4 ms·
This is exactly why a sales tax would make things so much easier. Who care about historic price points of when you bought and sold BTC, let alone the historic e
by IgorPartola 13y ago
This is exactly why a sales tax would make things so much easier. Who care about historic price points of when you bought and sold BTC, let alone the historic electricity costs and pool fees when you mined it. You buy a milk shake, you pay taxes. Want food, etc. to be taxed differently? Still easier than figuring out if you are operating a railroad/fishing farm in Alaska while running a BTC mining rig to heat your house using sustainable energy from your newly installed solar panels.
- BrandonM 13y agoSales taxes are regressive, so much so that combined US state taxes are also regressive, being largely funded by sales tax. Refer to the big square in the middle of https://xkcd.com/980/ https://xkcd.com/980/
- humanrebar 13y agoSimple taxes is a justice issue. A simple tax code will always be more fair than an arcane one. If we're worried about the cost of living of people with incomes below a certain level, the best solution to that problem is a solution to that problem, such as an earned income tax credit, a guaranteed income, food stamps, health insurance supplements, and the like.
- sp332 13y agoThe trouble with a refund is maybe the person can't afford to pay (price of goods + taxes) in the first place. And it seems strange to collect sales tax, then redistribute the money as food stamps, to reduce the burden from the sales tax.
- humanrebar 13y agoYou could dispense an EIC on a paycheck-by-paycheck basis.
- tzs 13y agoAlmost none of the complexity of the tax code has anything at all to do with it being progressive. The progressiveness comes from the rate structure, which takes under a page to specify. Almost all of the complexity comes from dealing with what to tax, not how much to tax it.
- humanrebar 13y agoI agree and you misunderstand. I was saying that, as far as the tax code is concerned, complexity can be treated as orthogonal to progressivity. I also think that complexity is a justice issue since it favors those with inside knowledge, lobbyists, and the resources to have full-time tax specialists at the expense of everyone else. This second point is a big deal. It's why we see headlines about how multinationals are legally paying ridiculously low tax rates. It's a headline because it's not fair on its face, despite how legal it is.
- evjim 13y agoOr why not inflationary tax? We already have it, but if it was made the sole tax, we could get rid of whole bureaucratic industries for processing tax. Inflation encourages spending which is good for the economy.
- twoodfin 13y agoSo the U.S. government would fund itself just by printing money? If so, I don't think whoever had this idea has really thought it through.
- scotty79 13y agoIt's a good idea. The problem is only how it should be decided and by whom, how much to print. It can't be government for obvious reasons.
- twoodfin 13y agoHow could wages possibly keep up with the inflation that such a scheme would create? If they don't keep up, the government needs to print more money to provide more benefits to keep people from starving, and you have a pretty vicious circle.
- evjim 13y agoWe are already partially taxed by inflation. I think about 1% per year. Minimum wage should be matched to inflation and living costs. Obviously it could cycle out of control if the amount of money printed wasn't regulated. But it could be a decent method to cut no-value-add industries (IRS, accounting). Job mobility could be higher if you didn't have to file with the government every time you got hired. So the worker would have more leverage over the employer if they did not keep wages sufficient. Additionally, there are many untaxed workers right now that we would then be taxing if inflationary or single tax was used. Ex, waiters, other tipped jobs, sketchy corner store that only take cash, illegal immigrants who work under the table
- twoodfin 13y agoI am warily a supporter of a national sales tax to replace the income tax, but there are a few problems with it: - Making it non-regressive, let alone as close to progressive as our current system, is damned hard. FAIR Tax-style check-cutting probably isn't enough. - The tax would have to be high enough that black market sales would be extremely tempting. It's comparatively easier to monitor and regulate ~150 million workers, each with a small number of "tax events" per year, vs. hundreds of billions of taxable transactions. - A sales tax has the potential to be at least as complex and distorting as the income tax, and probably moreso. Politicians likely won't be able to resist the urge to make favored products cheaper (or cheaper for favored constituents), and the levers available will be much more direct, as you won't have to wait until April 15 to see, say, your electric car credit.
- iLoch 13y ago"Income tax? Sales tax? Why not both?" - Canadian government. sigh
- scintill76 13y agoThe US doesn't have federal sales tax, but many states do, so Americans have this too.
- VLM 13y ago"Making it non-regressive, let alone as close to progressive as our current system, is damned hard." Its not really important or difficult. The state I grew up in has a long list of poor people exemptions by industry. Everything in the grocery store except hot deli food is tax free, for example. Tuition, medical care, bunch of other poor people things all tax free... As a poor person the only taxes you'll likely ever pay are the 100% or so gasoline sin tax and sales tax on a car. 5% depreciation on a new car is a fraction of driving it off the lot, and for used, especially for poor people, there's a wink and nod that if you're not involving a bank just don't submit anything completely ridiculous, and they don't enforce sales tax at all on family sales because they know we'd just avoid it via gift tax if they cracked down and other than divorce situations you'll never get family members testifying against each other. Its important to keep the tax rate reasonably low compared to the "real world poor folks" inflation rate (not the made up one). Another way to think about it, is I live in a civilized (non-california) area and our cost of living is much lower. So you can express our 5% sales tax as living about 18 months in the future, or as living about 1/20th more like Californians. Its just not a big deal. Now if you want a euro style 50% then the big problem isn't so much the poor as all the people trying to evade that kind of tax rate. We already have plenty of problems with petroleum fuels and tobacco products, imagine those kind of problems with "everything".