2 ms·
The OP suggested that the universality of red in this fashion was evolutionary in basis. Stop signs as an example of universality. But stop signs are closely co
by dalke 13y ago
The OP suggested that the universality of red in this fashion was evolutionary in basis. Stop signs as an example of universality. But stop signs are closely coupled to a specific, near-universal machine culture.
The presence of early non-red stop signs suggests that "red = stop" is a learned association. Indeed, as the Wikipedia article states, the early standardizations used a yellow background instead of red. I conjecture that it was originally yellow for visibility reason, then turned red for better contrast with yellow used for caution signs. A full analysis would need to dig into the reasoning for this decision.
A more complete analysis would need to look into how color was used in the 1800s, before driving culture appeared. For example, was red the predominate color of danger in steam engines? (Note also that in Swedish and Finnish cultures, Falu red/punamulta is associated with an idyllic country-side life. These houses are not considered "dangerous" despite being red.)
The first and third literature references I gave are not in opposition to the idea that red has a (near) universal meaning. They instead cast doubt on the conjecture that the associations are evolutionary. The first suggests that even the observed psychological effects might be culturally learned, and the third suggests that we have a rather wide-spread global culture, making it hard to determine what is cultural and what is evolutionary.
Stop signs are also nearly universally octagon in shape. I very much doubt there's any sort of evolutionary reason for this choice.
My challenge was for the OP to defend the statement that the choice of red = blood = danger = stop is based on evolutionary reasons, with scientific research to back it up. The paper I quoted show that there's very little research which can distinguish between a shared culture (and yes, China and the US have a shared culture) and evolutionary universalism.
One need only read http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity_and_the_color_naming_debate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity_and_the_c... to see that even the basic color terms across cultures, and the evolution of color terms, is still being debated. It would be hard to ask someone "is red a dangerous color" if that someone doesn't distinguish between red and yellow.