9 ms·
This is the real shame in the Oculus acquisition. If Oculus had been able to give away just 10% equity, every single Kickstarter backer would be $20,000 richer
by modeless 13y ago
This is the real shame in the Oculus acquisition. If Oculus had been able to give away just 10% equity, every single Kickstarter backer would be $20,000 richer today. The sentiment would be completely different. The SEC needs to get in gear and start allowing equity crowdfunding pronto.
The SEC's classification of millionaires as "accredited investors" who get first crack at all the best investment opportunities is exactly the kind of "rich get richer" policy that people ought to be furious about. I think not enough people understand it.
- Phlarp 13y agoYea, all those early BFL investors are really rolling in their unregulated equity crowd funding cash these days.
- general_failure 13y agoKickstarter needs a no-acquisition clause
- martinald 13y agoI don't think that would work. It would seriously diminish the possibility of kickstarter-based companies ever raising crowd funded funding.
- anigbrowl 13y agoBut most people go to Kickstarter to fund the development of a particular product, not to boost the corporate entity that produces it. I mean, it's not that Kickstarter buyers are against people earning a living and making a profit, but something like 9 out of 10 Kickstarter projects are 'labor of love, we want to make it accessible to you as cheaply as possible,' as opposed to 'we want to build up a lot of buzz and then have a ginormous exit/IPO/get rich beyond your wildest dreams.'
- res0nat0r 13y agoSo why can't it be both? If you are against my product becoming a huge hit after getting off the ground first via kickstarter then moving on to bigger markets with a possible windfall for the creator, and a better product for everyone due to a large IPO, then it sounds more like jealousy than anything else.
- anigbrowl 13y agoPeople want to feel in close contact with a dev team and part of a special club. If OR had gone on to be a huge company in its own right I don't think that would bother people much, but by getting acquired many of the early backers end up feeling on the outside, the real 'special club' is the one where you need enormous amounts of money to be a member. Also, while it can be both very often in the real world it becomes one or the other - think of all the not-nice things that corporations o on the basis that their investors' needs come first. You're just going to have a harder time funding stuff if your pitch includes a non-ironic desire to make megabucks because a lot of people will be put off by that.
- sparkzilla 13y agoI think you mean it needs a "No acquisition by Facebook" clause.
- gojomo 13y agoIndeed, I don't see anywhere else that Americans accept a "wealth test" to exercise a basic economic right (ownership of production). Note, the accredited-investor rules are not an "ability-to-pay" test. That would be fair: if you can write the check, you're in. The rules also are not a creditworthiness test: they don't evaluate reliability, and investors want to give money, not take it from others. And they're not a competence test: you can be credentialed to professionally handle others' investments and businesses (through things like passing the bar or "Series 7" or CPA exams), or otherwise have degrees in law, technology, and business... and still not pass the same "accredited investor" wealth standard that any dolt who inherits a million dollars does, automatically. The distinction ought to be abolished as a matter of basic fairness.
- refurb 13y agoThe reason for the accredited-investor regulation was to prevent people from putting all of their wealth into risky investments they know nothing about and being left destitute. People on HN are pretty smart, but it's not representative of the entire population. People get scammed by ridiculously obvious scams. Do you really think they have the ability to invest in a start-up in an intelligent way?
- shiftpgdn 13y agoI know it's a bit of a libertarian viewpoint but it is not the government's job to be my nanny. If I wish to throw all of my money down the toilet on some hopeless start-up I should be allowed to do so.
- EpicEng 13y agoI would tend to agree in spirit but, of course, no one wants to throw their money away, they get tricked into doing so. Government does have an interest in the livelihood of its citizenry.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- alexqgb 13y agoKickstarter specifically prohibits equity deals with backers, as allowing them would place them in the crosshairs of the SEC. FYI.
- asdfologist 13y agoWow, you just missed the entire point of his post.
- alexqgb 13y agoActually, the dude (heavily) edited his original post after a bunch of people pointed out that he didn't know what he was talking about.
- asdfologist 13y agoOh I see. This highlights an interesting flaw in the HN edit functionality - it can make the child posts look stupid.
- alexqgb 13y agoYes, and moreso to people who are not, themselves, terribly careful readers. Savvier folks can read a string of knowledgable corrections to a point that (apparently) wasn't made then work out what must have happened easily enough.
- saraid216 13y agoIt's honestly frustrating to go down a well-commented post and see a half-dozen "the title is misleading" posts... and then finally one that actually quotes the old title, basically nullifying the validity of most of the discussions one just read.
- sroerick 13y agoCould you elaborate on this a little bit? I've never encountered this before.
- icpmacdo 13y agoIf a crowd funding website that was completely bitcoin based would it be able to avoid all SEC regulations? If there are regulations in the future is there a liability to creating this now?
- pmorici 13y agoNo, There used to be 3 difference BTC denominated securities exchanges, Havelock, BitFunder, and some other one I can remember the name of. They were mostly based out of Canada then some regulators forced two of them to close and Havelock moved to a country in central America to avoid the same fate.
- tim333 13y agoNo doesn't work like that. Raising funds is raising funds whether it's in us$, bitcoin, pork-belly futures or whatever. You could list in another country like on Seedrs in the UK and then presumably be subject to UK rather than US law. Although if most of the investors and assets were in the US the SEC might still try to stop it.
- anigbrowl 13y agoIt's better to address the problem directly (investor eligibility) rather than trying to invent technological end-runs around it, because the law is not deterministic and such technological instrumentalities are very transparent to regulators..
- loceng 13y agoWould they really have offered equity though? I don't know.
- yeukhon 13y agoI don't get the sentiment, those who feel they have been betrayed. First Oculus gave out the perks they promised to deliver, haven't they? That's the whole deal with backers. You back a project and you should receive the promised perk in return. Another way to look at backer is to think of them as your first set of customers. I don't see why Oculus should return equity even if KS allows them to do so. If the option was "give us $10,000 and you get 0.1% of the equity then would we still have this discussion. Obviously not. But the contract these backers signed up for was just the perk.
- ama729 13y ago> First Oculus gave out the perks they promised to deliver, haven't they? That's the whole deal with backers. You back a project and you should receive the promised perk in return. You don't back a project just to get the perks though most of the time, you back a project to support a company grow and thrive. IMO they clearly broke the social contract between them and the backers.
- yeukhon 13y agoI don't dispute they want the final product in the end. They agree with Oculus' vision so they back them up. But why are people feel upset? Two reasons: 1. Some people feel they are entitled to share the acquisition because without their early support (via KS crowdfunding) Oculus may never get that $2B acquisition, or/and 2. They dislike the acquisition and they feel entitled to have a voice. Like public trading companies shared holders should have a say in the company's direction and the company is responsible to maximize shareholders' profit Either one or combined. If the deal is clear from day one, which is that you, the backer, will only receive the perk as promised, and any penny you give to the project will be used to keep the project growing. But you don't have any say in the project, because, they never said they will let you be a shareholder. They are not going to discuss acquisition with you, because, this is a private company. Fan support is essential to keep a project like this growing. But business is business. If you think you are better off with some extra $$ in your pocket and getting a powerful parent looking after your project at the same time, you probably should take the acquisition.
- forrestthewoods 13y agoDon't be ridiculous. That's not how it works. Every dollar, and then some, needed to be spent on the headsets. Oculus wasn't going to give away 10% of the company in exchange for negative dollars. If the SEC does allow equity via crowdfunding you'd have to be relatively insane to take them up on the offer. It just doesn't make sense.
- tim333 13y agoI think a lot, probably most companies on Kickstarter would be ok giving 10% of equity to their backers if it was legal.
- pushrax 13y agoI don't understand your reasoning – the point of selling equity is to have more money available for immediate use. If they had followed this path, they might have raised even more capital.
- forrestthewoods 13y ago$300 doesn't get you a headset AND equity. You might take $300 from person A to manufacture a headset to sell to person B for $300. But person A doesn't get both.
- sgk284 13y agoIs there a fundamental reason why Person A can't get both? Equity costs nothing to give out (excluding legal / accounting overhead) and could serve as a great incentive. Effectively, a project would say "Hey! Give us $300 dollars. We might get you this product we're trying to build, but we also might fail at delivering. Here's some equity too, to help compensate for your risk."
- qq66 13y ago> Equity costs nothing to give out Only if your company isn't worth anything.
- clef 13y agoThis is a giant casino for people that have a lot of money they can afford to lose.
- GBond 13y agoThe real shame is not that the backers didn't a get a financial payout ('tho they should). The real shame is how Oculus' most passionate enthusiasts got burnt. They were in it for the shared vision but got a tough lesson in capitalism instead.
- crummy 13y agoWhat exactly did they lose?
- saraid216 13y agoFaith.
- rtpg 13y agowhat about the product they bought? I don't expect financial payout from a McDonald's franchisee because I bought some hamburgers from them.
- pushrax 13y agoThe $10 backers didn't receive anything other than a pat on the back.
- danielweber 13y agoWhich is what they were told they would get.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sc68cal 13y agoThis reminds me of the same arguments that were made about Bitcoin and exchanges and how the mean old SEC wasn't letting the little guy get in on the action. The same thing would happen in the world of Kickstarter - big asset bubbles and rampant speculation, bogus funding campaigns, graft, and exploitation.
- icelancer 13y ago>The same thing would happen in the world of Kickstarter - big asset bubbles and rampant speculation, bogus funding campaigns, graft, and exploitation. I see. So what do you call a roulette table with obviously addicted gamblers throwing their money away, then? Good old American fun?
- lmm 13y agoIf the gamblers are obviously addicted then I believe the casino is legally required not to serve them.
- icelancer 13y agoThey do not. Laws governing alcohol do not cover gambling. (And even so, alcoholics have no problem getting regular drinks at their bars of choice, anyway, with few - if any - legal issues.) Problem gamblers must self-exclude and the casinos then must do their best to adhere to these lists that the Nevada Gaming Commission sends out. (And casinos are very good, if not infallible, at doing this.) But the person must exclude his/herself.
- AUmrysh 13y agoKickstarter already has plenty of exploitative scam campaigns. I knew (I use the term loosely, more like I had to ban from a social group for being offensively rude to women) one of the guys that ran a successful kickstarter. He hasn't updated his project in months, and his last updates were about how he's only spent a small amount of the money, is looking for a new dev team, and wants to hire a web developer on the cheap. I knew it was a scam from the day I learned of it, just based on this guy's character and inexperience. I can assure you that equity would be no different, unless the investments could be protected by law in some way. I don't really know how to prevent this sort of thing, investors needs to do their homework, but even that's not always accurate.
- pavlov 13y agoHere's an illustrative example of just how arbitrary these regulations are... In USA, donation-based crowdfunding is legal but equity-based crowdfunding is not. In Finland, it's just the other way around: a company can sell equity to private individuals, but it can't take donations [0]. In both cases, the proponents of the laws claim that the average citizen is dumb and would be ripped off if these protective laws weren't in place. Yet somehow Finns are smart enough to invest into private companies whereas Americans aren't, and meanwhile Americans are smart enough to make their own decisions about donations whereas Finns aren't. Both of these laws are just historical accidents at this point. They made sense in an era where information was hard to acquire, but today you can just google a person's name to find out whether you want to invest in her project. Arbitrary limitations around crowdfunding should go. - - [0] More precisely, one needs a "collection license" from the police to take donations in Finland. This is only available to registered charities, so doing a Kickstarter is effectively illegal for Finnish companies and individuals.
- seventytwo 13y agoNot arguing with you here, but I just wanted to say that the point of this rule is to prevent people from getting scammed in large numbers. Allowing equity crowdfunding would also have to come with a bunch of new rules to prevent a company from claiming all sorts of fantastical stuff and then folding after everyone's pitched in. Just think how this would work - people can't even be bothered to read their ToS or Privacy Policy for Facebook. You think they're going to pour over an operating agreement to become an equity member for a company? This rule was enacted as a quick and simple way to prevent people from being fucked.