2 ms·
Wellll... it really is a union card. The fact that a person has a PhD from a reputable institution does in fact set an absolute baseline: this person managed t
by eli_gottlieb 13y ago
Wellll... it really is a union card. The fact that a person has a PhD from a reputable institution does in fact set an absolute baseline: this person managed to do something that was sufficiently close to being science for other scientists to call it science.
I would say that if we want to think in terms of "union cards", we should just scrap the PhD and pin "science ranks" to publication metrics, as the real scientific job market already does. After all, what we really need from a scientific union card isn't to tell us how good a scientist is (and it doesn't do that), it's just to give us some baseline for separating real scientists from crackpots and wannabes (of which there are far too many).