3 ms·
Its an interesting choice of battlegrounds. I find the infrastructure vs infrastructure wars fascinating by how Google and Amazon invested in them for their own
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
Its an interesting choice of battlegrounds. I find the infrastructure vs infrastructure wars fascinating by how Google and Amazon invested in them for their own businesses and are now productizing the 'remainders' and getting less and less for it.
- lsc 13y ago>Google and Amazon invested in them for their own businesses and are now productizing the 'remainders' and getting less and less for it. Are the prices dropping faster than moore's law? The costs are dropping approximately with moore's law. Edit: the interesting bit here is just how you lower your prices. In the VPS market, it is traditional to keep charging your customers the same, and to just give them more ram/cpu/disk/network. This is way easier on the bottom line, as your revenue doesn't fall (by much. Most people won't bother changing to a smaller plan, some will.) - in the "cloud" the tradition is a bit more consumer-friendly; the tradition is to just cut the price and hope the consumer will buy more.
- debacle 13y agoMoore's law doesn't say shit about storage.
- lsc 13y ago>Moore's law doesn't say shit about storage. Yes, the cost progression of storage is expressed by Kryder's law, and is actually faster than moore's law. (well, in terms of storage space, not storage speed.) Of course, both are observations and not true laws; things will get interesting if/when the capital and power required per unit compute (or per unit ram or storage) stops dropping. But, my point is that in the past, the costs involved in providing compute infrastructure has fallen dramatically over time, and most people expect this to continue, at least for a while.
- voellm 13y agoCheck out Kryder's Law for Storage: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Kryder http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Kryder
- gwern 13y ago> Yes, the cost progression of storage is expressed by Kryder's law, and is actually faster than moore's law. (well, in terms of storage space, not storage speed.) In theory, not necessarily in practice. The Thai floods caused a multi-year pause in Kryder's law we're still recovering from. (I'm not sure how robust Kryder's law is - there's a lot less data and analysis of it than Moore's, since that's the famous one.)
- jedberg 13y ago> Google and Amazon invested in them for their own businesses and are now productizing the 'remainders' This is a myth. Both companies created their infrastructure businesses as separate entities by leveraging their datacenter expertise, but they were not 'remainders'.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoVery interesting, this doesn't match my experience, can you say more about how you reason to the claim that Google created a separate 'infrastructure business entity' ?
- SpikeGronim 13y agoI am an ex-AWS employee. I can verify that AWS was founded as a new line of business using new servers purchased for AWS. The idea that AWS was started using Amazon's spare capacity is widely repeated but false. Amazon is definitely leveraging their expertise and not their physical machines. Source: I've seen the original pitch deck for Amazon S3.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- cperciva 13y agoAWS may not have used Amazon's spare hardware, but it certainly used Amazon's spare code.
- jsnell 13y agoIsn't it just common sense? The provisioning / capacity planning for a DC has to be done based on peak usage. The usage patterns of the core business and the hosted customers are almost certainly going to be the same -- there's going to be a trough in the night-time, and a peak in the evening. At the time when people want to buy resources, you'll have no spare resources to sell. The only way the business model of selling spare resources could work is if you found customers with a different usage pattern to fill the trough. That's hard. Yes, you can find some customers with time-insensitive batch processing that could be done during the night time. But Google and Amazon already do massive amounts of batch processing, and still won't have a flat utilization level over the day. Or alternatively you could try to flatten out the diurnal variations by making sure there's no geographic affinity between users and the DCs. But that's suboptimal given intercontinental network latencies.