3 ms·
I would have to say that the problems in academic science go deeper than "PhD union cards", but they're certainly rooted in the same academic-familial-reproduct
by eli_gottlieb 13y ago
I would have to say that the problems in academic science go deeper than "PhD union cards", but they're certainly rooted in the same academic-familial-reproductive structure as the PhD issue.
Academia does a breadth-first heuristic search on possible research, slowly converting the search space of potential ideas into published papers. If you want to work in the research system, you get slotted into a specialty and an education largely just according to what your grad-school and postdoc supervisors already work on. Hence why I'm calling it a breadth-first search: new scientists are almost literally additional nodes in a search tree.
The problem is the heuristic that governs where the tree is expanded (and how quickly): publication numbers and grant funding (which is determined by publication numbers). From the personal perspective there's also the sheer coincidence of which research fields and which advisers you've heard of at all when you finish your BSc or MSc and apply to your postgraduate research degree -- which is governed by grant funding and publication numbers.
Thing being... not only is a tree-shaped expansion structure generating untenable job markets, but the expansion heuristic in question doesn't really correspond to what we want out of scientific research. There are three main reasons to prioritize one research proposal over another: we think it will be technologically fruitful, we think it will be cheap or easy, and we think it will advance knowledge. In short: technology, convenience, and mystery. Grant funding and publication metrics, however, almost exclusively target convenience, with technological applicability coming in second-place and the fundamental scientific issue of filling in our ignorance about Nature stuck waaaay at the back of the bus.