3 ms·
Firing someone who didn't follow your edict to break the law (by action, or by inaction) is immoral, absolutely.
by FireBeyond 13y ago
Firing someone who didn't follow your edict to break the law (by action, or by inaction) is immoral, absolutely.
- bernardom 13y agoLet me be clear: I agree. What they (the mid-level HR people) did was immoral. Obviously. My point is that there's no need to compare them to war criminals, or for the dramatics in an ostensibly "news" site- "sadistic," "brutal," et al. When we do so, we displace a conversation about the real story: a tech cartel that colludes to depress salaries, and the secondary but still very interesting question of how their mid- and lower-level employees who enforced the policies should be treated.
- FireBeyond 13y agoOf that, I do agree. The issue at hand can stand on its own feet without unnecessary comparisons.
- a3n 13y ago> What they (the mid-level HR people) did was immoral. Obviously. "Geshuri’s decision to “terminate within the hour” the recruiter was enthusiastically seconded by Google’s VP for Human Resources, Shona Brown ..." There's nothing mid-level about the VP of HR. She should have known this was illegal, certainly was responsible to know that it was illegal, and was responsible for either advising the company that it's illegal or leave the company.
- naturalethic 13y agoYou're conflating law and morality. To resurface Godwin again, if a soldier was fired for executing a jew you were trying to save by implementing a secret policy of breaking the law to save them, would that be immoral?