe, that's pretty much backwards -- marriage has always been about property, and, it was fairly late that the Church even got involved at all, and the Church getting deeply involved in governing marriage was largely a trend that happened as the Church deepened its involvement in government more generally.
- Mikeb85 13y agoYes I forgot. For some cultures in some time periods women were property that was traded from father to husband, in exchange for goods, and marriage was the contract that finalized the transfer of property. Especially for the higher classes that had a significant amount of property. In some religions at least marriage signified a bond between two people, and not merely a transfer of property. My views are shaped somewhat by the fact that in Orthodox Christianity (the type I'm most familiar with), marriage isn't a transfer of property, and the bride isn't 'given' from father to husband. It's an equal arrangement. Whereas in Islam and 'western' Christianity the bride is 'given', much like property.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> For some cultures in some time periods women were property that was traded from father to husband, in exchange for goods, and marriage was the contract that finalized the transfer of property. I wasn't talking about women as property, though that's also a factor in some cases (which undermines the whole "traditional marriage" as a good thing argument.) I was talking about marriage being about property arrangements, not the parties being property.
- m0a0t0 13y agoIt hasn't always been about religion, possibly community though. Doing away with government marriages if it was for everyone. At the moment it is important because it has tax benefits and not having it equal makes gay people seem like second class citizens.
- kofejnik 13y agoin other words, witch-hunt is ok if you support the cause?
- m0a0t0 13y agoNot if I support the cause but if the cause is right. This is also not a witch-hunt. I honestly cannot believe that people are so apathetic about equality
- freyrs3 13y agoMarriage equality is important, but a society in which we're able to go to work, do ours jobs and bracket our concerns about the personal lives of our coworkers and bosses is more important than any immediate social issue in the present. It's the foundational principle of living in a pluralistic society.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rjknight 13y agoNo, it really doesn't. There are sensible people on this thread trying to argue that Brendan Eich shouldn't be forced to resign because of his private political views, and there are idiots like you using words like 'witch-hunt' and talking about the 'gay agenda' (what, you think they have a committee somewhere drawing up a hit-list?). I sincerely doubt that you are trying constructively to help here.
- jrs235 13y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7483726 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7483726
- hkphooey 13y agoSilly you for thinking there was an agenda. In the UK, the Labour (political party) Gay Rights Manifesto of 1985 said, "A socialist society would supersede the family household... Gay people and children should have the right to live together... It follows from what we have already said that we favour the abolition of the age of consent."
- intortus 13y agoThere's a huge difference between holding general religious beliefs and contributing financially to a political movement specifically pursuing institutional discrimination of a large class of Americans. I'm a little troubled by the chilling effects that career and public opinion can have on political expression, but it's hard to generate sympathy for blatantly unconstitutional, horrendously discriminatory forms of political expression.
- freyrs3 13y agoPhilosophically what's the difference between financially supporting a political cause and voting for leaders which support that cause?
- intortus 13y agoThe intent behind a financial contribution (or any other sort of contribution to a campaign) is to amplify one's vote by getting others to join in. What makes this case so interesting is that the campaign in question is so specifically wrong. If it were for a candidate or party who has some questionable views, I'd feel inappropriate holding it against someone, but I'm not aware of any saving graces for Prop 8.
- drone 13y agoThe Catholic Church works very hard to supress gay marriage everywhere in the world, and has done a lot more harm to our society than Prop 8 ever would have. The Catholic Church is supported by tithes from their members, which are generally required. By this same logic, should they not be arguing for the firing of every Catholic employee, who ostensibly spend 10% of their income received from the company to the same end?
- gjm11 13y ago1. The Roman Catholic Church does not require tithes from its members. I'm not sure any part of it ever has. 2. No one is saying that every employee who does as Eich did should be fired. Some people are saying that someone who has done as Eich did shouldn't be CEO of Mozilla.
- hkphooey 13y agoYes, Mary the office manager, she claims to be a Christian but I've always suspected her of being a witch. Burn her! Drown her! Do both! But whatever you do, don't go near John, because I hear he gets upset over cartoons and he might react violently rather than meekly accepting punishment like a good Christian. If you're sick of the political correctness and need a good laugh, watch this short piece by British aethist comedian Pat Condell, 'How gay is Islam?' http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nLbltj-tD1Y http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nLbltj-tD1Y
- m0a0t0 13y agoWhy is it that for some people political correctness - something which tries to make people respect one another more and be nice - is the devil. You have the right to say almost whatever you want. That doesn't mean you fucking should, does it? There's a big difference between the two
- RunningDroid 13y agoBecause for some people political correctness is about lying to make others feel good.
- m0a0t0 13y agoWell when the thing they are lying about is a view which is harmful then I see no problem.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- burntroots 13y agoYou've heard of the chilling effect, right? I would say insisting on being politically correct in all things or you're not fit to run a company would qualify as censorship.
- simonster 13y agoMary and John aren't the CEO. There was disappointment over Brendan Eich's position on gay marriage when he was CTO, but I don't think anyone was calling for him to resign, and even now I'm not sure anyone is calling for Eich to leave Mozilla. CEO is the ultimate leadership role, and if you are gay or have gay friends, having someone in that role who does not believe in gay marriage hurts.
- npizzolato 13y agoThe comparison between the CEO (and therefore the public face) of a non-profit organization and Mary the office manager is so absurd it's ridiculous. When your actions impact more people, you get put under a harsher spotlight. I'm not sure why that's a difficult concept to grasp.