3 ms·
The main concern, I think, is that if someone censors the official archive, everyone has their own copy of the censored posts to use to prove such. It's the sam
by derefr 13y ago
The main concern, I think, is that if someone censors the official archive, everyone has their own copy of the censored posts to use to prove such. It's the same sort of resilience you get from having local Git repositories, or from the Bitcoin block-chain. You don't get this from any message board I know of (although that's not fundamental to the definition of a message board.)
- tptacek 13y agoSure, but people who want to preserve a high-fidelity archive of a message board can do that too.
- f- 13y agoProbably, but in the end, it doesn't matter: there is a single, widely archived mailing list that almost everybody knows about. Outside the several mailing lists we have, there's nothing resembling a central repository of security research and industry gossip. It's possible that it all could be done better with a custom web forum, a VIP room on Chatroulette, or a well-designed UUCP dead-drop - but so far, despite many attempts, nobody really succeeded with that. Plus, F-D is awful mostly because it's a fairly accurate mirror of the security community itself (and certainly many of the web forums I have seen). More often than not, this is what makes the headlines - not a novel sandbox escape exploit that bypasses kSLR.
- oracuk 13y agoF-D was mostly awful because it was open. There are plenty of private security forums with a much higher signal to noise ratio. They perform slightly different functions and rely on a higher level of trust than an open mailing list can deliver but the security community is not uniformly awful.