11 ms·
A note from near the bottom: For the benefit of readers who aren’t necessarily Go players, a four stone handicap means that black (the computer) was allowed to
by sp332 13y ago
A note from near the bottom:
For the benefit of readers who aren’t necessarily Go players, a four stone handicap means that black (the computer) was allowed to place four stones on the board before white (Ishida) made any moves. This may sound like a lot but, while it is a significant handicap, it’s not really as big as it sounds.
- awwducks 13y agoIn my estimation (I play go), beating Ishida Yoshio at 4 stones in a non-simul game [1] probably requires a player that's at least 4 dan amateur. [1] Professionals usually play amateurs simultaneous games. That is, 1 vs. many. The quality of play improves dramatically if they are playing a single game. In this case, a single game Ishida probably wanted to win.
- CocaKoala 13y agoyeah; there are some people in the comments suggesting that that Ishida might not be playing at the level of a top 9p right now, but this is still pretty significant and a very impressive feat.
- awwducks 13y agoYep. The difference between Ishida and a top pro today probably isn't more than 2 stones.
- hyperpape 13y agoEven that is probably high. I think any professional in the world could lose on 5 stones (c.f. http://www.computer-go.info/h-c/index.html http://www.computer-go.info/h-c/index.html).
- MichaelGG 13y agoI was under the impression that the difference between nearly all pros is 3 stones or less.
- hyperpape 13y agoProbably accurate for active professionals in the big three countries, and probably a bit generous. I doubt there are many professionals, if any, who need three stones against the best. In fact, top western amateurs might be competitive on three stones. There has been some compression of professional strength in the past 50 years, so there may be some older professionals who need that much. Additionally, there are players with professional ranks who no longer compete, or only compete in Western tournaments. They may need three stones.
- T-hawk 13y agoWould it be accurate to say those 4 stones are about equivalent to one pawn in chess? As a back-of-the-envelope calculation, one pawn is 1/43 of your starting material in chess if the king is included as a four-point fighting piece. Four stones in Go comes to 1/45 of your expected endgame material as half of a 19x19 board.
- visarga 13y agostrength difference between pro 1 dan and pro 9 dan is only about 2 stones
- CocaKoala 13y agoIt's hard to make a comparison like that because Go and Chess operate on fundamentally different models. Chess is about capturing a specific piece and putting your opponent in a position where they have no options but to lose; to that end, it's a war of attrition where players slowly lose resources until the game is over (note that I do not play chess at any significant level). In contrast, Go is about capturing territory by fencing it in. Placing four stones on the board is like placing four free fenceposts; you can't really call it a tangible resource like a pawn, but it gives you more of a structure and gives you some influence over the rest of the board. It's possible to remove resources from your opponent in go, since you can surround pieces and capture them. But it's not really an attrition thing like in chess; it's more about territory and control. Trying to make it a numbers game and saying "four stones is 1/45 of your expected endgame material" isn't really relevant to go, because the position of the stones matters so much more than the number. If you have four more pawns than your opponent in a game of chess, that's pretty clearly an advantage; if you have four stones in a totally useless area of the board, or four stones in a really useless configuration, then they're not helpful at all.
- gcp 13y agoIt's hard to make a comparison like that because Go and Chess operate on fundamentally different models It is very easy. The nature of the game is completely irrelevant. The question is what expectation of winning rate a 4 stone advantage gives to a Go player. For middle ranks, one stone is about 100 ELO-equivalent, or 64% winning rate. (I think it's closer at top dan ranks, would have to look up the statistics). 4 Stones is about 92% chance of winning between equal players. The equivalent in chess is slightly more than 4 pawns advantage, or about a minor piece.