48 ms·
Dean Kamen: Healthcare Debate "Backward Looking"
- zhyder 17y agoThe problem is that the same healthcare service costs a lot more in America than it does anywhere else in the world. It's understandable if the surgery that only 4 surgeons in the world can do costs a lot, but relatively routine/commoditized stuff shouldn't cost more than in other developed countries.
- kjn 17y agoThe other problem is that despite spending significantly more than any other nation, measures of health care (i.e preventable deaths, access to health care) rank the US well behind other first world nations. The interview largely ignores that concern, and focuses instead on the strawman of absolute cost.
- cwan 17y agoUnfortunately the debate usually isn't as black and white all the time given that there are a number of metrics like survival rates following heart attacks or cancer detection/treatment where the US is very much ahead of other first world nations. Absolute cost is far from a strawman in this issue given that the basic argument for reform (as they've proposed - since I think a lot of people are for reform including Dean Kamen), is that the US healthcare system as it is now is too expensive and ergo a significant barrier to access. Others like Kamen make the point that by restricting absolute costs, innovation will drop because the incentives for innovating drop.
- kznewman 17y agoThis seems intuitive and if its true that the cost is ONLY for that service and not ALSO for the superior research and development, then I would agree. I don’t know for sure but my hope would be that at least some relatively routine/commoditized stuff is higher in America to pay for things that aren’t being done in other places. In any case Dean Kamen makes some great points about moving beyond fear based legislation.
- mrkurt 17y agoI've only ever seen statistics that compare the aggregate cost of health care relative to aggregate outcomes in the US vs other countries. Do you have more details on the delta between pricing for specific services? It's generally very difficult to compare the cost of specific services in any meaningful way. For instance, many countries institute price controls on medication, cutting the cost of some prescriptions to 30% of what they'd cost in the US. However, some of these drugs were developed in the US based on US patent law and with the assumption of a certain amount of profit from US consumers. A price control in Canada is effectively subsidized by US consumers of a given drug, in lots of cases. A great deal of the costs we pay come as a result of artificial scarcity of both drugs and medical services. The result of legislation, fears of malpractice, and prescription requirements mean that treating a simple sinus infection (which I can diagnose reasonably well myself) costs ~$150 or so after the doctor visit and trip to the pharmacy. There are a great many ways to attack that scarcity, but we're not really considering them (unfortunately). Dean Kamen has a good point. The level of medical care we can provide to people is both insane and insanely expensive. High prices are rationing. What we need to do is attack the high prices that are artificially inflated.
- asmithmd1 17y ago"A price control in Canada is effectively subsidized by US consumers of a given drug" I think that is the crux of his point, if the US didn't have these crazy high prices - then the drug would not have been developed. I liked this quote: "Every drug that's made is a gift from one generation to the next because, while it may be expensive now, it goes off patent and your kids will have it essentially for free." The high cost in the US is paying for the R&D that makes the drug possible
- blasdel 17y agoThe drug companies spend almost nothing on R&D, not compared to what they spend on consumer advertising, marketing to doctors, regulatory compliance, lobbying, civil defense lawyering, and patent lawyering.
- 17y ago
- ncarlson 17y agoHealth care is just like any other product or service. It will be sold at market prices.
- abstractbill 17y agoHealth care is not just like any other product or service. It's impossible to predict when you'll need it, and how much of it you'll need. When you really need it, you'll pay any price for it, even if that means spending every penny you have and then going heavily into debt. I can't think of a single other product or service that behaves quite like that.
- potatolicious 17y agoI'm sorry, I know the man is a celebrated inventor and all, but this is hogwash. He's talking about how making health care accessible to all will make it accessible to none - an interesting thesis, but ultimately one that has been soundly disproved by the success of public health systems in most of Europe and Canada. He is partially right - the lack of extreme-expense health care drives out extreme high-end solutions such as the article's highlighted "Luke" arm, a prosthetic that is almost as good as the real thing. But really, what do we want as a society? For a two-digit number of extremely wealthy people to have access to the world's best prosthetics, stuff that is in the realm of sci-fi? Or for everyone to have access to "good enough" prosthetic technology that advances more slowly? "if talented people are given resources they're going to keep driving us to having better, simpler, cheaper solutions to problems" Absolutely false, and proven by his own highest-profile project; the Segway hasn't gotten significantly cheaper or more accessible despite years of R&D, and is unlikely to become affordable anytime soon. This man's own business is a textbook case of the lie behind this claim. In order for solutions to get cheaper there must be market pressure to reduce cost: this is something that doesn't exist in America's current health care system. Health care providers don't care about cost - it's passed along to insurance companies and consumers anyway. Insurance companies care about cost, but not really - it's easily passed to sponsoring employers or individual buyers anyway. Really, the only people that truly want cost reduced are the endpoint patients and their employers, who generally lack the clout and influence to push for real cost reductions. The entire system is broken. Costs have not lowered for health care, and will not lower, until the system is reorganized such that cost reduction becomes advantageous to all stakeholders. He does make a cogent point in the end: more R&D will lead to better solutions and lower costs (given the right structure and incentives). But this argument is really independent of the affordability issue that plagues America today. Where I come from (Canada) we do a huge amount of pharmaceutical research (in fact, we invented the insulin injection) on government funds. I personally know very talented people working every day on cancer research. Yet we can still afford to give everyone health care. Imagine that. A person can still get a major disease without going broke. Imagine that. I really do think Dean Kamen is conflating two unrelated issues. The lack of R&D funding is an issue, but increasing R&D need not come from the pockets of consumers. Just look at the existing private system - a third of every health care dollar spent is just on administrative costs. Imagine if we took this money and threw it into R&D.
- danteembermage 17y agoTaking the rationing argument to the extreme, suppose we could take a painless treatment once a year that would stop all aging and disease but costs $1 million. Would we still innovate in cheaper, less effective methods? We couldn't possibly pay for the treatments for everyone, but should they be subsidized for some? Would there be pressure to make the treatments illegal for those who can afford them? What if for a quarter of the price you get half the effects, but you can still only take it once a year. What would be the optimal time to not age/be disease free a month, a week, a day?
- logicalmind 17y agoWhile we're theorizing, what if you knew you could make a pill that would be "a painless treatment once a year that would stop all aging and disease but costs $1 million." But it takes a company 50 years to develop and costs $1 trillion in research. Could a company take such a risk? Could the government?
- kqr2 17y agoSince Dean Kamen makes medical devices, doesn't he have a conflict of interest? Basically, if the government tries to control costs, he will probably earn less per device.
- billswift 17y agoSince the gov't wants more control over all that money, doesn't IT have an even bigger conflict of interest?
- logicalmind 17y agoThe government doesn't make money, your government representatives do. I would think that the government representatives would make more money by keeping the healthcare lobbyists in place. Then again, maybe this healthcare threat is simply a shake-down to get the lobbyists to give them more money. Who knows.
- billswift 17y agoWho said anything about the gov't making money? They want the POWER from CONTROLLING it.
- Nwallins 17y agoPrint Link: http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/health_medicine/4327012.html?do=print http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/health_medicine/4327...
- run4yourlives 17y agoDisclaimer: I'm Canadian, and I shouldn't be wading into this debate... You do realize though that the rest of the modern world looks at the US in this one issue the same way we looked at you when you had legalized segregation? The rest of us can't even understand why this is a debate. How is it that someone can argue in favour of people not having the ability to access a doctor? Would you also argue that people shouldn't have access to fire-fighters unless they pay the fire-fighter's tax? Police? The protection of an Army? Our socialized systems aren't a panacea, but the trade-offs of having someone wait for knee surgery so that another can get cancer treatment seem pretty fair to me. Sometimes, I simply don't understand the American perspective.
- _pi 17y agoYou have no idea, I recently got into a car accident (look at my history for the story of that). And for all of our "socialist policies" in the US that republicans owuld want you to believe, we're grossly libertarian. Long story short: Accident happened, cop came out and wrote me a ticket based on the fact that he had to come out, and pretty much told me that. Then today I got a bill from the fire department/EMS for them having to come out. In total these bills/tickets are about 1K in cost. So you'd think there isn't a fire-fighters tax but there is....
- jws 17y agoIn the 1970's I lived in a small town in Oregon. You paid your fire protection fee and they stuck a little sign in your yard. If your house caught fire and you weren't a customer they would allegedly come and protect your neighbor's houses, but not risk anything to save yours.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoWhat makes you believe that there's anyone in America that does not have access to a doctor? Hospital emergency rooms are required to take and treat all comers (at least if they want to participate in the system), and the Medicaid system reimburses those expenses. A poor, uninsured person might not be able to get a kidney transplant, but they'll get some level of basic care. And what Mr. Kamen argues is that the income generated by those expensive procedures -- not to mention a segment of the population that is willing to pay for it -- is what will lead to the breakthroughs in the future that will make (say) kidney transplants unnecessary in another generation. What really concerns me is that I know, because I have Crohn's Disease, that I have a much higher risk of colon cancer. Even at forty years old, I'm trying to put myself into a position where I'll be able to deal with that should it happen. But in the ultimate socialized/rationed model, I'm not allowed to buy myself additional treatment beyond the lowest common denominator. Canada recently fought (and lost, thank %deity%) to prevent citizens from getting better health insurance than the socialist plan. In England and other places you're allowed to get better care, but only if you pay for every bit of it -- you can't take the baseline and then pay for the overage. So that's definitely the direction that "progress" is moving in. My biggest objection is that this prevents people from having their own values. I'm not to be allowed to make decisions that balance for or against my lifespan. I can only get the mix that the regulators have deemed appropriate for every person, one size fits all.