3 ms·
Having a PhD I would not say it is worthless, but I suspect if I had spent the same amount of time just working I would have gained just as much. Of all the pro
by danieltillett 13y ago
Having a PhD I would not say it is worthless, but I suspect if I had spent the same amount of time just working I would have gained just as much. Of all the problems science faces the 'need' for a PhD to join the science 'union' is pretty low down - things like pervese incentives and rewarding academic gamesmanship over quality are much more of a problem.
- wyclif 13y agoClearly not "worthless" if you plan on spending your career teaching or researching in academia. Otherwise...people should really, really count the cost.
- Blahah 13y agoFor me, the value of the PhD is in the experience itself. Few get to experience, full time for 4 years, the intellectual freedom that my PhD affords. Even if I never work in academia, or my PhD doesn't help me get a much better job than I would otherwise have got, I'll still always be glad to have done it.
- thearn4 13y agoIt probably isn't necessary in the strictest sense of the word, But I guess that really depends on what it is that you want to get out of it. But the most valuable part of my PhD were the few years that I spent getting regular face time with subject matter experts, who walked me past the periphery of my field, to the point where I am comfortable enough publishing my own peer reviewed research. You could read the literature and try to get far enough up to speed to publish entirely yourself, but I guarantee that you will miss many subtleties if you don't connect with folks in the field. Enough that you are face a lot of hurdles trying to pass your work through peer review. The idea of doing that alone seems twice as daunting as doing a PhD. That said, I am neither teaching nor in academia (gov't at the moment). My retrospective might be a bit different if I was trying to elbow my way into tenure.
- hueving 13y ago>I guarantee that you will miss many subtleties if you don't connect with folks in the field. Enough that you are face a lot of hurdles trying to pass your work through peer review. This translates to, "you need to learn to speak the correct dialect of bullshit to get into the club."
- aortega 13y ago>I suspect if I had spent the same amount of time just working I would have gained just as much. You would have gained just as much, except for the PhD certification. I don't think you would need a PhD to do science. Journals never ask for your CV in a submission. However you need it to get a job in science, because your employer does not know if you actually can do science. That's why you need certifications.