5 ms·
"Under the ruling, purchasing a $2 cup of coffee with Bitcoins bought for $1 would trigger $1 in capital gains for the coffee drinker and $2 of income for the c
by uptown 13y ago
"Under the ruling, purchasing a $2 cup of coffee with Bitcoins bought for $1 would trigger $1 in capital gains for the coffee drinker and $2 of income for the coffee shop."
So if the coffee shop leaves the "property" as bitcoins instead of converting it over to dollars, and the value of those bitcoins falls before cashing-out, they're stuck paying tax on the $2 worth of income despite potentially no-longer having the funds to cover those taxes.
- JonFish85 13y agoWelcome to the tax world! This is true of a lot of things.
- endersshadow 13y agoWell, capital gains would be a different set of taxes, but this is essentially how other currencies work, as well. If you earn income, you earn it at the exchange rate at that time--even if the exchange rate takes a dive in the future.
- jstalin 13y agoMy initial thought is that they'd be able to deduct the loss since the bitcoin is being treated as property and not currency. The trade of property for property is done at market value and any subsequent trade is as well, leading to a loss.
- andylei 13y agobut then the coffee shop gets to claim some tax credits for their negative capital gains
- candybar 13y agoNo, if they take a loss on the bitcoin when they sell it, they can deduct that loss from their income.
- dragontamer 13y agoYes, although they sell the BTC as capital loss with carryover to the next year if you hit the cap. http://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/capital-loss-carryover.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/capital-loss-carryover.a... Declaring them as "property" is the simplest solution. Everyone who has worked with Stocks knows exactly how the tax system works in these cases.
- patio11 13y agoThis is not an anomalous case in taxing business income. A few startups asked me to do work on a barter basis. (Can you do a week of marketing work for us if we build you an iPhone app?) I told them that, if I were to agree to do that, I'd be legally obligated to value my work at it's market price and file an informational return to the IRS showing that amount of money given as payment for services rendered, which they'd be taxed on exactly as if I had paid them the equivalent sum in cash. (i.e. They'd pay thousands out of pocket despite never receiving a cent.)
- phogster 13y agoWait, are both parties responsible for paying taxes in this case? In the normal case the party receiving payment for services rendered is the one that pays income taxes. Here both are providing and receiving a service at the same time.
- bduerst 13y agoIt's more complex than that because both parties have to report the dollar amounts of the goods/services in the barter exchange. Whoever comes out on top has to report income, and whoever comes out on bottom has to report the expense.
- mattm 13y agoAssuming the barter trade was even, the income and expense would cancel out thereby no taxes would be owed.
- bduerst 13y agoIn barter exchanges, this is almost never the case, and is more suspicious when reported as such.
- logfromblammo 13y agoThe whole point of barter is that the stuff traded by each side has roughly equivalent value to the traders. Seems like the tax rules outlaw pure barter and make you use dollars in your transaction whether you want to or not.
- amalcon 13y agoIn general, the coffee shop is doing that anyway.
- thrownaway2424 13y agoIf a coffee shop is accepting bitcoins in exchange for coffee, they are already exposed to the FX risk that bitcoins will fall in dollar terms before they can be liquidated. In other news, the number of coffee shops which accept bitcoins is indistinguishable from zero in practice.
- junto 13y agoThis is an important point. If bitcoin had been used more as a currency, rather than investment speculation, the bitcoin community would have a much stronger case to argue that it is a currency. It probably wouldn't have changed the IRS decision since this is the first regulatory post warning shot, but bit coiners only have themselves to blame. It needs to be perceived by the outside world as a currency and not like a ponzi scheme that is full of thieves and brigands, because like it or not, that appears to be the general public's and the medias opinion to date.