3 ms·
Ask HN: Should high school gifted programs be banned?
Have you gone through such a program? Do you regret it?
Sure it's nice to have smart peers, but putting a huge amount of effort into such a program is a huge waste of time that is better spent on startups.
Moreover, such programs increase the probability that you would pursue a career in academia, which generally leads to failure for the vast majority of people.
Even picking a university major is an issue when certain fields such as mathematics are considered more respectable than others such as CS in such programs.
Finally, the possibility of not even going to university is certainly not encouraged in such programs.
- TallGuyShort 17y ago>> Have you gone through such a program? Yes >> Do you regret it? Very much so. My middle school was a small charter school, with about 60 kids in each grade, and 2 classes going on at any one time. One day out of the blue they announced that some students had been selected to participate in some gifted classes. I was selected for all 3, and at first I felt honored. But only 5 kids had been picked, and each gifted class had at most, 3 kids in it. Obviously I was isolated from all my friends, and strongly disliked by all the rest. I learnt nothing from the class (other than how to take a beating) and would have to call it the most miserable year of my life. edit: Oh, and the school also required that I complete all the homework from my regular classes, even though I wasn't attending the class and doing additional work. I think I failed most of that year. Real 'gifted'. So all in all, I'd consider that particular program a failure, and I'd be surprised if most other programs didn't have similar consequences. The school neglected the fact that sociality is part of an education. I felt at a disadvantage when I got to high school, and didn't know the kids my age any more. They thought I was a weirdo, and I actually felt less prepared for some classes than they did. I had missed a full year of social development.
- dmix 17y agoInteresting, I got near perfect on some provincial exam in elementary school and was about to go into a gifted course but fell short on the pre-screening test. I always regretted not having that opportunity because normal school always bored me. Maybe it wasn't such a bad thing. Also, I strong disagree that they shouldn't exist. Only that they not consist of social isolation and 3 person class rooms.
- spooneybarger 17y agoNumber of wtf questions: "putting a huge amount of effort into such a program is a huge waste of time that is better spent on startups." what startups would those be? tech startups? how about the gift kids who couldn't care less about tech? maybe they just want to become authors? who knows. startups? "Moreover, such programs increase the probability that you would pursue a career in academia, which generally leads to failure for the vast majority of people." define failure. failure to get into academia? misery at getting into academia? "Even picking a university major is an issue when certain fields such as mathematics are considered more respectable than others such as CS in such programs." what does a university major have to do with a gifted program in a high school? "Finally, the possibility of not even going to university is certainly not encouraged in such programs." other than vocational tech programs, where exactly is not going to university encouraged? -- how about this, lets say you take away they gifted and talented program and put them back in standard college prep course work. how many did you think will get bored beyond belief by not being challenged? how well are they going to do? shouldn't you teach to level of each individual student rather than as a faceless homogenous mass?
- amichail 17y agowhat startups would those be? tech startups? how about the gift kids who couldn't care less about tech? maybe they just want to become authors? who knows. startups? They can write novels. It's hard to do that while competing with bright peers in a gifted program. define failure. failure to get into academia? misery at getting into academia? Not enjoying grad school. Getting a job at a mostly teaching college afterward. Teaching uninteresting courses. Teaching the same courses over and over again. Not having much time to do research. Getting your grant proposals/papers rejected. Not finding bright students to do research with. what does a university major have to do with a gifted program in a high school? If your teachers in a gifted program look down on computing as a career, that certainly isn't encouraging. other than vocational tech programs, where exactly is not going to university encouraged? Gifted students are expected to get into top universities. The pressure to pursue a university education is very strong in a gifted program.
- spooneybarger 17y ago
- timwiseman 17y agoA properly handled honors/gifted/advanced high school course can be a great benefit. You seem to assume that those who would be in such a program want to start a startup. Most people simply do not want to do that at all. Startup founders are a very small percentage of the population, and while it is growing it is likely to remain very small (and successful startup founders are a relatively small percentage of startup founders at that....) Even for those that do, few of them do or should have started work on the startup during high school. As to academia, there is certainly a correlation with people in those programs and people that go into academia, but I think the causal connection is relatively weak. And if they want to go into academia, that is not a bad thing. It is not a path I would choose, but it is not bad for many. As for your point about picking a major, I do not know about all programs, but the one I was in certainly did not discriminate against any majors. Even if it did, that would be a force easily resisted as soon as you left that program and went into an actual college. And for that matter, many people change majors at least once (went through 3). As a whole, they are beneficial to their students.
- amichail 17y agoYou seem to assume that those who would be in such a program want to start a startup. A large number of people would like to make money on their own. Just look at the number of apps in the app store for example. Even for those that do, few of them do or should have started work on the startup during high school. Why would you say that? The brain is sufficiently developed at that point to create interesting products/services -- especially with gifted students.
- timwiseman 17y agoA large number of people would like to make money on their own. Just look at the number of apps in the app store for example. True, but putting out an app or two or doing a little consulting on the side is a far cry from starting a starting or being able to support yourself that way. I suspect that the number of people who do support themselves without a traditional employer will grow, but that will remain a small percentage (though slightly larger) for a very long time if not forever. Why would you say that? The brain is sufficiently developed at that point to create interesting products/services -- especially with gifted students. I agree, in fact I said something similar in my other response. But, again that is a far cry from starting a start up. There are two main reasons I think starting a startup during high school is a bad idea for most people: 1. Your inability to enter into a legally binding contract will limit your dealings with investors or any type of customer that require an ongoing relationship. 2. While I know some exceptions exist, most people have neither the technical nor people skills to start a company as a teenager. Even those that will wind up being mostly self taught require time to do it, and they simply have not had it yet. Again, I know there are exceptions, but they are few. After high school, those start to change. 1 changes instantly for legal reasons when you hit 18. 2 falls on more of a bell curve, but it will gradually start moving towards the tipping point sometime around then for a lot of people.
- tokenadult 17y agoAnother crazy question. The short answer is, no, I wouldn't want any kind of specialized program DESIRED BY LEARNERS AND THEIR PARENTS to be banned, unless there was irrefutable evidence that the program was actively harmful. (And if we are going to ban something for being harmful, let's start by banning the way that mathematics is taught in elementary school in most schools in the United States.) http://www.ams.org/notices/200502/fea-kenschaft.pdf http://www.ams.org/notices/200502/fea-kenschaft.pdf http://www.aft.org/pubs-reports/american_educator/fall99/amed1.pdf http://www.aft.org/pubs-reports/american_educator/fall99/ame... http://math.berkeley.edu/~wu/Skywalkertalk.pdf http://math.berkeley.edu/~wu/Skywalkertalk.pdf I know of some worthwhile secondary school gifted programs, such as the Thomas Jefferson High School of Science and Technology http://www.tjhsst.edu/ http://www.tjhsst.edu/ or the Montgomery Blair High School Science, Mathematics, Computer Science Magnet http://www.mbhs.edu/departments/magnet/ http://www.mbhs.edu/departments/magnet/ or the Davidson Academy of Nevada http://www.davidsonacademy.unr.edu/ http://www.davidsonacademy.unr.edu/ and those school programs serve the needs of some learners who don't find their needs well met by conventional school programs. Some of the alumni of the better secondary schools for gifted students end up being start-up founders, and that is great. I didn't go through any such program. I wish I would have. No such program exists in my state, so I have sought a distance learning program http://epgy.stanford.edu/ohs/index.html http://epgy.stanford.edu/ohs/index.html for my oldest son, which has its own set of trade-offs. Like I did, I think he will enjoy being off to college and nearer to more intellectual peers more of the time.
- amichail 17y agoThe short answer is, no, I wouldn't want any kind of specialized program DESIRED BY LEARNERS AND THEIR PARENTS to be banned, unless there was irrefutable evidence that the program was actively harmful. (And if we are going to ban something for being harmful, let's start by banning the way that mathematics is taught in elementary school in most schools in the United States.) The harm done is that students are wasting a huge amount of time that they could have spent on a startup. There is nothing better than being able to make money on your own and gaining financial independence. Brain power and energy decline with age after your mid-twenties. So pursuing a startup later becomes more difficult.
- Senethior459 17y agoamichail: You posted a link to this on AskReddit, but not a link to AskReddit on this. If anyone wants to read the responses over there: http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/989zz/should_high_school_gifted_programs_be_banned/ http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/989zz/should_high...
- srn 17y agoThis is a troll, right? FYI not everyone who's smart wants to do computer science or a startup. I went to a gifted boarding school and it is my best educational experience so far including college. http://lsmsa.edu/ http://lsmsa.edu/ You have to apply to the school to get in. Yeah you didn't go if you don't want to go to college. That's OK, then don't go. I took java, numerical methods, operating systems, intro to graphics, visual basic. And fencing. Unfortunately their CS class offerings are not as awesome as before.